The Gambler from Natchez (1954) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A plot borrowed from "The Count of Monte Cristo"!
Nazi_Fighter_David22 March 2001
Warning: Spoilers
"The Gambler of Natchez" is a mildly watchable romantic adventure, set in the 19th century riverboat days... It offers Dale Robertson discovering that his gambler father has been dishonored and murdered by three of his traitorous partners...

In the tradition of "The Count of Monte Cristo", Robinson sets out to track down and destroy each of his aristocratic enemies, with time out to flirt with a breathtaking beauty (Lisa Daniels), and succumb to the temptations of a sultry-innocent river girl, Debra Paget...

Robertson carries off the romantic requirements with ease... He looks good in his fencing scenes... The film has plenty of humor and single combats with pistols, swords and fists... The men are brave and handsome, and the women good and beautiful... Evil is punished and right rewarded...

With a rambling script and tasteful costumes, the picture keeps rolling along to its predictable Technicolored happy ending...

Watch for a rangy athlete: Woody Strode in his decorative supporting role saving Dale Robertson's life..
18 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Nice Dale Robertson Vehicle
boblipton30 April 2020
Army officer Dale Robertson arrives in New Orleans to settle his father's estate in antebellum New Orleans. His father had been a gambler, and an honest one, but he is shown evidence that he was cheating and killed for it by local aristocrat Kevin McCarthy, whose beautiful sister, Lisa Daniels, RObertson has rescued from a rainstorm. Despite her beauty, RObertson begins his Monte-Cristo-like course of vengeance. He is aided by riverboat captain Thomas Homez, and his daughter, Debra Paget, at her most sultry.

It's one of the series of handsome Technicolor 'shaky A' productions that Robertson starred in in this period. Robertson shows off some athleticism in a final epee duel with McCarthy. There's lots of careful camera composition by cinematographer Lloyd Ahern Sr. to cover the fact that Robertson is dueling with a stuntman.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Murdered with all the proprieties
bkoganbing29 May 2017
Dale Robertson stars in the title role as The Gambler From Natchez who has come home after a furloughed leave to join Sam Houston in Texas. Which would put the year at around 1836 in the ante-bellum south and in New Orleans.

Robertson has come home to visit his father whom he finds out has been killed. His father was a gambler by trade and he was murdered with all the proprieties of the Creole code covered. Robertson himself is a gambler and good one.

He identifies three men Kevin McCarthy, Douglas Dick, and John Weingraf, as the perpetrators and he's marked them in his little black book of revenge.

The comparisons of The Gambler From Natchez with films like Mississippi Gambler and The Iron Mistress are rather obvious. But a very astute previous reviewer saw the elements of The Count Of Monte Cristo here and I salute that person.

The most harrowing scene in the film is Robertson with a knife in his back eluding the people pursuing through the shore marshes of the Mississippi. Those pursuers included the overseer who put said knife in his back and some of his slave charges. I'm sure it was with a great sense of irony that 20th Century Fox filmed black people pursuing a white runaway in the swamp.

Later on said overseer meets a most timely end at the hands of Woody Strode. How many times did black man kill a slave overseer and suffered no consequences.

Aiding and abetting Robertson's cause is riverboat captain Thomas Gomez and daughter Debra Paget. McCarthy has a fetching sister in Lisa Daniel who also intrigues Robertson. You never know on which side she will fall.

The Gambler From Natchez is not as good as the other cited films, but it certainly holds its own in the entertainment department.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Quickest remake in Hollywood's history?
greenbudgie16 March 2022
There is some good action from Dale Robertson who appears to do all his own fight scenes in this movie. His fisticuffs and sword play are particularly good. Debra Paget is gorgeous as a bare-footed daughter of a riverboat captain played sympathetically by Thomas Gomez. It's an unusual period western with some good mystery attached. It's set in 1840s Mississippi's gambling dens and swamps. This was a swift remake of Tyrone Power's 'The Mississippi Gambler' the year before. That must make 'Natchez' one of the quickest remakes in Hollywood's history. The best scene in the movie has Robertson wading through a swamp at night with a knife in his back. He is being pursued by one of his father's three killers. He needs to solve the mystery behind his father's death and he uses the 3 of Spades as a revenge card. This card is cleverly incorporated into the film's poster with the 3 of Spades torn into three pieces.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent story of romance, revenge, and winning a fortune
weezeralfalfa13 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Dale Robertson plays a pre-Civil War soldier and gambler(Vance),whose father is a famous gambler, widely accused of being a cheat. The plot is rather similar to that in "The Mississippi Gambler", released just the year before. Our hero gambles fairly, in contrast to some of his competition, and desires to build a gambling establishment where winners have better skill or luck, rather than illegal tricks.

In the romance department, in both films, the hero has two gorgeous women to choose from: one an aristocrat, while the other is a commoner. In "The Mississippi Gambler", Ty Power chooses the stubborn aristocratic one, while in the present film, Vance chooses the barefoot river girl, Melanie(Debra Paget),who practically throws herself at him. In both cases, the younger ingénue is chosen. In the present film, we were not absolutely sure who Vance would choose until the ending. The very different personalities of the two ingénues is a big factor in making this film a more pleasant viewing experience(at least for men). I'm sure a significant factor in Vance's choice of Melanie over Ivette(Lisa Daniels),was the fact that Melanie saved his life twice from assailants. Besides, she was a real Barbee doll, as Captain Barbee, her father, would agree.

As in "The Mississippi Gambler", there are 3 main villains, 2 of whom relate to Ivette: her brother Andre, and her fiancé, Claude St. Germaine. Also, Nicholas Cadiz, owner of a large casino. In addition, there is a German gambler who is angry that Vance won all his money. He picks a fight with Vance, and is about to stab him in the back with a meat hook when Melanie lands a frying pan on his head.

So, how did Vance, who originally had no financial interest in either the steamboat Baton Rouge(BR) or the property Araby(where Ivette and family lived), wind up owning both in full? It's a rather complicated story. Thus, I will summarize it as I understand it:

Vance's father, often called 'Chip', invested a 25% interest in the boat BR, as did each of the following: Andre Rivago(Ivett's brother), Cadiz and Claude(Ivette's fiancé). Chip wagered with Andre their 25% shares in BR, and won. Next, Chip wagered his 50% interest in BR against the Rivago estate: Araby, and won. Andre became enraged and shot Chip dead, placing some doctored cards in his hand, thus negating his winnings. Hence, Vance inherits Chip's original 25% interest in the BR.

Later, Cadiz challenges Vance to a pistol duel for causing the gaming commissioner to close his casino, due to house cheating. Vance wins Cadiz's 25% interest in the BR by winning the duel, giving him a total of 50% interest in the BR. He now bets his 50% interest against Andre's 50% interest(Apparently, Andre obtained Claude's 25% interest, either in a wager I missed, or somehow after Claude was killed). Andre loses the wager. He now bets the Araby estate against Vance's full ownership of the BR, and loses. Andre becomes enraged and tries to kill Vance, but himself is mortally wounded. Thus, all of the 4 original partial owners of the BR are dead, and Vance is now the full owner of the ship and estate. However, he signs the Araby estate over to Ivette, since his quarrel was with her brother, not her. She invites him to share the estate with her, but he declines, saying his heart belongs with the Baton Rouge and Melanie.

In all, I found this obscure film to be of greater interest and enjoyment than "The Mississippi Gambler" or, indeed, most films of that era. You can see it on YouTube. I have one major caveat: How did the waiter manage to see and remember all the details of the card playing leading up to Chip's assassination?
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
River boat western
searchanddestroy-131 January 2023
This bland western made by Henry Levin belongs to the category of westerns that I will call "riverboat westerns", and taking place around Mississippi river as MISSISSIPPI GAMBLER, DUEL ON THE MISSISSIPPI, RAWHIDE YEARS, IRON MISTRESS and several others which I don't have titles now in my head. There is no Indian war, no cavalry, no desert of course, no small town, no sheriff. So it is more adventure movies than purely westerns. It is question of riverboats, gamblers, French descent supporting or not characters, honor duels at dawn in a field with witnesses. A quite good atmosphere. So, this remains a quite smooth and a bit boring time waster, but not a milestone in Henry Levin's career. Kevin McCarthy is excelelnt as the villain.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed