Samson (1961) Poster

(1961)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Jews in Poland
hof-419 November 2021
The Golden Age of Polish cinema began shortly after WWII and did not ebb until four decades later. From its many outstanding directors, Andrzej Wajda was the best known outside Poland. I remember vividly the impact that A Generation (1955), Kanal (1957) and especially Ashes and Diamonds (1958) had when released in Buenos Aires in the late fifties. Given Wajda's curriculum in 1961, I thought Samson would merit a view. It does, but it is not an entirely satisfactory film.

The story is (obviously) a retelling of the legend of Samson and Delilah, with Nazis as Philistines. The scenario is Warsaw shortly before and during WWII, and Samson is Jakub Gold, a young Jewish resident of Warsaw ready to begin his studies at the Polytechnic University. He lands in jail and gains freedom only when the jail is damaged by German bombing at the opening of the war. After, he leads a precarious existence both inside and outside the Warsaw Ghetto, his survival depending on the goodwill and courage of strangers (few and far between).

The movie suffers from a heavy-handed effort to convey symbolic messages and to conform the action to the legend, which also makes the plot somewhat predictable at times. Also, key scenes are not given enough relief. There are positives, however; gritty, harsh black and white cinematography fits the tale, music is used sparingly and effectively and acting is excellent all around. Last, but not least there are a few history lessons. The chilly, sinister initial scenes in the Polytechnic show that violence against Jews in interwar Poland was not limited to the uneducated, and tolerated by the authorities. It also shows the appalling conditions in the Warsaw ghetto during the war, a topic which was not as well known in 1961 as it is today.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A fair effort from Wajda about the Holocaust
adamwarlock24 August 2018
We follow a Jewish man in Warsaw just before and during WW2. He is jailed before the war for defending himself from an anti-semetic mob. The prisoners all escape as Warsaw is about to fall to the Germans. Then, he's in the ghetto, escapes and hides throughout the city. He wishes to return to the ghetto to share his people's fate rather than hide. He doesn't have the physical strength of his Biblical namesake but emotional strength. The film has kind of an unconvincing climax, needed a better fake explosion. Overall a good effort but not a home run for poland's greatest director.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Pretty good.
pazdziernik13 February 2005
Warning: Spoilers
We saw the 1961 film "Samson" by Andrzej Wajda on Saturday. This was a black and white movie in Polish with English subtitles. There were a few instances in which the dialog did not have subtitles. This was limited to a few lines here and there. This movie was set in Warsaw and the Warsaw ghetto during World War II. It was much like "The Pianist" by Roman Polanski (2002). The lead actor even looked like Wladyslaw Szpilman (Adrien Brody) of "The Pianist."

"Samson" is the story of a Jew, Jakub Gold (Serge Merlin), at the polytechnic university in Warsaw imprisoned and sentenced to 10 years for accidentally killing his friend in German- occupied Poland. In prison he makes several contacts that will factor later in the movie. The prisoners are released when Warsaw is bombed. Jakub is sent to the Warsaw ghetto where the Jews are "doomed to death for the crime of existence" and is assigned to picking up corpses from the streets and helping to provide them with a Jewish burial. Along the way he picks up his own mother. After one such burial Jakub and another man escape from the ghetto. After he escapes he desires to go back into the ghetto to share the fate of his kinsmen. After being locked in an apartment building after curfew he meets a woman, Lucyna (Alina Janowska) , who is also a Jew but who has been hiding her identity in order to survive. Lucyna falls in love with him. She tells him "You know what it's like to escape the Warsaw ghetto but I escape every day." They are separated. Lucyna thinks that Jakub went back into the ghetto. She identifies herself as a Jew to the Germans in order to be sent to the ghetto in order to find him. (Shades of an O. Henry tale here.) Meanwhile he finds refuge in an apartment belonging Józef Malina (Jan Ciecierski), whom he met in prison, and Malina's niece, Kazia (Elzbieta Kepinska). Jakub wishes that he had the strength of the biblical Samson to fight the Germans single handedly. Kazia falls for him. Jakub vacillates and instead of returning to the ghetto hides in their basement until the Warsaw uprising has ended. He only returns to the ghetto after the Germans had put down uprising and destroyed the ghetto in the process. Afterwards he meets others of the resistance.

It was not quite clear why Jakob did not return to the Warsaw ghetto and instead spent his time with Mr. Malina and Kazia. He did not have the strength of the biblical Samson after all I suppose.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed