Filthy Guy (1972) User Reviews

My opinion and I added some other comments.

[[e-mail] · 6/10 · 22 September 2003]

I thought it was a good old-school kung fu movie, but I expected a little bit more from Sammo Hung. I agree with the other comment I read, that the part with the cows was the best and original. I've never seen anything like it. I also liked that Shih Tien watched everybody's head to find out if it was Dirty Su. I did not like a lot of jokes, I also think that Yueh Hua (I'm not sure) who played the right hand of Shih Tien is not funny at all. And also the way it was dubbed into English was terrible.

For "scientific" purposes only

[ckormos1 · 6/10 · 20 March 2016]

I feel more like an archaeologist examining the remains of an ancient city rather than a movie reviewer. Only a VHS pan and scan with English dubbing converted to a digital file is left of this original film creation. That means as much as a third of the movie is missing from the sides and the dialog is at best 60% correct in the translation. Also the resolution only captures about 20% of the original film quality. Realistically the only person watching this movie almost 40 years after it was filmed would be a hard core Sammo Hung fan looking to view every movie the man ever made. I am one of those people. My review has little to add to the obvious. Dean ,Carter, and Sammo collaborated to make some of the best movies of the genre but this is not one of those. Why? I think mostly because the filthy head gag is funny at most two or three times and cannot possibly make up for the otherwise lack of comedy. Outside of that not every movie can be your best. This is simply slightly below average stuff when compared to everything else released in a very prolific year for martial arts movies.

Like the early Jackie Chan movies made during this time period are not that good

[jordondave-28085 · 4/10 · 11 May 2023]

(1978) The Return Of The Rivals- Filthy Guy/ Filthy Guy DUBBED MARTIAL ARTS PERIOD PIECE

As a fan of Hong Kong veteran actor Samo Hung, this early effort by him is not a very good one both in terms of comedy as well as the fights. Like Jackie Chan, they have to be in many mediocre martial art movies until they were able to do their own. The set up has Samo as nicknamed Filthy guy because of his dirty unwashed head which is as hard as a rock gets himself chased and been ordered to be killed because heès abetter martial artist than the Carter Wong character, whose another actor of many chop-socky movies made in the 1970s. He then sends out his army to go after him. Meanwhile, theirs also another story involving a sheriff and two girls. And this is also another one of those chop socky films which some good person have to get killed since it was the thing producers wanted.

Only for die-hard Sammo Hung fans

[planktonrules · 2/10 · 12 May 2007]

This film stars Sammo Hung, an actor and director you might be familiar with, though he isn't a household name. A few years ago, he played the fat cop on the silly TV show "Martial Law". At this point in his long career, he was so obese that many of his stunts seemed to be done by stunt men. However, earlier in his career, he directed many of Jackie Chan's films and made a few of his own. Even in his younger days, he was pretty chunky and far from the typical martial arts hero image. However, with his extensive training as a Chinese acrobat, he was surprisingly light on his feet and could do some interesting tricks in his films. The problem in this particular one is that the movie was supposed to be funny but I never found myself laughing, as the jokes were very broad and the film just bored me to tears. Cheap and forgettable--this isn't one of Sammo's better films (unless you want to see him smashing clay pots over his head--there's a LOT of this in the film).

Oh, and lest I forget, the version I saw was the English dubbed one. The dubbing was just awful and the accents sounded a lot like Eric Idle and a lot of working class Englishmen--not the sort of accents you'd expect for this movie and they sounded pretty lame.

Worst Sammo Hung chop-socky

[winner55 · 2/10 · 16 July 2006]

This is the worst of the Sammo Hung films of the old-school chop-socky 'fu film era that I've yet seen. Hung is burdened with an ugly wig - a wig conventional to Cantonese comedy, it indicates that the character never washes his hair. This would be mere annoyance, except that the wig is actually the whole point of the movie! Hung is even made to use it as a weapon in hand-to-hand combat! Hung did not write, direct, or even choreograph this mess. The film is clear indication that the chop-socky film producers had not the slightest idea of what to do with the new generation of 'fu stars showing up in the period 1978-1980. Obviously, knowing Hung was beginning to earn a reputation for comedy, the producer decided to hire him for what the producer obviously thought was a funny script. The humor is so low, you can scrape it off your shoe. Hung mugs like the village idiot. This is a far cry from the sophisticated comedy Hung himself writes and directs. And the kung-fu? well, if the dirt on the top of a guy's head counts as a weapon, what sort of fighting can one expect from this? The surviving English-dub video of this film is the worst pan-and-scan job I've seen in a long time, and the dubbing ridiculous.

Remember that Hung had already directed the far more polished Iron Fisted Monk by the time he made this film. Clearly he's just picking up a few bucks as quickly as possible. Wish I had known him back then, I'd have paid him not to make the movie! The two stars is for the performance of Carter Wong as the bad-guy of the pic.

A thankfully forgotten kung fu comedy

[Leofwine_draca · 3/10 · 12 October 2016]

THE FILTHY GUY is an early vehicle for a pre-fame Sammo Hung, made years before he hit the big time by appearing in the likes of KNOCKABOUT and MAGNIFICENT BUTCHER, films which hold up to this day. Sadly, this film has more in common with the low rent nonsense that Jackie Chan churned out before he achieved fame with Lo Wei and then DRUNKEN MASTER; it's amateurish and largely unfunny.

Time has not been kind to THE FILTHY GUY. The plot is one note and poor Sammo plays an extremely dumb character with a filthy head of hair. The only interesting thing is that he's involved in the kind of gruelling training sequences that Jackie would later utilise extensively in the likes of DRUNKEN MASTER and SNAKE IN THE EAGLE'S SHADOW; I never realised Sammo got there first. However, the fight scenes, which are few and far between, are largely lacklustre for those of us who know what the big guy is made of.

The film boasts supporting parts for Carter Wong as the villain of the piece and Yueh Hua as his right-hand man. There's the usual dumb comedy involving cross-dressing and animals, but it all largely ambles past without engaging the viewer at all. THE FILTHY GUY also boasts a notably bad dubbing job with some of the most grating accents ever. I'd skip it.

One of my personal favorites starring Sammo.

[rudeboy8080 · 18 April 2001]

This is one of my personal favorite martial arts films starring Sammo. Aside from some stabbings, this is a very light-hearted movie. Sammo Hung portrays an orphan who helps rebels fight against an evil and incompetent emperor. As usual, Sammo doesn't act like a macho fighter, but rather a goofy character wearing a filthy wig while showing off his martial arts skills. The talented Shih Tien co-stars, but is reduced to a whipping boy for the other characters to mistreat. One of the best gags in the film is where an army of cows rescues Sammo and his friends when they're being attacked by imperial troops.

A very entertaining martial arts-comedy. I highly recommend it.

Not bad but hardly his best

[phillip-58 · 4/10 · 4 September 2007]

Definitely not one of Sammo Hung's best films but not bad. It was directed by Kim Yung. Although not credited Sammo probably had a hand in the fight choreography which is well done, especially against Carter Wong. The plot is preposterous but a few points like the use of the cattle are original. It is also the only film I can remember where Sammo (suffering from some strange head mange, never explained) goes through a training sequence. Although the film is called Filthy, in the film he is always called 'Dirty Guy'. The females pretending to be men, a common kung fu plot device, is laughable here as the two female leads are gorgeous. But one does tend out to be more than she pretends to be, leading to a good fight with Sammo. Carter Wong is no great actor but can fight well. There are many well known character actors but Dean Shek Tin is under-used. Worth watching but keep the hand on the fast-forward.