Mystery Man (1944) User Reviews

Hoppy Impersonated!

[museumofdave · 6/10 · 4 July 2015]

It's a fascinating comment on "B" Westerns, and possibly on films in general, that one of the reviews on this site plugs this simple Western film as one the "better Hoppy films," while one of the other five cites it as "lesser Hoppy." Both reviewers are right, of course, and each took the time to comment from separate viewpoints. In a world as big as the Wild West, there should be plenty of room for both opinions. Too bad the world isn't so big any more!

Black-clad, cool-headed Hopalong Cassidy (William Boyd) must track down lawbreakers and get the guys in the slammer--and wouldn't it be a surprise to all of us if he failed to do so? Most Hoppy films have a distinguishing hallmark, and perhaps this one's is a Movable Herd and the men who move it.

Mystery Man is a low-key, genial cowboy movie with only one song tossed in for good measure, and the sheriff's daughter picking on whatever attractions Hoppy's second- hand man has to offer. For action fans, there is a good deal of gun-play behind boulders and dust-raising in Lone Pine, and' as is often the case, the cinematography by Russell Harlan is a major bonus point, taking what could show as dull chases and enhancing California desert landscape with background mountain majesties and banks of clouds. Harlan turns the ordinary into memorable--lucky us!

Those annoying Trillings!!!

[planktonrules · 7/10 · 10 October 2020]

When the story begins, Hoppy and workers from the Bar 20 help a town in their fight against the notorious Trilling Gang. They subdue the gang and jail them. However, when Bud Trilling himself arrives in disguise, he helps the gang escape. Now you'd think the gang would run for the hills, but instead they hide in the desert and wait for the Bar 20 workers to take their herd to market...and then they jump them and steal the herd for revenge. But, eventually Hoppy and the workers escape...and retake the herd. Now you'd think that would be the end of it....but it isn't. Now Trilling, posing as Hoppy, has Hopalong and the workers arrested! And, the sheriff is apparently an idiot! What's next? See the film.

Like most of the Hopalong Cassidy films, this one is very good. So, instead of seeming like a B-western,...it's almost like a B+ western....if there was such a thing. Exciting, fun and full of action.

By the way, if you want to see this and any of the other Hopalong Cassidy films, check for them on YouTube. This is because they have the best possible copies...fully restored to their original length and in pristine condition. I've enjoyed them so much that this is the 65th one I've seen...and only have one more to go!

No mystery to us

[bkoganbing · 6/10 · 18 March 2017]

This Hopalong Cassidy film Mystery Man has Hoppy dealing with the Bud Trilling gang. The title of the film comes from the fact that while we know that Trilling is actor Don Costello he's not known to anyone other than his gang. No wanted posters with likeness are circulated so consequently he can move around pretty freely.

Bill Boyd, Jimmy Rogers, and Andy Clyde at the beginning of the film happen to be in town when the gang pulls a holdup at the bank and in a very thrilling gun battle they're captured and hauled away to jail. Costello frees them however and the rest of the movie is a running battle between the Bar 20 crew and the Trilling gang. Costello is a resourceful foe, but you know comes out on top.

Costello certainly regretted he and the gang decided to diversify from holdups to cattle rustling.

Unusual Hoppy movie -- one long caper of rustling Hoppy's herd

[chipe · 6/10 · 12 March 2015]

This is a fair Hoppy movie. I bother to review it to point out one unusual thing. Virtually all of the Hoppy movies entail some kind of mystery or some clever way to flush out the bad guys, get the goods on them. ***Spoilers*** This Hoppy movie is very different! In this oater, after Hoppy helps capture the Trilling gang (but not Trilling himself, who is unknown outside of his gang) at the start of the movie, from there until the conclusion of the movie it is one long caper: the bad guys getting out of jail to rustle Hoppy's 1000-head of cattle being driven for sale at the Circle J, and Hoppy recapturing and losing the herd, etc.

(1) The Trilling gang rustles Hoppy's herd by sneaking up to the cowboys' downtime camp, scattering the cowboys' horses and making off with the herd.

(2) Hoppy and his men gather their horses, follow the herd, chase off the rustlers and regain the herd.

(3) The rustlers pretend to be a posse of lawmen, get the drop of Hoppy, tie up Hoppy and his men at their hideout, and go off with the herd.

(4) Hoppy and men escape the hideout, but before they can regain the herd, Trilling has pretended he is Hopalong, owner of the herd, and Trilling sics the local Sheriff on the real Hoppy and company, who are thrown in jail.

(5) The Sheriff's daughter knows the truth, so she breaks the real Hoppy and crew out of jail, and they finally apprehend the Trilling gang.

One of the better Hoppies!

[stevehaynie · 7/10 · 22 May 2006]

Although Mystery Man is no contender for the best Hopalong Cassidy movie ever made, it is definitely among the better movies in the series. The action moves from one city to the next as Hoppy drives a herd of Bar 20 cattle to its destination. This parallels the story as it moves steadily toward its climax.

The villain, Bud Trilling (Don Costello), is introduced to the viewer early on, but Hoppy and the law do not expose Trilling until the end. During the course of the movie Trilling is a faceless villain who is able to enter towns and encounter sheriffs without fear of recognition. During a bank holdup by Trilling's gang, Hoppy, California, and Jimmy join the fight against the bank robbers. Jimmy's life is saved by a visiting young lady named Diane Newhall (Eleanor Stewart). She explains that her father taught her how to shoot and that he is the sheriff in the same town where Jimmy will be at the end of his cattle drive. This brief meeting pays off later in the movie. Trilling works up a scheme to steal both the Bar 20 herd and the money at the end of the trail while leaving Hoppy and his men at the mercy of the law.

No one stays put in Mystery Man. As soon as there is enough action in the first town, the story moves on to the cattle drive. During the cattle drive there is one musical performance which is rare in a Hopalong Cassidy movie, but it fits the scene well. Events along the way keep the story interesting then move to the last destination. There is no tired feeling from too much action in one place.

With a bigger budget this could have been a great movie.

"Spread out here boys, and keep your eyes open!"

[classicsoncall · 6/10 · 26 September 2017]

Say, did you get a good look at the Trilling Gang during the opening of the story when all those newspaper headlines blared the gang's robberies? In between stories, the gang looked like it had over twenty riders! That's a lot of bad guys to divvy up the loot with. If I were Bud Trilling (Don Costello), I think I'd have cut a few of those guys loose.

The story starts out with a bank robbery in the town of Holbrook, with Hopalong Cassidy (William Boyd) and his pals Jimmy (Jimmy Rogers) and California (Andy Clyde) on hand as part of a Bar-20 cattle drive. Hoppy and a few of the town locals pull a move I don't think I've seen before - they block the exit out of town with a couple of wagons in the middle of the street. This made me wonder why the outlaws didn't turn around and go the other way, but just as well. They're put in the calaboose by Marshall Blane (Jack Rockwell), and Hoppy can return to the trail with his men.

Meanwhile, Bud Trilling himself remains incognito as a well dressed businessman, and hangs around to help spring his top henchman Bert Rogan (Francis McDonald) and the rest of his men out of jail by passing him a weapon. From there on in, it's a see-saw game of the baddies and the Bar-20 crew gaining the upper hand. Trilling even impersonates Cassidy by warning Sheriff Sam Newhall (Forrest Taylor) that Hoppy and his men intend to steal his cattle!

Well no need to tell you how this thing turns out. With the help of the sheriff's daughter (Eleanor Stewart), this time Hoppy's guys make a jailbreak and take it to the bad guys for a final showdown among the Alabama Hills of Lone Pine, California. It's a tribute to Hoppy's skill and ingenuity that after so many adventures, he's able to come out on top while all during the story, he spent a good deal of time with both hands tied behind his back.

Altogether one of the more minor Hopalong Cassidy entries

[wrbtu · 9 May 2003]

Set in Holbrook in the 1880s, Hoppy is dressed all in black (usually a good sign, but not always). On the positive side, there's lots of action & gunfights (four in all), & the heroine is especially helpful (she's a Sheriff's daughter). On the negative side, Jimmy Rogers is as wooden as always, the comedy is not too funny, the plot seems rushed between horse chases, & most of all, there's no real sense of toughness from Hoppy. Altogether one of the more minor Hopalong Cassidy entries.

I rate it 5/10.

Average

[coltras35 · 5/10 · 4 March 2022]

Hoppy, California & Jimmy Rogers set out to stop a gang of bank robbers led by a man pretending to be respectable citizen In this average Hoppy western that ticks the boxes and nothing more, though it's still dependable entertainment. The title is a little confusing as there's no one in the film resembling a mystery man. It can't refer to the main villain as he doesn't stay a mystery for long.