Key Witness (1947) Poster

(1947)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
One man's trash......another man's treasure
kalbimassey19 July 2022
Mechanical genius.......or just an eccentric oddball, who might attempt to cross a turkey with a banjo in the hope of producing a bird capable of plucking itself? Sullen supervisor (Harry Hayden) clearly thinks the latter of docile draughtsman, John Beal's fanciful ideas, having no time for his talking clock or innovative interactive light switch. Beal's stock falls even further, when he damages a gift bought for the company boss. Without complaint, the compliant Beal shells out for a replacement.

Domestic life paints a similar picture. Despite a loving wife (Barbara Read), his noble ambitions have fallen foul of the 'too young, too old, wrong time, wrong place' mindset. He's little more than Mr. Mop.....with his talking clock! During his wife's absence, he is initially hesitant about a day at the races (the track meeting, not the movie!), as he has promised to clean up at home. In the event, he cleans up at the track, but celebrations are short lived when he becomes the chief suspect (despite tenuous evidence) in the murder of a female acquaintance. Once again Beal turns out to be the dripping tap, rather than the water cannon, choosing to run away and exist as a hobo. Stealing the documents and adopting the identity of a dead drifter becomes a life changing experience of mammoth proportions, but will his wacky, quirky gadgets be the making or the breaking of him?

Devoid of both a big budget and a big name, 'Key Witness' succeeds by virtue of a big heart. Well acted and consistently satisfying, unconventionally bouncy, buoyant and frothy, but tempered by a pervading dark, forbidding undercurrent and an unnerving twist. An enlightened curiosity, a rare bird......a novelty noir.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Martha's Slipper is a winner.
ulicknormanowen7 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
In spite of its title ,"key witness", is only partly a thriller : it is often sometimes closer to comedy ( the hero at the races ,later accused of plagiarizing himself ,even of ...killing himself ,it's almost Kafka in miniature) ,with elements of pure melodrama (the father who finds back his estranged "son" after all those years ) thrown in for good measure .

The talking clock is a good trick (I wish I had one ) and the hero is very endearing : humiliated and treated like a slave by his second-in command , told off by his wife who blames him for making a financial contribution to his boss' birthday present....and finally sentenced to death (this scene ,IMHO , comes at the most awkward moment ,only to justify the title)

But the rest is thoroughly enjoyable.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A few coincidences too many.
planktonrules27 April 2024
The plot to "Key Witness" is one that is filled with many crazy coincidences...so many that you have to completely suspend disbelief in order to enjoy the movie.

Milton Higby is a pretty normal sort of guy who has lived a relatively unimportant life. One day, when his wife is away to see her aunt, he goes to the racetrack and makes a bet which earns him a small fortune. He naturally celebrates and gets pretty drunk...and a woman he barely knows lets him sleep it off in her bedroom. While he's sleeping, the woman's crazed ex-husband arrives and murders her...and vanishes. Now people think Milton is a killer...and he hit the road to avoid the police. While a hobo, he stumbles upon a body. He takes a few things off the body...after all, the dead guy's not going to need it. Almost immediately after, he steps off a curb and is hit by a car. He lands in the hospital and based on the things in his pocket belonging to the dead guy, they think he's a rich guy's long lost son. Milton tries to convince them he isn't...but after a while, he gives up and goes along with it. After all, life as Milton Higby isn't an especially good idea! What's next? See the film.

Despite being a film with a bad plot, it's STILL interesting and possibly worth seeing. In other words, you really need to suspend disbelief in order to enjoy what you're watching...and you REALLY need to suspend disbelief repeatedly. My suggestion is still watch the movie...accepting its limitations but also understanding that the story, though unbelievably farfetched, is worth seeing.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Quite entertaining little thriller
searchanddestroy-117 April 2011
Warning: Spoilers
A rare gem, this D Ross Lederman movie. Hard to find. Made for Columbia Pictures and about the story of an ordinary guy, an architect, who is also an inventor of things no one is interested in. Our guy wins a small fortune. And that's when his troubles begin.

Surprising story I won't spoil but, believe me, you can watch it with a great pleasure. A very good B movie from the late 40's. We have seen this kind of film some times before, but what matters? Why avoiding our own pleasure just because of this?

B movies often give good surprises !!! and I guess there are many of them we have not seen yet. Let's cross our fingers.
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Beal Takes The Rough And Smooth
boblipton14 August 2022
John Beal is a hardworking office worker. He's supervised by petty tyrant Harry Hayden, and things are no better at home, where his wife, Barbara Read, berates him for not getting ahead. Then one day, while Miss Read is out of town, Beal's pl drags him to the horse races, where Beal hits the daily double on a couple of long shots. He tells Hayden off, and is spending some of the money on a good time when the girl he is with has her ex-husband come in and shoot her dead. Terrified by the thought of being found guilty of murder, Beal becomes a hobo for several years. Then one day he winds up in the hospital, where he is mistaken for a rich industrialist's son, who the man has not seen since he was two.

Although this might have made a nice two-reel movie, or perhaps an episode of the Alfred Hitchcock show, it goes on way too long, with Beal being an inert lump who absorbs good and bad luck like a bean bag. At a shorter length, it might have some sardonic wit. But at 67 minutes, you have time to despise every character in it.

Fortunately for Beal, he was another of those actors who didn't need the silver screen. He lived for another fifty years and prospered, on stage and big and little screens, dying in 1997 at the age of 87.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Twisty tiny thriller
adrianovasconcelos22 April 2022
A short flick lasting 66' with a largely unknown cast, this shoestring production actually had me riveted throughout thanks to an imaginative script, sharp dialogue, an unassuming leading male character (no frills from John Beal, apart from the apparently useless gadgets he keeps inventing), his disappointed and downputting wife in a surprisingly cynical role by Barbara Read and Charles Trowbridge in a short but effective part as the father of the dead character Beal gets to impersonate.

Better cinematography than this type of C production tended to have.

I thoroughly enjoyed it!
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed