Netchaïev est de retour (1991) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Jacques Deray still at his best
searchanddestroy-11 February 2014
Warning: Spoilers
I really like this movie, made by the famous french director Jacques Deray, who was not at his best with LE MARGINAL and LE SOLITAIRE, both starring Jean Paul Belmondo. Here, Yves Montand is poignant in his character, even if we can argue that movie is a bit hard to tell, a bit complex to get. It reminds me ENGRENAGES TV show. Lindon gives also an interesting performance.

Just one thing I would like to add, concerning the comment made by the other user, the very nice guy Du Monteil. DST - now named DCRI - was in charge, as the Renseignements Généraux, of internal terrorist affairs, a sort of equivalent of British MI5, Scotland Yard Special Branch - that doesn't exist anymore, and FBI, but certainly not CIA,, as Dumonteil told. Because FBI is also in charge of INSIDE THE US terrorist affairs, and not only crime and other gangster files. CIA, on the contrary, is in charge of OUT US TERRITORY affairs, the equivalent of french DGSE, British MI6 or Israeli MOSSAD.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Forgotten Gem.
hsequeira774 October 2022
Directed by the late Jacques Deray, this forgotten movie is up there with the director's best work. Maybe not in the same league with "La Piscine" and "Flic Story", but on the same level with one of my favorites, "Trois Hommes Abattre".

The movie was a flop when it came out because dealing with terrorism it coincided with a string of terrorist attacks in France and because the french crime thriller ("le polar") was becoming out of fashion. But it's a great film with a superb performance by the wonderful Yves Montand, one of is last.

There is only a french DVD without any subtitles and it's very hard to find online. Hope some day it'll came out on BLU Ray.

A forgotten gem. One of the last great "polars".
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Back with a vengeance
dbdumonteil3 June 2012
This is Yves Montand's next-to -last film and it is a muddled affair:based on a Jorge Semprun novel,the movie is a hotchpotch ,a dreadfully boring story :Yves Montand is at the head of the DST (=MI5 -brit- =CIA -US-)and he has got big problems with his son (Vincent Lindon)who was once a revolutionary (shades of May 68 )and now tries to redeem himself by thwarting the terrorists' ominous plans;his former mates (including Miou-Miou) have become notables and some feel nostalgic for the years when they fought against the establishment. (that always wins in the end,as everybody knows).

Vincent Lindon ,wearing glasses,gives a wooden performance ,and it is obvious he is much better today:he is deeply moving in "welcome" for instance.Montand does not seem to care much for his prodigal son.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed