The Maverick Queen (1956) User Reviews

Saw It In Pan-And-Scan

[boblipton · 6/10 · 13 March 2020]

Barry Sullivan is a Pinkerton agent. He's sent to gather information on the Hole In The Wall Gang. Barbara Stanwyck, who fronts for them and is Scott Brady's lover -- he plays the Sundance Kid -- falls in love with Sullivan. There's also a subplot about Mary Murphy, whose cattle keep getting rustled.

It's hard for me to judge this movie, because I saw it with the visuals wrecked. Released by Republic at a 2.35:1 aspect ratio, I saw it in TV-standard pan-and-scan, wrecking cinematographer Jack Marta's compositions and reducing every shot to an undistinguished series of close-ups and medium close-ups. The story is one of those A Westerns from the 1950s, meant to star a woman or two in trousers, but with the action carried by the men. I'm pretty sure that if you got to see it at its proper aspect ratio, you'd like it a lot. The way I saw it, though, reduces it to mush.

No longer Cattle Queen, Missy conquers the Maverick!

[mark.waltz · 6/10 · 31 July 2015]

Long before Barbara Stanwyck worked with "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid" star Katharine Ross on "The Colbys", she had her own encounter with Butch and Sundance in this colorful western made by Republic Pictures in the mid 1950's. She's the colorfully named Kit Banion, the proprietress of a Wyoming saloon. In her encounter with Sundance (Scott Brady), she tells him "Somewhere along the way, sometime, I'll meet a better man like the ones I used to know, and when I do, I'll drop you like a poisonous snake!" A rail thin Stanwyck shows what she does best, standing up to sinister men, and being just as ruthless in getting what she wants. Stanwyck rides, shoots and fights with the toughness of the fiercest western hero (heroine). She finds her match in Jeff Younger (Barry Sullivan), telling him "That's a great name to slung around carelessly" upon their first meeting, indicating to Sundance that she has found the better man.

The film makes reference not only to the Younger Brothers ("You might be Younger, but you won't be older if you don't watch out!"), Butch and Sundance but "The Wild Boys" (a violent western made the same year as the Newman/Redford pairing). Pretty Mary Murphy is perhaps younger and more feminine than the still striking Stanwyck (nearing 50!), but she more than holds her own in her scenes with the female master of melodrama. "The only way you leave the wild bunch is feet first", Stanwyck explains as she shows shows Kit's softness in a romantic scene with Sullivan, who is not as he appears to be. This leads to an exciting sequence on a speeding train with bandits aboard, only made better with the color photography of the natural backgrounds including the breathtaking mountain scenery.

The title song, sung by Joni James, is gorgeous, as is the score by Victor Young and the photography by Jack Marta. This is one of those westerns that is probably more impressive on a big screen; Its photography almost screams 3-D. Familiar actors such as Wallace Ford and Jim Davis appear in smaller roles, giving this quite an incredible ensemble. Stanwyck's tough, slightly villainous femme fatale is an amazing characterization, and you can see why she was attracted to parts like this whether out in God's country or in the Asphalt Jungle. No other actress has defined what parts women really had in the old west than the great Barbara, and even in the weakest of these films, she made them so much more memorable.

A good Western with unerring sense of style and great main and support cast

[ma-cortes · 6/10 · 22 October 2022]

Willful and attractive Kit Banion (Barbara Stanwick) is the Maverick Queen. She is a saloon owner and one of the chiefs of an outlaw gang nicknamed the Wild Bunch . As the story unfolds Kit proves she is tough and smart, and can ride and shoot as well as any man. But a Pinkerton agent , posing as Jeff Younger , nephew of the infamous outlaw Younger brothers , is sent to infiltrate the Wild Bunch and gather evidence against the band . There appears Jeff Younger (Barry Sullivan) who teams up with the gang led by Sundance Kid (Scott Brady) . But Kid is a very jealousy man and when he finds out his girlfriend Kit falls for Jeff he becomes into a nasty and vengeful gunslinger who seeks for vendetta against him . Then the gutsy saloon keeper gets in trouble while squabbling over two men . While the powerful Pinkerton is relentlessly dedicated to catching Butch Cassidy and the members of The Wild Bunch. Hear Joni James sing !. Photographed in the colorful state of Colorado in exquisite Trucolor by Consolidated Film Industries !.

Exciting classic Western with a love triangle , crosses , double-crosses , gun-play and rousing action . Weird and hysterical Western with peculiar touches , dreamlike emotionalism and magnificent dialogue in which is blended domination , jealous , humiliation and a deadly confrontation ; resulting to be a fascinating and melodramatic film . This Western has acquired something of cult following along the lines of the magical and mythic ¨Joan Crawford's Johnny Guitar¨ , perhaps because it comes from the same studios : Republic . It has another Hollywood legend , Barbara Stanwick who gives a stunningly dominating acting in a similar role and Scott Brady as Sundance Kid who bears remarkable resemblace to his character in the Crawford picture . This isn't as excellent as Johnny Guitar , but notable enough , altough it does have some impressive shootouts , and more action than the vintage film . Love and hate are woven into three protagonists : Barbara Stanwick , Barry Sullivan and Scott Brady ; the fabulous trio sharing a mythical confrontation . Exceptional performances by all casting as top-notch Barbara Stanwick as a feisty lady saloonkeeper , Barry Sullivan as the mysterious , stubborn drifter and Scott Brady as saddle-tramp bandit who turns a psychopathic temper caused by jealous while taking up his pistols . Sensational plethora of secondaries , such as : gorgeous Mary Murphy at an important role as Lucy Lee , Wallace Ford , Howard Petrie , Jim Davis, Emile Meyer , Walter Sande , George Keymas , Taylor Holmes and John Doucette.

It contains colorful and brilliant cinematography in Trucolor by director of photography Jack A. Marta . As well as sensitive and atmospheric musical score by the classic composer Victor Young . This vintage as well as traditional movie was produced by Herbert J Yates from Republic Pictures and professionally directed by Joseph , ¨Joe¨ , Kane , containing some vigorous scenes , though virtually the Republic studio's last major production before it lurched towards extinction. Kane was a good craftsman who made around 100 titles from the 30s . This motion picture The Maverick Queen (1956) was well directed , though with no much enthusiasm . Kane directed a great number of films and several episodes of notorious TV episodes . Kane started directing career started with co-directing serials for Mascot and Republic, and he soon became Republic's top western director . He handled many of John Wayne's Republic westerns of the 1940s , and piloted numerous Roy Rogers and Gene Autry films . Unlike most Republic house directors, Kane was credited as associate producer on many of his films. He stayed at Republic until the studio's demise in 1959, and after freelancing for mostly independent production companies, he turned to directing TV series as Bonanza . Kane usually worked with Vera Ralston, whom husband Herbert J. Yates, president of Republic Pictures and Kane's boss, attempted without success to make a star . He made a lot of westerns , such as : King of the Cowboys 1943 , Idaho 1942 , Ridin' Down the Canyon 1942, Heart of the Golden West 1942 , Sunset Serenade 1942, Sons of the Pioneers 1942 Romance on the Range 1942 , Sunset on the Desert 1942 , South of Santa Fe 1942 ,Man from Cheyenne 1941 , Red River Valley 1941 , Jesse James at Bay 1941, Bad Man of Deadwood 1941, Rags to Riches 1941 , Nevada City 1941 ,Sheriff of Tombstone 1941, In Old Cheyenne 1941, The Great Train Robbery 1941 , Robin Hood of the Pecos 1940 , The Border Legion 1940 , Young Bill Hickok 1940 Colorado 1940 ,The Ranger and the Lady 1940 ,The Carson City Kid 1940 ,Young Buffalo Bill 1939, Days of Jesse James 1939 , Saga of Death Valley 1939 , The Arizona Kid 1939 , In Old Monterey 1939 , Wall Street Cowboy 1939 , and many others . The flick will appeal to Western/adventure buffs ; it's an agreeable popcorn story plenty of breathtaking scenes , emotion , adventures , colorful exteriors and anything else . It's a wonderful enjoyable story for kids , teens and old people . Rating : Decent Western 6.5/10 .

Some missed potential but still an enjoyable film for genre fans

[bob the moo · 25 July 2005]

Lucy Lee is a young and pretty cattle owner, trying to get her herd to market to sell. One night in camp her and her partner are joined by Jeff Young – a man who saves them when they are later ambushed by the Sundance Kid and his gang. Sundance reports back to Kit Banion (aka the Maverick Queen) and she in enraged by his failure. However the arrival in town of Jeff Younger gives her a new scheme to run. As she attempts to assert further power can the others stop her criminal schemes?

Starting out with the usual style of song over the usual sort of landscapes nothing gave me any doubts that this would be a fairly ordinary western adventure and indeed that is what it turned out to be. The plot offered potential because it is more than just the standard good guys/bad guys stuff – this plot is driven by betrayal, lies, jealousy and intrigue. Shame then that it doesn't all come off, it is interesting and engaging but it does struggle to keep it tight with so many things going on – I wasn't sure exactly what my focus was supposed to be. This is also seen by it taking 15 minutes before the title character actually made it onto screen, not that bad a thing but just further suggestion of the slight lack of focus that made it a bit harder to get into. The characters don't all make sense and again the lack of focus meant I was confused as to who I was following.

The cast aren't much help in this regard either because nobody really steps up and makes the film their own. Stanwyck tries hard but she was approaching the end of her long career at this point and she isn't helped by being left in the background for most of the start of the film while the much younger Murphy makes us think the film is about her. Sullivan is pretty good and has a nice easy charm. Brady, Petrie and a few others make for interesting bad guys but their performances aren't that interesting and they just accept whatever changes the script throws at them.

Overall this is an enjoyable enough western that is fairly run-of-the-mill despite having aspects of it that are more than the standard stuff. The plot is good but the lack of focus for large chunks means that it is a little difficult to get into and the solid if unspectacular directing and acting don't do anything to really remedy that. Enjoyable for genre fans but no more than that.

Stanwyck betrays her outlaw gang to promote and save her new love.

[weezeralfalfa · 7/10 · 14 July 2018]

The site summary says that Kit Banion(Barbara Stanwick) was dubbed The Maverick Queen because in her early days around Rock Springs, she would round up all the unbranded cattle she could find and brand them. Of course, never having married and not foreseeing the possibility of such, she was a maverick herself. Considering the 2 female characters(Kit, and Mary Murphy , as Lucy Lee), this can be deduced as an iconic 'good' girl vs. 'bad' girl film, although they aren't visibly competing for the attention of the lead male: Barry Sullivan, masquerading as Jeff Younger, nephew of the infamous Younger brothers. In fact, toward the end, they sometimes cooperate as partners with Jeff against the Hole in the Wall Gang, which Kit has been an indispensable part of......If you remember the ending of the Anthony Mann western "The Far Country" Ruth Roman, as the young middle-aged 'bad 'girl, and Corinne Calvert, as the young 'good' girl both had their eyes on Jimmy Stewart, who was fighting for his life against the villain, played by John McIntire. Ruth died trying to defend Jimmy against the shooting of McIntire, leaving Corinne as the apparent winner, by default. Well, a rather similar thing happens here. Kit dies trying to defend the wounded Jeff against a variety of gang members, leaving a cute Lucy as the apparent winner. In both cases, the younger 'good' girl won, although this is not always the case in westerns("Abilene Town" comes to mind as a clear counter example).......Eventually Jim Davis, dubbed 'The Stranger' in the credits, shows up, looking dapper in his all black outfit. He claims he is the real Jeff Younger, and whips out a newspaper photo to prove his identity. He would like to meet the outlaw gang, and goes riding off. I don't remember seeing him again. He had served his purpose in confirming rumors that Sullivan wasn't the real Younger, and might be a lawman. Later, it's confirmed that he is a Pinkerton man. Kit would like him to replace The Sundance Kid(Scott Brady) as her primary lover, but recommends that he relocate far from the gang, which she considers doomed, in the long run. She seems to think she's stuck in her now ambiguous situation. ......The drawn out climax, near the end, seemed largely unrealistic, with characters supposedly safely escaping from a burning cabin, with gunslingers all around.......Spectacular mountain scenery usually composed the on location background. This was around Durango, Royal Gorge, and Silverton, CO...... The film was produced by Republic, not long before the demise of this studio, with the phasing out of B westerns.......This was one of the last Hollywood films Barbara would star in. It was also near the beginning of her emphasis on westerns, which would culminate in her "The Big Valley" TV series, that ended about a decade later. She would again costar with Barry Sullivan the following year in the western "Forty Guns". If this sounds promising, see it at YouTube.

She Sure is A Maverick-Maverick Queen ***

[edwagreen · 7/10 · 30 December 2012]

Barbara Stanwyck in still another gritty performance, with no nonsense at all. As a leading member of Butch Cassidy and Sundance Kid's cattle rustling group, Stanwyck as always shows that she is up to the task.

Realizing that the western area is changing with all the settlers coming in, she correctly predicts the end of the era and that the gang will be wiped out. Butch and Sundance certainly aren't glamorized here as they were with Paul Newman and Robert Redford's "Sundance Kid" in 1969.

Despite her participation in this illegal enterprise, Stanwyck is looking for something better in the men she chooses and she finds that in Barry Sullivan, who has infiltrated the gang, a Pinkerton Detective man.

A good film which is filmed with traditional lines-"We can't go back," and "I made my path."

aging beauty becomes outlaw leader

[dougbrode · 6/10 · 15 March 2006]

When Barbara Stanwyck's era of Hollywood superstardom came to an abrupt end in the early fifties, she refused to quit and became the star of a number of feminist westerns which cast her as a tough yet sensuous aging woman in tight pants and a cowboy hat, oftentimes the leader of an outlaw gang. She'd make one minor classic of this variety, Forty Guns for Sam Fuller. The Maverick Queen has a bigger budget (and was shot in color) but lacks the energy and magnetism of that later film - both, however, co-star he with Barry Sullivan, a highly underrated leading man who enjoyed far greater success on TV (including a two year stint as Pat Garrett on The Tall Man) than in the movies. Babs struts around in tight pants and we're not supposed to notice that she could easily pass for her boyfriend's mother. And as the badguy, her former boyfriend the Sundance Kid, there's Scott Brady - who played The Dancing Kid in JOHNNY GUITAR, the very best of the odd westerns that cast visibly aging former big name female stars in cowgirl roles. (Joan Crawford, in that film's case). This is handsomely produced by strictly minor stuff. We're supposed to cry when Babs "gets it" in the end, but I can still recall kids in the Rialto theatre in Patchogue, Long Island laughing out loud at the end way back when.

Good Western!

[RodrigAndrisan · 7/10 · 11 July 2022]

The best, worth seeing, in this film is Barbara Stanwyck, she is by far the best actress in the entire cast. Everyone else, including Barry Sullivan, Scott Brady, Mary Murphy, etc., is good, but only functional around her. I try to imagine what it would have been like if Barbara Stanwyck had worked with Sergio Leone.

Lacklustre characters let down plot

[Igenlode Wordsmith · 5/10 · 27 June 2002]

Perhaps the first thing to note about this film is that the Maverick Queen herself, Kit Banion - cattle trader, saloon proprietor, hand in glove with Butch Cassidy's Wild Bunch, and the richest woman in Rock Springs - doesn't actually appear until ten to fifteen minutes into the action! Even then, we initially assume she must be a minor character; surely the lady of the title song must be Lucy Lee - sweeter, younger and far less hard-faced - the girl the hero has already rescued in the first scenes? (Mary Murphy, just two years into her career, as opposed to Barbara Stanwyck, at this point a full twenty-five years into - and almost at the end of - hers.)

But Kit soon takes charge of the situation; and she can look after herself. There is a scene which cleverly subverts the audience's expectations, in which she is attacked and her lover rides to the rescue - only, before he can arrive, she saves the situation single-handed by deliberately sending her opponent over a cliff. When her would-be saviours arrive, they find her already bruised but triumphant. And in the final gun-battle, it is she who takes an active part when her lover is wounded, forcing him to keep moving, shooting without hesitation to protect him and taking a bullet in his defence.

The outlaw gang in this film are not the usual brutal but dim-witted cannon fodder provided for the hero's benefit, either. As it turns out, they've spotted the plot twist long before the audience (or before me at least!) When the fugitives hole up in a cabin, the pursuers actually take advantage of their superior numbers to surround the cabin and force their way in - and later on, instead of obligingly shooting it out, they simply set fire to the building in order to smoke out their quarry. The hero's ruse to lead them off fools them for a while - but as soon as they see through it, they jump to the right conclusion and head back in time to foil the planned escape.

The casual amorality of the outlaws is also well depicted. Sundance's disappearance after he gets the worse of a struggle with Kit is greeted by Cassidy with no more than "Well, I guess he deserved it", and his subsequent return is accepted with an equal shrug: "Thought you were dead, but I'm glad you ain't." There is no question, for example, of the rest of the outlaws hesitating for a moment to attack when they ride up just because Kit happens to have two of their number held at gunpoint.

My main problem with this film is that none of the principal characters seem to have any real motivation for what they are doing. Jeff at least has a plot rationale for his inconsistent actions - and for why we never see beyond his surface - but neither Kit nor Sundance seem to have sufficient justification for acting clean against their own best interests. In both cases, they are presumably intended to be in the grip of an overwhelming and unreciprocated affection - but Sundance spends the entire film chasing Lucy Lee rather than the woman who has supposedly prompted him to wild jealousy, and the Maverick Queen also displays an unjustified and distinctly surprising concern towards her. After all, not only did we see Kit cold-bloodedly engineering this same girl's bankruptcy for her own profit earlier in the film, but she also has to know by this stage that Lucy is her rival for Jeff's affections!

But whether due to bad acting or a poor script, Kit doesn't really give the impression in any case of having fallen passionately enough for Jeff to make it plausible that she should give up everything for him. Kit Banion is no lovable rogue with a heart of gold; she is depicted as a ruthless and hard-headed businesswoman - albeit with a slightly unusual turn of trade - who is deliberately toying with a young newcomer in order to pay out the lover of whom she has tired. At some point this is presumably supposed to betray her into genuine affection, but for all the kissing in evidence, it somehow fails to convince - particularly when faced with Jeff's lack of response.

Lucy too remains something of a cipher. Her early appearance, when we naturally assume she is the title character, leads us to expect that she is going to have a much larger role than ultimately transpires, but in fact, that initial scene more or less sums up her entire function - to act as a (repeated) plot device so that Sundance's pursuit of her can allow Jeff to get the better of him, and to provide the token 'good woman' required as the hero's love interest. There is no convincing relationship of any kind established between her and Jeff, any more than there is between Jeff and Kit - or Kit and Sundance.

All these characters come across as masks, without little or nothing real going on behind their faces. There is quite an intelligent plot going on in the background, but I simply couldn't find it in me to care very much about what happened to any of them. That lack of engagement on the part of the audience is, I think, the fatal flaw in this film.

I gather it is a Zane Grey adaptation. The virtues of the plot - such as they are - are owed entirely, I would guess, to the source novel. Any essence of the original characters would seem to have got lost in the translation from page to screen. Given its intelligently-drawn villains, morally ambiguous title character and cleverly set-up twist, the material might have made even a great off-beat Western...I'm afraid, however, that this isn't it.

Zane Grey's Steamy Sex Novel

[bkoganbing · 5/10 · 1 March 2008]

In The Maverick Queen you will find the characters of Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid in support of Barbara Stanwyck. But Howard Petrie and Scott Brady aren't anything like Paul Newman and Robert Redford. You won't hear Raindrops Keep Falling On My Head. And Brady as Sundance is a sexual predator as well.

The Maverick Queen was made in the last days of Republic Pictures which was the home of the B movie cowboy. Gene Autry and Roy Rogers and a bunch of others toiled there for a while. The last of them, Rex Allen, had just finished doing his series. The films that these guys did were now being made for television. Something like The Maverick Queen would never have been made at Republic ten years ago.

This movie is about sex, it concentrates on Barbara Stanwyck who operates against her own interest because of her attraction for Barry Sullivan. She's tired of the Sundance Kid as a lover, in fact she urges him to take a bath before putting the moves on her again when we first meet her.

As for Brady when it becomes obvious about her attraction to Sullivan, he tries to kill Stanwyck and later attempts to rape Mary Murphy. Rape was not something found in Republic westerns. The film is directed by Joseph Kane who directed a ton of films there with Autry, Rogers, and the rest of the cowboy stars.

The Maverick Queen boasts some nice location photography and was the first of Republic's films to be filmed for the wide screen. It's based on a Zane Grey novel and I never would have dreamed that Grey would have written anything like that. Joni James also sings the title song over the credits and I liked her rendition of it.

Unfortunately The Maverick Queen should have been done when the Code was finally done away with, a lot of plot holes might not have occurred. It also should have been in the hands of director not from the grind 'em out school of B westerns. It might have been a whole lot better.

Classic Stanwyck

[chazz-7 · 8/10 · 10 April 2001]

Stanwyck's portrayal of the outlaw woman Kit Banion is an all-time classic. This role sets the standard for strong western women in the cinema. Stanwyck perfect for the role of the beautiful and strong-willed Kit Banion, leader of the Wild Bunch outlaw gang who can ride and shoot with the best of them. Stanwyck more than holds her own, matching wits and pistol shots with outlaws and lawmen alike. However, her lawless days are numbered when she falls in love with a Pinkerton agent (Barry Sullivan) who infiltrates the gang. Good supporting cast with familiar supporting actors. Visually pleasing with great western scenery, shot on location in southrn Colorado. Exciting action scenes liven up a sometimes plodding script. Well worth watching. A must see for fans of classic westerns.

Pretty routine stuff bordering on bad in a few scenes...even with Stanwyck chipping in

[secondtake · 5/10 · 27 December 2012]

The Maverick Queen (1956)

Well Barbara Stanwyck made a lot of Westerns in the 1950s, and most of them are routine stuff, and in them she has often limited if still central roles. This is a great example. She's in the film much less than her co-stars, and the story is a patched together set of common problems--the cattle rancher faces trouble from the cattle rustlers and a hero has come to town, and a little love is going to cross the frontier.

The key difference in all these movies is that Stanwyck plays a strong, sometimes very very strong, woman. That alone makes them watchable. But don't expect "The Maverick Queen" to hold up critically or even hold your attention fully. The plot even has so many little confusions, on purpose. you have to pay close attention (and show some patience) to keep in on track.

For one example, without giving too much away, the main man, played well by Barry Sullivan, is new in town, and he says he's Jeff Younger, a famous gunslinger. This suite Stanwyck's character perfectly--she runs the tavern but also the general racketeering schemes for the province. But then another man arrives in town and says he's Jeff Younger. Hmmm. Along the same lines, the pretty young girl in town is another strong woman, clearly a good one, and her sidekick is a lazy loaf but a good guy, until you see him start telling people things he shouldn't. And so on. These are really great plot twists but they aren't handled with total clarity or given the impact you might expect so the movie totters a bit.

The director, it might be noted, is Joseph Kane, who pretty much only did Westerns, over a hundred of them, and he probably didn't distinguish one from another very well. He's not even trying to create a masterpiece on the small budget this small studio gave him. (It's a full color Republic Pictures production, and there are corners cut.)

The one other interesting side note is the presence of Sundance as a major character (and Butch Cassidy as a very minor one). Of course, history is thrown to the wind on what happens to Sundance, so never mind that . (Watch the Newman/Redford one for the classic outline.)

And Stanwyck? She's strong, and I mean physically tough, and she busts out with good acting in a few scenes. But she, too, seems to realize she's doing routine stuff.

A final note--I saw this on TCM, and for the first time in twenty years of watching movies there I saw one that was not shown full screen. Yes. A shame. It's a wide wide screen enterprise and it uses an unusual system called Naturama, and it was the first Republic movie to use it. It was really just a compatible anamorphic widescreen system like Panavision, but for some reason it was cropped (given the awful "pan and scan" treatment) for this release. That didn't help with the fluidity of the filming, or the appreciation of the big landscape of Colorado so proudly announced in the opening credits.

Should you see this? Not really. There are better Stanwyck Westerns, and better Westerns. And better movies.

Sigh, poorly written piece that could have been so much more.

[hitchcockthelegend · 4/10 · 6 November 2009]

Tough gal Kit Banlon opens a hotel and saloon out in frontier Colorado that soon becomes a haven of gamblers and gunfighters. With notable patrons being none other than Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid. Fighting off the romantic advances of Sundance, Kit's life gets more interesting when she becomes attracted to a relative of the Younger Brothers' outlaw posse. Or is he? Whispers in the shadows point to the handsome stranger perhaps being a law man on the trail of the infamous Wild Bunch. Kit could very well be jeopardising much more than a unfulfilled romance if she falls in with the stranger?

Directed by the genre prolific Joe Kane and based upon on the novel written by Zane Grey, The Maverick Queen is something of a wasted premise, with all the elements are in place for a twisty psychological Western. The story is a sound one, with the characters at first glance looking to have potential for gusto and intrigue, but it just doesn't come together as a whole, either through one dimensional male characters or through lazy writing, it ultimately ends up being a damp squib. A squib briefly sparked by Barbara Stanwyk (Kit) in one of her later career tough feminine roles, and a pretty as a picture Mary Murphy who also gets to show a bit of spunk. But the girls can't carry the picture alone...

Barry Sullivan was a safe and amiable actor, he however was far from being a leading man who was able to carry a picture up front, thus here as the leading protagonist he struggles badly as he tries to make the tepid Kenneth Gamet screenplay work. It's a surprisingly weak adaptation from the man who wrote The Flying Leathernecks and the hugely enjoyable Coroner Creek, while Kane himself has to take some of the blame for letting the film plod when it should be zippy. There's a nice kicker in the finale - something that saves the piece from rotting at the bottom of the "B" Western barrel, but sadly it's just not decent enough to warrant a second glance - rendering as fact that both Stanwyck and the audience deserved better. 4/10

Been there, done that....

[planktonrules · 5/10 · 26 December 2012]

Considering that "The Maverick Queen" was the first widescreen film from Republic Studios, you'd think it would be a prestige picture. Well, apart from sporting a once A-list actress Barbara Stanwyck (who looks pretty awful in color under such heavy makeup), it was far from a memorable movie.

The film is about Butch Cassidy and the Hole in the Wall gang. It seems they are being aided, covertly, by a lady (Stanwyck) who runs a business called 'The Maverick Queen'. When a guy comes into town saying he wants to join the gang (Barry Sullivan) and that he's Jeff Younger (of the famous Younger gang), Stanwyck goes gaga for the guy and blindly pushed him into a role in their next robbery. At first the ruse seems to work--until the REAL Younger shows up--then it sure looks as if Nelson's days are numbered. Will his new sweetie just stand back and let the gang do him in or will his sheer manliness win her over to his side--getting her to give up EVERYTHING she's ever worked to create?! Well, in real life, the answer would clearly be NO--but this is a movie after all!

As the film progressed, I kept feeling like I've seen this film before. The notion of a butch female gang leader falling for a lawman and betraying the gang is very old and very clichéd--and other actresses like Marlene Dietrich and Joan Crawford (among others) made similar flicks....VERY similar flicks. Additionally, in a scene when there is a showdown and Nelson's character attacks Sundance, not once does Sundance call out for help from his gang who is waiting outside!! Because of bad writing there is never any suspense in the film if you've seen many westerns--you know what MUST happen with each and every cliché--especially the ending.

The bottom line is that although this movie looks nice with its location shoot and color widescreen print, the story itself is pure B-movie all the way. It's pretty indistinguishable from a Roy Rogers or Gene Autry film the studio made in previous years--films which cost a whole heck of a lot less to make and with much more modest pretensions. Passable entertainment but no more and perhaps my score of 5 is a bit generous.

Please note: In the film, Sundance is killed. However, in real life he died in South America--thousands of miles from where the film is set! Historical accuracy....who needs it?!

Kane's best.

[searchanddestroy-1 · 9/10 · 18 April 2021]

That's for me the best movie from director Jo Kane, this prolific director who never quit Republic Pictures. Of course ROAD TO DENVER was also a good western but this one, starring Barbara Stanwyck in a role very close to the ones she had in FORTY GUNS, THE FURIES and CATTLE QUEEN OF MONTANA, this western is helped by superb Colorado state settings, and a music score - and song - that brings you far beyond this tepid and so predictable story. Barbara Stanwyck is as good as ever and Scott Brady doesn't deceive either, nor Barry Sullivan. In France, it was released in VHS, in Naturama - 2.35 frame. We were so lucky. So were we with another Jo Kane' film: JUBILEE TRAIL. One more last thing, it is very amusing to see evoking Butch Cassidy, Younger brothers and several West legends who had nothing to do with each other in real life. But many westerns did the same.

Typical western

[HotToastyRag · 3/10 · 1 October 2018]

With a side plot of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid thrown in, The Maverick Queen can appeal to a wider audience than just die-hard western fans. Barbara Stanwyck, in her pre-The Big Valley phase, plays a tough saloon owner whose independent attitude attracts attention from both Barry Sullivan and Scott Brady.

This one doesn't really stand out in my mind as being an exceptional western, but if you liked Barbara and Barry's chemistry in Forty Guns, you might want to check this out to see them together again. There are all the classic western elements: corseted ladies, train robberies, shootouts, horseback rides, and double-crosses. So, if you like westerns, you can give this a whirl. I'm a little picky in this genre, so I won't be renting this one again.

Stanwyck holds all the cards

[jarrodmcdonald-1 · 12 March 2022]

This was the first and only time Barbara Stanwyck, who made plenty of westerns, worked for Herbert Yates' illustrious studio which specialized in such fare. She plays Kit Banion, a larger than life saloon gal who has ties to some outlaws that includes one of the Younger brothers, Butch Cassidy and Sundance.

THE MAVERICK QUEEN is Stanwyck's show. She is surrounded by audience favorites like Wallace Ford, Jim Davis and Scott Brady. Brady plays Sundance. So you can see what sort of shady business she's involved in...however, she retains the upper hand for most of the film's running time. She's in command of what happens when these dangerous dudes appear on screen.

Another important character is a guy named Jeff who shows up to "help" Kit. He's played by Barry Sullivan, and while we are told he's a criminal at first, we later learn he is in fact a Pinkerton detective on a mission to nab the gang. The film reunites Sullivan with Stanwyck after their previous work in MGM's psychological drama JEOPARDY (1953). The following year they would team up for another western, over at Fox, called FORTY GUNS (1957). Mr. Sullivan is well suited to the genre, and he shares a nice easy rapport with Miss Stanwyck.

Stanwyck is probably a bit too long in the tooth to play a seductive saloon madame at this point in her career, but she makes up for it with her considerable acting skill. A decade earlier she had portrayed a saloon gal in Paramount's CALIFORNIA (1947). But while it was implied the character in that film had obviously used sex to get ahead, it's not as explicit as it is here. Therefore, Lily Bishop, the woman she plays in CALIFORNIA, does get a happy ending- provided she leave a life of sin behind. But in THE MAVERICK QUEEN, Kit Banion is a known "maverick" and must not be rewarded for this.

I suppose we might ask-- has she been corrupted by Sundance and his men? Or did she corrupt them? We're sort of left to figure it out for ourselves. The production code leaves it to our imagination.

Balancing out the toughness of Stanwyck's character, we have Mary Murphy playing a supporting role. She is cast as the softer more wholesome ingenue-- a farm girl that Sullivan meets when he first arrives in the area.

Miss Murphy was a contract player at Republic. And typically, she was cast in "A" westerns as the sweet-natured love interest. She did not have the star power Stanwyck possessed, but in this story, she is given the main romantic storyline. Ultimately Murphy's character wins the good guy (Sullivan), because Stanwyck's character is too immoral, too far gone to be saved. And since Stanwyck, under these circumstances, cannot be allowed the happily-ever-after fairy tale ending, it goes to Murphy.

The audience might have expected Mr. Sullivan's character Jeff to redeem Kit, and for Miss Murphy to redeem Sundance, so that more age-appropriate couplings could occur. But we know that Sundance is not the type to be tamed, and apparently, neither is Kit. This leaves wholesome Lucy the only viable match for Jeff, even though he's old enough to be her father.

Despite such contrivance, the film is still worth watching. It contains some interesting action sequences and as we all know, Stanwyck always puts on a real good show because she's the one holding all the cards.