Gun Law (1933) Poster

(1933)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Sidelining Mr Hoxie!
JohnHowardReid16 May 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I always wanted to see Jack Hoxie. A big, big star in silent westerns, he made only six sound films (aside from a fleeting bit in "Phantom Express") of which this is the second last.

Naturally, I assumed that he was playing the part of Tony Andrews, who is the central figure in the opening scenes. What a shock when the personable Tony Andrews character is killed! (Also a surprise to find out later that the actor was actually Paul Fix. He doesn't look like Paul Fix, he doesn't sound like Paul Fix, he doesn't act like Paul Fix. But he is! Mr Fix is obviously a much more versatile actor than we usually give him credit for).

Anyway, as we knew Harry Todd's Blackjack all right, that left as a likely candidate only the Sonora Kid, played by this big, hulking Lon Chaney Junior imitator. I was not impressed. Hoxie is easily the least interesting performer in the entire cast. Not only that, he and director Lewis D. Collins allow everyone else to steal all his scenes. At first it's Paul Fix. When Fix bows out, Harry Todd takes over, and when Todd is pushed aside, it's J. Frank Glendon as Nevada Smith (alias the Sonora Kid—don't ask me how that happens) who does the pushing!

Other players who contribute to sidelining Mr Hoxie include the lovely Betty Boyd as our agreeable heroine, Nita Hammond; Mary Carr as Mrs Andrews, the dead man's blind mother; Otto Lederer as the talkative barber; William Burt as the reluctant-to-pay banker; Bob Burns as the marshal; and yet another super-sympathetic old lady, Emma Tansey, who also has a key role in the plot. Not to mention "Dynamite", the horse.

Director Collins handles it all with reasonable "B" competency.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
early Talkie western with J Hoxie
ksf-22 December 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Spoilers - This EARLY western is a short shortie, at only 53 minutes. GUN LAW comes as part of a two DVD set from TCM.com, accompanied by Blue Steel, the "A" feature. The sound and picture quality are both pretty bad, and most of the scenes are quite dark, making it hard to follow. The picture opens with three cowboys reading a newspaper, where Tony's ma is looking for the where-abouts of her son. The only problem is, they are wanted now, and have their pictures on "wanted" posters. Jack Hoxie is "the Sonora Kid", who parts ways with Nevada Smith (Frank Glendon) and the rest of the old gang. Tony gets knocked off, so they head back to Tony's home, and the trouble begins. When the Sonora Kid pretends to be the dead man for his family's sake , Nevada shows up and blackmails him or he will spill the beans. The script and the acting are both pretty iffy, and I would suggest seeing one of the stronger remakes of this story. This film was made near the start of the talkies, and they DO get extra credit for the amount of outdoor filming they did. Hoxie had been making movies for 20 years by this time, and this was the second to last one that he made, according to wikipedia. Also note that "Dynamite the Wonder Horse" is even listed in the opening credits. This version from Echo Bridge is only 53 minutes long, and also includes a text biography of Jack Hoxie on the same DVD.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed