She Had to Eat (1937) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Always nice to find new classics nobody has ever heard of.
mark.waltz6 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
As a froggy voiced live action version of Elmer Fudd, Eugene Pallette steals this screwball comedy with songs that features "The Wizard of Oz's" Tin Man (Jack Haley) as a country bumpkin whose large pet hare becomes Pallette's target. Before you can say "What's Up Doc?", Pallette's personality changes, and not recognizing Haley, he throws him off his private train even though his loyal valet (Arthur Treacher) insists Pallette invited him aboard. In the big city, Haley is mistaken for a look-alike gangster, and joins forces with con-artist Rochelle Hudson to find new and clever ways to find a free meal, all the while trying to avoid the law and the screwy Pallette.

Amusing, light comedy fare, this is filled with interesting characterizations, especially Franklin Pangborn as a fussy foreign car salesman (delightfully sniffing in disgust when Haley compares it to a tractor), then treating Haley and Hudson to a lavish lunch simply because he believes them to be involved in the oil business. The very quiet "waskilly wabbit" steals every moment he's on screen simply because he's totally adorable. The songs don't add much but some sophisticated glamor, but contribute greatly to the unique atmosphere, especially when Hudson sings a jazzy contemporary song to show up the hammy, untalented old lady who headlines boring social events and needs to be put out to pasture.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Eugene Palette's frog voice dominates this mediocre comedy
hollywoodlegend24 January 2014
I bought a copy of this film to see Jack Haley, the man with the beautiful eyes and pretty face. Haley keeps getting mistaken for a criminal and is continually asked to take his pants down for a positive i.d. at the police station. Didn't see that coming! Rochelle Hudson does a bit of singing. I was more concerned about what would happen to Haley's pet rabbit Cactus (nothing bad happens to him) than about any of the characters.

Eugene Palette's unmistakable and unpleasant voice seemed to dominate the film. Haley didn't get a chance to shine. The comedy was weak and the story largely forgettable. Sorry for the downer of a review. I was hoping for more Jack Haley highlights.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed