The Kid from Cleveland (1949) User Reviews

Not just history, there is a story too

[craig_smith9 · 7/10 · 15 May 2001]

I suppose that this is somewhat less than a good average film. On the other hand, I never was bored watching it and I intend to watch it again (no, not because I am an Indians fan--I'm not). Possibly this is due to the continued appearances of the 1948 Indians. This may be a movie, but historically where will you ever get another chance to hear those great players and see more of them than you get from a brief newsreel.

Plus, there really is a story beyond the baseball. It shows fairly well the results of poor communication, lack of communication, and miscommunication. It also shows the importance of caring for someone, how important that is, and how important it is to work at showing that you care. We sometimes forget that there does need to be an intensity to our relationships, that we need to consciously work on our relationships with others.

Johnny Barrows loses his father in the war. He becomes especially upset when his mother remarries. Through a misunderstanding, he never really takes to his stepfather. His behavior is best when he is with the Indians. It is not till the end that this is cleared up and that is helped by a story of Larry Doby's first days as an Indian.

For baseball fans a must

[bkoganbing · 6/10 · 1 April 2013]

Young Russ Tamblyn gets his first big break as a baseball crazy kid from Cleveland who is a devoted fan of the new World Series winners from 1948 the Cleveland Indians. Russ is having a lot of home issues with mother Ann Doran and stepfather Louis Jean Heydt and comes under the influence of street punk Tommy Cook.

However a counter influence develops when he sneaks into Municipal Stadium and meets up with manager/shortstop Lou Boudreau, owner Bill Veeck, Hank Greenberg who was now retired as a player and working in the Indians front office for Veeck and their team announcer George Brent.

It's Brent who takes an interest in the kid and takes him home to meet his wife Lynn Bari and their two daughters. Tamblyn has to make some critical life choices and we can only hope as viewers he does the right thing.

The movie itself is a decent and well played film about juvenile delinquency as seen in 1949 eyes. But it is a nice look back at the baseball scene of the time. Footage of the 1948 series and some regular season games are nicely integrated into the plot. The World Series film also gives us a chance to look at Braves Field which is no more in Boston as a big league ballpark. With the stands now down, the field serves as the playing ground for the Boston College team.

Such baseball Hall Of Famers like Greenberg, Boudreau, Tris Speaker, Bob Feller, Larry Doby, Joe Gordon and Satchel Paige do a fine job in playing themselves along with the other Indian ballplayers of the era. Come to think of it Bill Veeck is also in the Hall of Fame and I'm sure this film was part of his promotion which in the game of baseball was second to none.

The Kid From Cleveland is a decent enough family film, but for baseball fans especially from the Cleveland area, it's an absolute must.

Russ Tamblyn is fine in his first starring role...

[AlsExGal · 6/10 · 23 December 2023]

... as a troubled teen baseball fan who hates his stepfather (Louis Jean Heydt), sneaks into the baseball stadium and claims he's an orphan, befriending the Cleveland Indians sportscaster (George Brent) and the whole team (playing themselves) but still getting in trouble with the law because of his home life and hanging around with a local hoodlum. The kindly sportscaster had been an orphan himself so he takes the boy under his wing and tries to find a way to reform him and keep him off the streets, and even convinces his wife (Lynn Bari) they should adopt him.

Of course, various complications intervene so we can have a wholesome portrait of the juvenile justice system bringing families together. The scenes using actual newsreel footage from the 1948 World Series are obviously grainier, but the newly shot 1949 baseball footage is all pristine in the copy I saw. The story is pretty much standard formula with little in the way of surprise twists, but it's all nicely done, beautifully shot (again with several noir-like sequences), and certainly a must for baseball fans and fans of delinquent-teen dramas.

a very sentimental movie for me

[lammsf · 24 August 2005]

I was an "extra" in the movie, which was filmed at the end of street where I lived,near Hough Ave. It was very near League Park, at other end of my street! Some of the the kids in neighborhood were also in the movie, of course we were all not paid but did have a lot of fun with the "stars" and were treated to a ballgame, taken by bus, where we ran around under the bleachers. Have seen it a couple of times on AMC, but not in about last 6 yrs. or so. Was a bit of a "tearjerker" as brought back many memories of the days after WW11 and the pride we in Cleveland had, and I still have, for our Indians. Would love to have a copy,mainly to see if I could find myself among the kids. Can't find any on-line. Thanks for memories!

Of Historical Interest

[abenr · 2/10 · 9 May 2001]

Although a dreadful film, The Kid from Cleveland should be of more than routine interest to the baseball fan with a sense of history. Small cameo speaking appearances are made throughout by such baseball greats as Hank Greenberg, Bob Feller, Tris Speaker, Bill Veeck, Satchel Paige, Larry Doby -- well, just look at the cast. The players do more than just bat and pitch, the difference between this and most baseball movies.

A valentine for every boy who ever dreamed of the big leagues.

[mark.waltz · 6/10 · 22 August 2020]

Even with veteran Stars George Brent and Lynn Berry credited over the title in the sentimental drama that combines Sports and a light study of juvenile delinquency, the real star is the young Russ Tamblyn who would go on to greater things a decade later. He is a young boy, despondent over the death of his father, dealing with his non understanding stepfather Louis Jean Heydt and his emotionally torn mother, Ann Doran, and somehow getting into a bad crowd.

But his passion is baseball, and when he visits the Cleveland Indians stadium after a game, his future is set as thanks to sports reporter George brand, he is basically made the mascot for the team who is determined in their own quiet way to help him get past his problems. Tamblyn visits a psychiatrist who tries to get to the bottom of Tamblyn's issues, and lets Brent steps in to try and bring an understanding to help the family heal.

Yes, this is sentimental and somewhat sappy in spots, but with a winning performance by the young Cam, it's difficult not to care about him. Real-life ballplayers from the Indians portray themselves, and you get a real sense of teamwork and spirit as they obviously see their own childhood dreams in his eyes. This apparently was shot on location in Cleveland which gives additional reality to the film.

Not a terrible movie, but not really a baseball movie either

[richard-1787 · 4/10 · 15 August 2014]

This is not as terrible a movie as I had read. It's a typical "social problems" movie from the post-World War II era, of which more famous examples would be "The Asphalt Jungle," "The Snake Pit," etc. As such, it's about delinquent children, why they become delinquent, and what might be done to solve that issue. It's not very convincing, frankly, but it's not terrible, either. It's just that the script is bad, the acting second-rate, and the direction no better. Not terrible, but not in any way impressive.

And then there are the baseball players whom the one child delinquent admires, all real members of the 1949 Cleveland Indians. They don't talk much about baseball, we don't really see what their lives are like (with the exception of Larry Doby's at the end), etc. As such, the movie really isn't about baseball.

Early in the movie, the players muff some of their lines, though they do better later. They aren't movie stars, and they don't pretend to be.

I doubt anyone is going to want to watch this movie to see how to deal with child delinquency. Those interested in the history of baseball may well want to see some of these legendary Indians just stand around and talk. (They don't really try to do any acting, nor are they called on to do so.) There is some newsreel footage from the Indians' World Series 1948 season, though not a lot of it.

In short, this movie is a mixed bag. The social problems segments are like a run of the mill 1950s TV drama. The scenes with the legendary Indians are not great movie-making, but it's fun to see those guys when they were active players.

A Serious Film, And The Indians Too!

[boblipton · 6/10 · 4 December 2023]

Cleveland Indians radio color commentator George Brent discovers Russ Tamblyn (in his first movie role) hiding out in the stadium. He says he's an orphan from Chicago who wants to see the game, so the team members agree he can come ack, and Brent takes him home to wife Lynn Bari and their two daughters. It comes out that Tamblyn isn't from Chicago, but Cleveland, and his mother Ann Doran and stepfather, Louis Jean Heydt.

Looking at the 1948 World Champion Indians is a bonus here, and enough to extend the movie into first-feature length. It's a story about a troubled boy, and well-meaning adults who are at the end of their tethers. For the era, it's quite frank, with Miss Bari mentioning casually that she cannot have any more children, and Heydt getting to show some range. Amidst this story, you get shots of the 1949 Indians on the field and off.

A Heartfelt Baseball Film.

[meddlecore · 8/10 · 23 September 2020]

Little Johnny Barrows Jr is a kid from Cleveland, who lives with his loving Mom and Stepfather, but who is heading down the wrong path in life.

He doesn't get along with his Stepdad too well, so he's fallen in with a young hoodlum named Daniel, who idealizes a gang leader named Mac...who runs a crime syndicate of child thieves.

One day, Johnny runs away from home and uses his abilities as a con man to sneak in to the Cleveland Indians stadium, where he convinces the brass that he's an orphan.

They take pity on him and give him an oppourtunity to meet the players and take in a World Series game against the Boston Braves.

The team loses the game, but goes on to win the World Series. And this encourages Johnny to keep visiting the man who helped him that day...Mike Jackson, the teams radio announcer.

Despite conning Mike and even stealing from him, he never gives up on the boy...and goes on to become Johnny's mentor.

Johhny's real father died in World War II, and this new relationship with all his childhood heroes only makes him more antagonistic towards his stepfather, who is just a baker, and can't offer him that same sort of lifestyle.

So, when Johnny runs away for a second time to visit Mike, earning himself a job as a junior sportswriter and batboy for the Indians during spring training in Arizona...he feels that all his dreams are destroyed when his stepfather shows up to bring him back to Cleveland.

This leads Johnny to fall back in with Daniel, and a life of crime...landing him in detention at the Juvenile Court.

That is, until one day the Indians come to visit, reuniting him with all his old friends from the team...including Mike.

Mike is driven to help the boy- never having had a son of his own- and tries to help get him out of this seemingly hopeless situation...even going as far as offering to adopt him.

Johnny wants to be adopted by the well-to-do family...but his Mother and Stepfather are not willing to just give him out without a fight.

So the matter goes to court, where the Truth about the whole situation really comes out.

The court rules in his Mother's favour, but this does not mean that Mike, his wife, and his "30 Godfathers" from the team are just going to throw him away...so they promise to retain their friendship and relationship with him as the team's batsboy.

So Johnny ends up with 2 families, one that keeps him in touch with his heroes, and the other who help him work toward achieving his goal of becoming an architect.

Now, a boy who might have ended up in San Quentin, like his friend, has been directed down a more positive path in life.

This is a great story, that offers hope to kids who dream, but may not have been given all the prospects that life has to offer.

The acting and direction is solid, and the film features a whole load of real ball players from the Indians...including the now infamous Satchel Page.

It is certainly one of the best- and most inspiring- baseball films to have ever been made in the history of American Cinema.

All around, it's an entertaining and enjoyable film with a positive message, that will have you clapping at the end.

7.5 out of 10.