User Reviews

Review this title
15 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
never to be forgotten
qatmom23 September 2006
Television in the 1950s was full of WW2 documentaries. Growing up in that decade, I do not remember learning about most of the major events of that war for the first time--I saw so many of these documentaries that I always seemed to know them.

The Valiant Years was one of the last and one of the very best. I must have been 10 years old when it was broadcast in the US, but I have never forgotten it. Every few years, I check to see if it is available here or from the UK, but it never is, which is a great shame.

I wonder if it is even preserved somewhere in the original film format? Does anyone know? Does anyone know who owns the rights? I recall that it was a joint production of the BBC and ABC (American).
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent
skallisjr6 January 2007
I saw this twice. Once when it was first released, then a few years later when a local station reran it. A book was published, reprising the narrative scripts. This one I've not forgotten, and as I age, I get increasingly frustrated that it's never been released to DVD or even VHS. This is one of the best documentaries of the European theater of World War II. The series brings fine detail to the beginnings of the war, and how it commenced. All historical documentaries should be this good: then students would be motivated to pay attention to the unfolding of events.

If it ever appears for home viewing, I'd be first in line to order a copy.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Work of genius criminally still unavailable nearly 50 years after 1st broadcast.
david-hardy17-18 September 2009
My own experiences echo the other users, baby boomers like myself. I was a month short of 9 years old in 1961 when this 1st arrived on our screens. I was hooked forever, and I was mesmerised from day 1. It lit an abiding interest in the study of that conflict and an abiding deep deep respect and gratitude for all the allied combatants.

The wonderful sweeping and majestic signature tune and incidental music that pervades throughout the individual episodes holds you in it's grip. Once heard, NEVER forgotten. Add to the mix, the hours of wonderful archive film, the unsurpassable Narration by Gary Merrill and also the impeccable readings from Churchill himself by Richard Burton.

This production comes as near as possible to perfect. So the next question is why this international treasure has never been made publicly available? Who thinks they have the right to deny us, why can't they get their act together and sort out the red tape and just get it out there so we can watch it again at least one more time before we die!! What are they waiting for??
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Comment on Winston Churchill - The Valiant Years
nick-89430 May 2005
Winston Churchill - The Valiant Years ran on BBC TV from February 11th to August 5th 1961, in fact it was repeated while it was still running in its first broadcast. There was also a selection of repeats in 1965, after Churchill's death. What has stuck most of all in my mind is the theme music (composed by Richard Rogers) - not just the title theme, so much so that I searched for the LP and obtained it only recently. I also recall the commentary by Gary Merrill, which seemed to add impact to the image. Richard Burton was well cast as the voice of Churchill. I am surprised that there has never been any attempt to repeat not even one of that series - or perhaps put it on DVD. Some might say that the content is now dated, but that could be said of any history, and this was perhaps one of the best portrayals, if not the classic portrayal, of Churchill's war years. I am sure the content of the series would stand the test of time if given a chance.
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Unable to Forget
jesterfari27 September 2010
My father watched this whenever it was on (about 7.00pm ish - can't recall the weekday), and I watched it with him. He was 41 in 1953 when I was born, so he must have been around 48, and I was 7 in 1960. I never missed a programme. His father died in 1943, having been a professional soldier, and fought in South Africa in 1900. Father was in the 6th A.A.Artillary. HKSRA., and then FMSVF until 1940. Mother lost a younger brother in WW2, and uncle aged 41 (on HMS Hood), and her father was in WW1 in France. She rarely watched it. It still remains with me as a significant reminder of the things they must have recently been through, and the stirring theme is unforgettable. I'm only 57, but feel a bit stranded by the fact that not many people seem to know anything about this series. This, and 'All Our Yesterdays', were my personal introduction to what my parents couldn't explain. Surely there must be some viewable remains ? My dad took me to the pictures in Hunstanton in 1962 to see 'The Longest Day', (my kids call it The Longest Film) and had to come out to buy Calamine lotion for my sunburnt legs - he missed the film.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The power to hold you through the years!
tonybu11 June 2010
Having watched The Gathering Storm at the weekend I finally tried to find out what the name of the documentary - the signature tune of which has remained in my psyche since childhood in England. Thanks to the reviews above I now know it was The Valiant Years. I was only 9 or 10 but the majestic music and the rippling of the water at the end of each episode - which one must presume is at Chartwell - Winston Churchill's home - I can summon in a thrice. I must confess as an adopted Australian now I am very much aware of Churchill's great blunders which cost tens of thousands of lives over decades but he was certainly the leader the Allies needed during the War. I remember some years back seeing a documentary on Churchill's life which ended with his funeral (which I can still remember vaguely as a child) and feeling inconsolable grief for a few minutes. There was something very big about Churchill and very small about the island he was trying to protect which I think resonates with the child within us and the father we ( I guess most of us writing in this column) have lost. I hope to at least get a copy of the music one day - but the DVD would be grand.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Carefully Researched Telling of The Great Statesman's Life Story, Going Back to early days for Background! Question: Hey BBC, So Where're the DVD's Already?
redryan6411 December 2007
Although we were "boomers," individuals born in the Post War Baby Boom, knowledge and even a sort of artificial "memory seems to exist concerning WORLD WAR II. This appears to be a widespread symptom that is present in a large portion of the Boomer Population in general. Just what causes this? Why does "our" pampered, spoiled brat of a group, the collective offspring of what many believe to be the greatest generation in the history of the World possess what no other has had ? Perhaps we can offer a theory as to the whys and hows, even as to the validity of the existence of this phenomenon.

Well, I started this and I'll finish it, by Dr. Spock!! World War II was the greatest single struggle in World History. Unlike the First World War, there was no great feeling of futility following its successful conclusion. Clearly the Good Guys won. Oh sure, we had a couple of questionable characters fighting on the side with the Allies.

These Buzzards, namely Stalin and Mao, were about as big a pair of heals that have ever walked the face of the Earth. They each may well have topped the Nazis and Der Fuehrer's head count of innocents killed.

The magnitude of the War in both the actual numbers of men under arms, the number of Nations participating* and the long lasting effects thrust on our World cannot be overstated. This fact is indisputable, and was well realized by those who were true veterans of active participation in the hostilities in any of the Theaters of War.

And out in front in the Post War world, serving as Evangelists of the non-denominational Gospel of the True History of the events were the Veterans of the War themselves. And let's not forget that there were millions of them in the United States alone. In our family we had my father, Clem Ryan (Navy)as well as uncles John "Bro" O'Connell (Navy-Seabees), Robert F. Ryan (Navy), Bernard E."Gene" Ryan (Coast Guard), Walter Fuerst (Coast Guard)Edward Ryan (Army) and Walter Sattler (Marine Corps). So, our family was well represented and had plenty of first hand stories told to us young 'uns! Next we had great pop fiction as in all those Hollywood Wartime Movies, which were then trickling down to us through showings on Television. Added to those was our generations first run Armed Service anthology TV series, such as:"NAVY LOG", "CITIZEN SOLDIER" and "THE SILENT SERVICE".

Even more of an impression was left by a small number of well made, beautifully mounted documentaries. With use of literally thousands of hours of American, Allied and Captured Axis news film and official government filmings of the actual events leading up to and occurring during the seemingly endless conflict. Much like today's currently running "Ken Burns' THE WAR", these televised showings brought the War to our living rooms and magically transported us to places like Dunkirk, Pearl Harbor, The Ardennes, Guadalcanal, Stalingrad and Iwo Jima. We didn't realize nor appreciate at that time how great a service this was, nor how these were all recent historical events, and just how recent.

The other great documentaries included: "VICTORY AT SEA"(NBC, 1951), BBC's "THE WORLD AT WAR" (1974), ABC's "CRUSADE IN EUROPE" (1949), Time Inc.'s "CRUSADE IN THE PACIFIC"(1951) and lastly we have today's subject, the BBC's Production of "WINSTON CHURCHILL: THE VALIANT YEARS".(1960).

This Valiant Years production was second to none in its use of archival motion picture footage. It also went that extra step in obtaining the services of two top acting talents of the English speaking world in American Gary Merrill as the Narrator and British (Welsh Born) Richard Burton. The decision was a sound one as both men were well known on either side of "the Pond", as well as Australia, New Zealand, Hong Kong and South Africa. Both had magnificent sets of pipes, which added to the effect and appeal of the film record unfolding.

And one other thing comes to mind. Mr. Churchill's own mother was an American, a fact that would seem to bind the two countries & peoples together. It also was a sound sales point for the American Broadcasting Company, who was the premier outlet for the series in the States.

The beautiful, majestic theme music and the incidental music in the original score are most haunting and unforgettable. They were composed by the American, Richard Rodgers; famed as half of the teams of Broadway's Rodgers & Hart and Rodgers & Hammerstein. In addition to nearly innumerable Broadway successes, Mr. Rodgers was the man responsible for the immortal score for NBC's "VICTORY AT SEA".

As a point of a truly trivial nature, we remember that the first run of The Valiant Years had as a sponsor, Meade-Johnson & Company, makers of "Metracal, Dietary for Weight Control", a very popular product for dieters back in the day. Well, one of their commercials told about hazards of overweight and difficulties in reducing. All of off-screen voice over was spoken by an unknown gentleman; who was obviously a Brit. As for the on screen man in the visuals; he wears a black overcoat, black Hamburg hat and dark gloves. The commercial presented the images of an obviously older, portly gentleman strolling somewhat belabourdly through a snow filled park. We only see him from a distance and from the rear.

NOW QUESTION, PLEASE: Is this commercial, which was only shown on the Sunday evening's Telecasts, supposed to look like Sir Winston, himself? We know that it was not him, but the resemblance is too much to ignore. We thought then and now that that was taking product placement and subliminal persuasion just a little too far!

NOTE: * Just try looking up World War II in the Encyclopedia to see just how many Nations did actually declare war, though most of their participation was minimal.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Brilliant series now unaccountably unavailable.
andeven10 August 2014
Just to add a couple of points to nick-894's excellent review of 30 May 2005 (sorry for the slight delay in doing so!).

Nick is quite right in giving the dates of The Valiant Years' original UK (BBC) run in 1961 and the pertinent fact that a repeat run started before the original had even been completed, such was the popularity of the series with, and demand from, the general public. It also, as he says, resurfaced in 1965.

In addition the series was repeated on Channel 4 in the UK around 25 years after its first showing, almost certainly in 1986. Three or four years ago I saw a box set advertised in a catalogue and sent away for it, only to be told that it was, after all, suddenly no longer available. They would let me know as soon as it was but, of course, that was the last I heard. From all this it does seem that the series is physically out there somewhere and that there must be some copyright problems which are preventing its release. Quite what they are and whether they can be resolved I would love to know.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Why No DVD Release ?
j-rees31 May 2018
This is a first class documentary series made in the early 1960s, about 10 years ago this series was about to be released on DVD for the very first time ........ but for some reason it was withdrawn at the last moment........ does anybody know why this was ? About the same time the BBC released on DVD the full documentary that they made in 1964 call.......... The Great War, but as i've said before The Valiant Years never saw the light of day in the shops.

PS The entire series of The Valiant Years does exist on film in the BBC archives so perhaps try contacting the BBC for an answer.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
All Regions DVD Now Available
jamesashford6 September 2017
I have been searching for a home viewing copy of this magnificent series since the advent of Betamax/VHS. This month, approaching my 77th year, I finally scored.

A web search for the title will bring up the site from which I ordered the series. IMDb Guidelines prohibit more specificity.

I'm watching the episodes now. The quality and sound are quite adequate, given the unknown source of transfer. Remember that this was done on film in the early 1960s. Let me put it this way: viewing this DVD is like sitting in front of your black and white RCA 24" TV in 1961. Good enough for me just to have it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Now on YouTube !!
gkt-3530023 August 2021
At last on YouTube. Hooray !!!

The BBC should be ashamed of themselves for depriving younger generations of this superb series.

Congratulations to the uploader: Michael Brooks.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Valiant Years should be put on DVD with CC.
pinnerbl3 September 2005
I have of late read with some interest the comments and memories of those who have commented on the impression that "The Valiant Years" made on them. Now more than 40 years after first seeing it in TV in Canada as a child of about 8-9 years old, the impressions it made in my life are still very much alive and active. I share with many comments made already how the stirring music stays in mind this this day, and the amazing voice of Richard Burton as he portrayed Winston Churchill. In recent years I have been in London on many occasions and have visited the War Rooms where Churchill led the Britain's effort for 6 long years. His voice seems present there still due to what I heard on The Valiant Years. I would love to see this series again as I at the moment watching The World at War for I believe the 4th time. Some things should never be lost to the public. I suppose as it has bee said so many times, "Those who forget history are doomed to live it again."

Dr. Mark W. McK. Bannatyne
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
My First Exposure to Historical Documentaries on Television
theowinthrop11 May 2005
I was only six years old at the time, and I had been to young to see VICTORY AT SEA back in the early 1950s. At the age of six, I had heard of Winston Churchill, and had seen pictures of him. But it wasn't until this series was shown that I actually heard his words (not that I realized they were being spoken by Richard Burton), and got some idea of his wartime service to Britain and the world. I wish it was shown again, as much of my memories are centered on the musical score and the readings of Burton. The narrative was quite informative - I remember how one episode mentioned the shooting down of a plane, supposedly carrying Churchill, which crashed killing all of it's passengers. One was Leslie Howard.

If there was some clever television network producer out there, this series and WORLD WAR ONE and TIME TO REMEMBER would be put on together - maybe on some offshoot of the history channel.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A forty-year-old clouded memory.
nicholas.rhodes14 August 2004
I have a very distant & blurred memory of this series which I think was broadcast just after Churchill's death in 1965. It was in black and white and had a very haunting and grandiose theme music which remains alive in my head to this day. The series seemed endless at the time and I would dearly like to see it to day to compare my appreciation 40 years later. Unfortunately, I fear it is just the kind of series which is likely to have fallen into total oblivion so I don't really hold out any hopes on this score. If however, such a miracle was to occur, I'll write another updated comment on IMDB !
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Fond Memories of This Great Series
imonteith-214131 February 2018
In 1960 I was nine. This was shown one night a week and it was a special occassion as it was the one schoolday night I was allowed to stay up to the ungodly hour of 11 p.m. My Dad figured it was a required part of my education, and I was fine with that. Dad had been a Major in the Canadian Expeditionary Force in WWI, horse-drawn artillery. He volunteered to serve again in WWII but was told he was too old. He was a huge admirer of Churchill and had a photo of the great man pinned up beside his desk in his law office. I found the series enthralling, not only for the action clips, but also for the narrative history and the power of the language: excerts from Churchill's speeches and that wonderful voice of Richard Burton speaking the Queen's English.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed