Earthbound (1940) User Reviews

Curious little fantasy

[scsu1975 · 5/10 · 17 November 2022]

Warner Baxter gets bumped off by ex-flame Lynn Bari, becomes a ghost, and trys to help his wife (Andrea Leeds) prove Bari did it. Meanwhile, Bari's hubby, played by Henry Wilcoxon, takes the rap. Charley Grapewin shows up dressed in black, looking like Harry Carey playing Bela Lugosi in the early scenes from "Plan 9 From Outer Space." Grapewin is apparently the only one who can see and hear Baxter. He ain't no Whoopi Goldberg though. Elizabeth Patterson, who played Mrs. Trumbull on "I Love Lucy," has a prominent role, but looks older here than she did on "Lucy." I kept waiting for her to say "oh, nuts."

I like Baxter in most of his roles - he is no great actor, but he always seems to have a likeable presence. Bari is a bit too overwrought as the "other woman." Leeds was new to me - she retired after making this film.

We never quite figure out who Grapewin is supposed to be, and the ending is a little ambiguous. Yet, at around 67 minutes, the film moves right along and will probably keep you interested. A bonus is Alfred Newman's fine score.

"Dead man haunted by the living!"

[moonspinner55 · 5/10 · 1 October 2008]

Light drama and sentiment mixes reasonably well for this thin story involving an American businessman in Europe who is shot to death by a former flame; he ends up attending his own murder trial in ghostly form, only to see the wrong person convicted for the crime. Why another person should accept blame (and life in prison) for a killing they didn't commit is something the picture never takes the time to iron out, and Warner Baxter is initially a dismaying hero with little personality (he improves however, as does the film after a slow start). Charley Grapewin is terrific as a Bible-reading stranger who can converse with Baxter's ghost, and Elizabeth Patterson is also very good as a busy-body. The film itself is extremely slight, with one special effect which becomes rather tedious, though director Irving Pichel keeps the narrative fairly tight and drives the movie to a satisfying wrap-up. ** from ****

Weepy supernatural melodrama

[JohnSeal · 4/10 · 12 October 2003]

This gooey concoction stars Warner Baxter as a happily married businessman murdered by the woman he previously spurned (Lynn Bari). His ghost, unable to rest because Bari's loyal husband (Henry Wilcoxon) is taking the rap for her, returns from the grave to make sure wife Andrea Leeds somehow determines the truth. He's aided along the way by the one man on Earth who can see him and talk to him: a pontificating bible-thumper played by Charley Grapewin. We don't learn what makes Grapewin so special--he doesn't seem to be a Mr. Jordan like angel or a Cedric Hardwicke style Grim Reaper--but his handy King James Bible apparently supplies him with a communication system to the beyond. Baxter spends the film tagging along behind Leeds, nagging her from beyond the grave until she stumbles across the evidence needed to free Wilcoxon and put Bari away. The deceased hubby can than, apparently rest in peace (whatever THAT may entail), as he bids a platitudinous farewell to the annoying Grapewin, who shuffles off stage as Baxter picks up a dead (?) bird, presumably symbolic of something. If you enjoy seeing death infantilized to the nth degree (or simply enjoy Christian mythology), Earthbound is for you.

Mood swings plague this missed opportunity that turns out to be an interesting failure.

[mark.waltz · 4/10 · 23 September 2014]

Everything starts off on the right mood for this supernatural romance that switches jarringly between comedy and drama and ultimately hits the wrong notes. Warner Baxter plays a charming scandal who seems happily married to Andrea Leeds but is plagued with a fatal attraction of a mistress (Lynn Bari) who happens to be married to his best friend (Henry Wilcoxin). She arranges for a confrontation which results in shots being fired, and immediately, his spirit leaves his body, a la Patrick Swayze in "Ghost". A farce of a trial follows with Wilcoxin accused and Bari desperately trying to hide her identity from a witness who saw her with the deceased. Baxter looks on, spouting like a fool who keeps forgetting he's a ghost and that nobody can see him or hear him. The whole courtroom scene just gets more and more maddening, going between the farce of a fool of a witness to everybody violently over-acting.

Like Clarence, the angel in the not yet made "It's a Wonderful Life", Baxter has his own mystical being, the wise, old Charley Grapewin who guides him in several scenes with the little grace that the film has. Elizabeth Patterson, as Leeds' companion, seems to have no other purpose her than to spout wisecracks about Bari, ready to let her husband take the rap for murder and return to America. Baxter continuously haunts his wife to get her to psychologically hear him so she can find the weapon that killed him and clear the imprisoned Wilcoxin.

Sumptuously crafted, this is one of the best looking of the ghost films of this era, dating back to "Topper" and continuing with fantasies like "On Borrowed Time", "Here Comes Mr. Jordan" and "The Devil and Daniel Webster". Yet, as riveting as it is, it doesn't completely satisfy because it all seems to be a bit too much, like an opera overstuffed with chorus but little substance. I can definitely call this well intended, and didn't entirely feel cheated, but I wished that it had all come together in a tighter package than what ended up being released.

Seen on Pittsburgh's Chiller Theater in 1976

[kevinolzak · 4/10 · 11 January 2014]

1940's "Earthbound" is a rare change for suave Warner Baxter, and his last at 20th Century-Fox (by 1943, he would begin the 'Crime Doctor' series at Columbia). Happily married to a much younger wife, Ellen (Andrea Leeds), we soon learn Nick Desborough hasn't exactly been a faithful husband, as his spurned lover Linda (Lynn Bari) has left her own husband for Nick, who refuses to pick up with her again because he genuinely loves Ellen and cares about Linda's husband Jeffrey (Henry Wilcoxon). All attempts to persuade Linda to return to Jeffrey result in the jilted woman shooting her former lover dead, whereupon his ghost instantly exits his body, failing to comprehend what has happened, or why no one can see or hear him. There is one man who communicates with the deceased Nick, Mr. Whimser (Charley Grapewin), who met the murder victim aboard a train only hours before his death. Nick learns that Jeffrey has confessed to killing him, returning to his widowed wife to find out what he can do to convince her to right the wrongs that have taken place. Warner Baxter has to play opposite no one for nearly the entire movie; there's a better picture in there somewhere, but not with this script. Even the luminous Andrea Leeds, in her final role, is given little to work with, while Lynn Bari is sadly out of her depth. The rarely seen "Earthbound" made one appearance on Pittsburgh's Chiller Theater, June 12 1976 (following 1954's "Creature from the Black Lagoon").

1940 Special Effects

[tdelaney1 · 8/10 · 10 October 2003]

Dig those 1940 special effects, Wow! Super-imposed ghost is the star. Lots of funny scenes, especially in courtroom where the murdered man's ghost is trying to help expose the real murderer. Actually this movie is mush for muddled minds, great for late night or lazy afternoon.