Victory Song (1945) Poster

(1945)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Self Sacrifice and Unity
freddyschmitz31 March 2021
"My patriotic sentiment won't allow me to experience joy."

Late World War 2 propaganda by Imperial Japan, directed by no more than 8 directors, including the great Kenji Mizoguchi and Hiroshi Shimizu. This movie consists of a bunch of patritotic anecdotes from various social strata of japanese society rather than a coherent linear story which was probably the result of having too many director working together. These anecdotes all circle around the themes of self sacrifice of the individual for motherland Japan and the emperor which is all one and the same thing. The japanese believed the emperor to be the direct descendant of Amaterasu, the sun goddess who sent her grandson to earth, who spawned the first Tenno who is one with the japanese people, meaning they are also of divine origin since they make up one single entity. Thus betraying emperor Hirohito (who was believed to be part of an unbroken chain of god-emperors) by not fulfilling your duty, be it as a soldier, a nurse, a wife or a student, would be the same as betraying your true self because the one is connected to the many, devaluing the "free individual" in favor of unity, homeland and duty. This film replaces "freedom" solely understood as the abscence of restrictions (a purely modern concept) with the freedom to fulfill ones duty according to ones own nature, imbedded in a hierarchy of a higher order (a primordial concept).

The difference of these two perceptions of what "freedom" constitutes is the difference between a liberal-democratic, secular and "enlightened" society and a primordial, traditional one.

The aforementioned anecdotes range from soldiers on the front reminiscing about their home, factory workers, a young boy applying for flying school behind his father's back, a police officer wandering his district, pupil marching through the japanese forests, a woman marrying a soldier before he is drafted, the civilian defense force quenching fires that were caused by air raids, a woman telling about an incident in which the americans sunk a ship full of wounded soldiers and fathers of kamikaze pilots drinking with their late sons army superiors.

The reason for this long introduction was meant to put the tone of this movie into context. It's pretty light hearted and optimistic considering the topics it dealt with. Not once is a character weeping for a lost son or husband, despairing over the hardships of the great war, then going on for 8 years. Especially the episode of the police man and the marching pupils reminded me of a japanese Heimatfilm, showing everyday life of japanese civilians during the war, a couple of humoristic scenes. There also is alot of singing. Even during the second to last scene, the fathers of the dead kamikaze pilots are cheerful and full of pride for their heroic sons, not once selfishly sheding tears for a kid lost, since they died for a higher order, fulfilling their duty to the Tenno. When mundane life is understood as merely one stage of human existence and individual life being inseperately connected to your people and the emperor, flying headfirst into the enemy is not as tragic as it sounds.

To wrap it all up, this movie is a bit all over the place, the narrative just being an excuse to shed light on the theme of self sacrifice, always from the same angle, concluding that determination and disregard for the detached, atomized individual is the only way worth living. With a runtime of only 80 minutes it is a moderately interesting display of the self-conception of Imperial Japan.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Victory Is Inevitable
boblipton31 October 2019
It's a collection of patriotic anecdotes. In the field, an officer rises from a shelling to lead his troops in reminiscing about home. A young woman has a marriage proposal withdrawn because the man has received his draft notice, and she insists on marrying him now. An old man goes out to shovel snow so the train can get through. His son offers to help, but is refused, so he can work in the munitions plant the next day. A father scolds his son for not asking him for permission to join the aviation school. Did he think he would refuse permission? Of course not! An old man walks through his village, making sure that everything is in top notch shape. Young boys work in munitions plants after school, and women too. A young girl tells the tale of the enemy planes bombing the clearly marked hospital ship. Battle front home front, if we all do our best, victory is inevitable and Japan will win the war.

This is the sort of patriotic flag waver that every nation produced during the Second World War.... although in the US and Great Britain, such messages were usually wrapped inside a story. This is just an series of anecdotes, some of which, like the commandant of the Kamikaze force, getting drunk with the fathers of the dead pilots, everyone very pleased about it, seem peculiarly Japanese. Although this was not an expensive film, it used eight directors, including Masahiro Makino, Kenji Mizoguchi, Hiroshi Shimizu, Tomotaka Tasaka, Tatsuo Osone, Koishi Takagi and Tetsuo Ichikawa. Major stars like Mieko Takamine and Ken Uehara took small roles. Just like American, Russian and British movies I have seen. I'm still waiting to see a German one.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed