The Fog (1964) Poster

(1964)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Hemant Da presents the Indian Rebecca
Rebecca is a classic mystery penned by Daphne du Maurier in 1938, which was adapted for celluloid by Alfred Hitchcock in 1940. The lady in the title role is already dead in the story but she, through her memories, the references to her in people's talks and her belongings left behind, continues to haunt the life of the new wife of her husband. It's a great psychological mystery whose climax was changed in the movie by the director, Alfred Hitchcock to suit the mentality of the American audience those days.

The great singer-musician of Indian cinema, Hemant Kumar adapted this story for a Hindi movie - Kohra (mist) in 1964, taking Biswajeet in the male lead, i.e., as the dead woman's husband and Waheeda Rehman in the central role of the hero's wife. Interestingly, despite the story revolving around the memories of the dead lady (called Poonam in the movie), the director has not shown her face despite several flash backs. He has allowed the audience to see either her body starting from the neck (in the front pose) or see herself from the back side. And that's the reason, I don't know which actress played this character who is the soul of the story.

In this Indianized version of Rebecca, widower Raja Amit Kumar Singh (Biswajeet) marries Rajeshwari (Waheeda Rehman) who enters his mansion with a lot of hope for her joyful future only to be stunned by the high-handed attitude of Daai Maa (Lalita Pawar) who looks upon her derogatorily and always compares her with Poonam, the deceased wife of her husband. By misguiding her to wear the attires of Poonam and imitating her mannerisms, Daai Maa brings about a rift in her relationship with her husband too. But one fine morning, the dead body of Poonam is found and Raja Amit Kumar Singh is arrested under the charge of her murder. Gradually the inner secrets of Poonam's life come to the fore. The ultimate truth is revealed in the climax taking place in the court-room.

Director Biren Naag has quite skilfully adapted the classic story of Rebecca for this Indianized story and changed the climax once again (firstly it was changed by Alfred Hitchcock in the Hollywood movie - Rebecca) which suits the taste of the Indian audience. The drama takes some time to pick-up but it is quite speedy in the later part and keeps the audience spellbound.

Gorgeous and talented Waheeda Rehman is the main attraction of this black and white movie. She impresses in all kinds of scenes - romantic, emotional and painful. Biswajeet is okay in the male lead. The supporting cast has done its part well. However the best performer is definitely Lalita Pawar in the role of Daai Maa (a role akin to the role of Mrs. Danvers in Rebecca). It is definitely one of her best performances. I will be highly grateful if somebody can tell me the name of the actress who played the role of Poonam (or Rebecca if we refer to the original story) because her face is never revealed in the movie.

Music is, in fact, the biggest strength of this classic suspense-thriller. Producer of this movie, Hemant Kumar has composed as well as sung the songs which include gems like - Ye Nayan Dare Dare and Raah Bani Khud Manzil. The movie contains Lata's classic songs like - Jhoom Jhoom Dhalti Raat and O Beqaraar Dil as well. Asha-Mahendra Kapoor duet - Kaahe Bajaai Tune is also in this movie. The beautiful lyrics have been dropped by the pen of Kaifi Aazmi.

Cinematography, art-direction, editing and production value aspects of this black and white movie are all up to the mark. The movie proves to be a memorable experience for the viewer after it is over.

Those who have not read (or seen) Rebecca, should not miss this classic Bollywood mystery. However, those who have read the novel or seen the Hollywood movie, will also find it quite engrossing and entertaining. And it's a very big treat for the fans of Waheeda.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A total rip-off of Hitchcock's Rebecca (1940)
aktech1 July 2006
But having said that - the cast here does a wonderful job of remaking the atmosphere that makes "Rebecca" an awesome movie. Waheeda Rehman is convincing as a newly-wed bride driven paranoid by the housekeeper (Lalita Pawar) and the mysterious specter of her husband's first wife...a thriller faithfully remade for the Hindi-speaking audience.

The overall cinematography is quite good. Most of the songs serve no purpose except for "Jhoom Jhoom..." which sounds quite appropriate as the recurring theme for the mysterious events occurring in the film. Lalita Pawar does an excellent job as the menacing housekeeper (Dai Maa) and is genuinely scary.

Biswajeet is the only weak point of the movie - but his role is existent for cosmetic purposes only - so much cannot be expected from him.

Overall, a good movie - but do not watch it at night!
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Spooky thriller with great music
csn_6120 August 2011
Warning: Spoilers
I saw it on the DVD of Mosderbaer…

The Movie is great and works well with the Gothic ambiance, lovely photography and great music by Hemant da. Waheeda simply rocks as well…

But it left some loose ends after the Court punished the culprit who confessed… What happened to all the special effects which indicated her 'bhatakti atma' ( wandering restless spirit ) of Poonam, the first wife? All the rippling curtains, banging doors and rocking chairs, and white apparition which torments Waheeda? Did 'it' go away after 'hearing. the court verdict? or was it just her hallucination? Can they live happily ever after in the same Havel, just 'thinking' that spirit has finally gone away for good? If he Director means 'No explanation, just have fun', then its is mindless entertainment, isn't it? This kind of loose ends were plenty in another famous spooky thriller by Raj Khosla too–'Woh Kaun Thi'?
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed