Those High Grey Walls (1939) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Once a small town doctor, always a small town doctor, even the big house.
mark.waltz7 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
If there ever was a rival for Dr. Christian, the radio and brief movie series MD played by Jean Hersholt, it's the small town doctor played by Walter Connolly in this prison drama. At the very beginning of the film, he's heading out of town and his destination is prison. He allegedly aided someone he had brought into the world after being shot, and that has gotten him sent to prison with no mercy. He longs to work in my prison hospital, but doctor Onslow Stevens wants no part of him. It takes a while, but Connelly eventually gets him to come out of his shell and reveal the cynical reasoning for the way he treats patients. This being prison, there's an attempted breakout, and Connelly, having won the respect of the guards and other prisoners along the way, ends up a hero, when he was all along.

Having one great acclaim as a character actor in many Frank Capra movies and screwball comedies of the 1930's, Connelly was always a delight to see in movies because he reminded everybody of their next door neighbor: the neighbor who greets you on your way to work, gives you his newspaper on the train, and wishes you a good day even though you're regretting it. In this film, he's practically a saint, and you really have to take his goodness as it comes. Certainly, he's a pest when it comes to doing what's right in prison as far as Stevens is concerned, but you know that attitude will change.

As I have been studying the films of 1939, I have come up with several that are never mentioned as some of the year's best, all but forgotten outside of obsessive classic movie fans like myself. In watching this, I realized that prisons have to exist but if I were to have to go to one or working one, I would want someone like Connelly there on my side. When things become really tough for him in prison, accused of something he did not do, I truly prayed that things would work out for him, forgetting that this is a work of fiction and that it's all made up from someone's creative mind. That's what powerful movies do, no matter what era they come from. This may not ever be as well known as all those 1939 films that everybody who loves classic movies talks about, but it certainly deserves its place among those that represent what movie makers can do when they take a great idea and work hard to get it right.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the finest "B" movies of the 1930s! You MUST see this one!
JohnHowardReid18 May 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Warmth, simplicity and freshness are qualities so unusual in the prison film that their presence in Those High Grey Walls has all the surprise of a violet's growing in a jail-yard. Manfully resisting most of the theme's obvious lures, from clattering jute mills to chattering machine guns, the film has chosen to go its way as drama rather melodrama. And through the admirable performances of Walter Connolly, Onslow Stevens and a few others, it has gone that way with complete interest and plausibility.

It is the story of a small-town doctor whose wisdom, tolerance and gentleness have grown through a score of years in the service of life. His prison offence was part of that tolerance: he had tended and shielded an outlaw simply because he knew the boy and his mother. And in prison, although the young doctor there derided his philosophy and tried to cure him of it, he still insisted that men remained men, whether murderers and thieves, and stood in dignity in the old, old relationship between patient and doctor. In time his philosophy has won another convert, for the young physician is healed of his bitterness and prepares to start afresh.

Director Charles Vidor has spun the plot smoothly, spotlighting the prison background in significant bits of action but never letting it overshadow its quiet central figure, the old country doctor. Mr Connolly has played him wisely and well, with a good trouper's recognition of the faint line between mawkishness and sentiment.

Mr Stevens's portrayal of the taciturn, memory-ridden prison doctor is properly reticent, grave and sincere, and there are well handled minor characterizations by Bernard Nedell and Paul Fix. The screenplay was written by Lewis Meltzer and Gladys Lehman from a story by William A. Ullman, Jr.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed