As the Earth Turns (1934) User Reviews

A fantasy world of country life that us city folk can only dream of.

[mark.waltz · 7/10 · 22 January 2013]

Yes, there is a simpler life somewhere out there, but truthfully, it really ain't so simple. Country folk in Maine have to deal with many issues-the elements of weather, lack of money for the replacement of cattle ("It broke its leg and I had to shoot it", the farmer actually gets to say), desires for college and land sold before they could buy it, and bitter resentments hidden inside each member of this family. This slice of life drama opens on a beautiful winter setting (straight out of Currier and Ives and Saturday Evening Post) is a vision that these people's lives are quiet as complicated as city folks, only with different characteristics.

The plot is slim, but beautifully presented and well acted by a large ensemble cast lead by Jean Muir, a talented and beautiful leading lady whose career was rather short-lived and filled with controversy. "The Wizard of Oz's" Clara Blandick pre-dated her Kansas farm woman here as the family matriarch, and gives a multi-faceted performance being simultaneously loving, resentful and strong. The handsome Donald Woods is rather bland as the next door neighbor, son of Polish immigrants who falls in love with the indecisive Muir but turns to her selfish younger sister when Muir turns down his marriage proposal. The characterizations of the Polish parents is fortunately lacking in stereotype, which usually presents them as overly cheery and eager to please in their new country. These elders originally settled in Boston before taking their chance in the country, so they know a bit more about American life than some of the uppity country folk think they do. Subtle prejudices are revealed towards them, a realistic touch for the hard-hitting depression era.

This film reminds us of the importance of the land and particularly reminded me of my growing up in the country in my pre-teen years with the memories of the picturesque farmhouse, huge barn, peach orchards and memories of people who seemed provincial but really were just fighting for their own dreams and ideals while the rest of the country looked on them as simpletons.

Rather dull, but an interesting historical portrait nonetheless.

[planktonrules · 5/10 · 16 February 2009]

Despite AS THE EARTH TURNS being a pretty dull little film, I am actually glad the studio decided to make it. That's because although the subject matter is tough to make exciting, it's a nice historical portrait of a way of life that has long since disappeared. AS THE EARTH TURNS is the story about some farmers who had extremely hard lives, as they lived in the very inhospitable center of Maine. Filled with snow and very low temperatures, the film did a great job showing just how tough life was for these people as well as how incredibly boring life could be for these farmers--with the nearest "town" many miles away and nothing much to do to keep yourself from going stir-crazy during the long, hard winters.

As for the technical merits of the film, it's decent, though there are absolutely no stars in this Warner Brothers film. This isn't a bad thing, as stars would have distracted from the message. Overall, the beginning of the film was exceptional but the rest of it awfully episodic and tedious. Watchable and mildly interesting to the right audience.

The main character of this movie actually is Millie Shaw . . .

[oscaralbert · 7/10 · 9 April 2021]

. . . (played by sixth-billed Dot Peterson), disgruntled because her lazy slob farmer husband George eats all the family pie, already has saddled her with five kids and now has deposited a sixth bun to bake in her easy oven. Filming discretely to avoid the scissors of an incipient Roman censorship cult, the eponymous Warner Bros. Use AS THE EARTH TURNS to warn our USA Homeland of a time when a lady's right to choice will be threatened by a High Court sects cultist majority. Another tot to tend surely will be the millstone that breaks the camel's back, as far as put-upon dromedary Millie is concerned. As she confides to her niece Jenny, hers will be a totally lost cause without the availability of on-demand doctor services. Viewers will agree that Shirley Temple and at least three of her youngest siblings are likely to be soon drowned in the family washtub by Millie if this beleaguered mom is forced to suffer through yet another post-partum depression.

Two sisters use much different approaches to woo single men into marraige

[Ed-Shullivan · 6/10 · 15 February 2019]

Although the story is supposed to be about the hardships and drudgery of living and working on a farm in rural Maine in the early 20th century this is only a sub plot to the real story which revolves around two sisters whose purpose and goals in life could not be any more different.

Jen Shaw (Jean Muir) is the older somewhat spinster hard working sister, and Doris Shaw (Dorothy Appleby) is the selfish lying sister who wants nothing more than to leave the family farm and way of life, and move to the big city. During one scene Jen is consoling her younger sister Doris after another hardship reveals Doris will not be able to attend secretarial school in the city but will have to stay on the farm for another season. Doris cannot accept the bad news, nor Jen's warm hand on her back as she attempts to console Doris, so Doris responds to her sister Jen's kindness and love by telling Jen she is "dull and stupid like a cow".

The two sisters also have completely different views on what they want in a man they will eventually marry. Jen the older sister may seem homely and dour, but she will not stoop to enticing a man into marriage. No, Jen wants to make sure beyond any shadow of a doubt that the man she may eventually marry wants nothing more in life than to work the (farm) land in rural Maine as she does. Doris on the other hand will use her sexuality, flirting, conniving and even stoop to lies to selfishly get what she wants, regardless of what people in their farming community may think of Doris.

In the end, will both and/or either sister get what they really want from their potential suitors? I won't spoil the ending, but the farming hardships and relationships in a rural community are exposed in As the Earth Turns.

I give this black and white 1934 film a 6 out of 10 rating.

farming... hmm.

[ksf-2 · 6/10 · 2 June 2021]

The title is a farming joke! This is the story of an immigrant family, trying to make a go of it in Maine. But it never really gets going... we see the ups and downs of farm life. Sons that go off to get educated and may or may not come back to the family home. Barns burning down. Hard work and sadness. This one never picked up steam... just kind of slowly moves along. Right at the very end, finally some emotions and magic. And that's the end. Should have started with that much earlier. Yawn. Directed by Al Green. Low budget thing for Warner Brothers. Green also made Copacabana (Groucho) and Dangerous (B. Davis).

Nothing New But Well Executed

[boblipton · 5/10 · 29 January 2009]

There is nothing much new in this story of poor farmers in Maine: their trials and tribulations, their hopes and dreams and the Polish family that bought the abandoned farm down the road. However, the performances are excellent. Jean Muir is luminous as the hard-working drudge who wants something more without quite understanding what, William Janney is her brother who is working his way through college and Donald Woods is as good in his miscast role as he can be: he is supposed to be Polish and a violinist, but his faking is as mismatched to the music as can be. Good thing that what he really wants to be is a farmer! But despite the excellence of the acting,it's largely repetitious of characters again and again: the kids are tired of the hard work, the father is understanding, the mother is shrill and grasping and so forth. After a while, it's a little too much.

Fans of star watching should keep a sharp eye out: Shirley Temple is listed on the IMDb as having her last uncredited role in this, the same year she became the biggest star at Fox. Interestingly, I was unable to spot her, nor is she listed in the AFI Catalogue as appearing here. If you do see her here, please let me know where.

A precode in rural Maine

[AlsExGal · 8/10 · 31 January 2016]

I didn't expect much from this film, but it really intrigued me. So much so that I want to find a copy of the book by the same name, published in 1933, and read the entire story.

The film focuses on three Maine farming families, all interconnected in some way. First there is the newly arrived immigrant Janowski family. They were encouraged to move there by their son, Stan, who gave up a career playing the violin in favor of farming.

Then there is the family headed by Mark and his second wife Cora. For Cora, what's his is hers and what's hers is hers. Part of her attitude is caused by the fact that she and her daughter by her first marriage hate the farming country of Maine and miss the big city.

The third family is headed by Mil and George. Mil openly goes around complaining about how she hates this kind of life and how shiftless George is - and he really is lazy. Mil is always advising any grown girl who will listen to her not to marry a farmer, don't do what she did and get "stuck", go to the city, do something with her life! When George's laziness is the cause of a needed cow dying and he goes to Mark to borrow one of his cows, and this prevents Cora's oldest daughter from going to secretarial school, all hell breaks loose. As one kid says "Who would know one cow breaking its leg could cause so much trouble".

The complicating factor is that Jean Muir as Jen, Mark's daughter but not Cora's, is content with this life, even though it is a hard one. And she and the Janowski's son Stan begin to develop feelings for one another. But Jen does not want to end up like Mil and George, so she insists on more time for making a commitment. She wants Stan to be sure and have no regrets. Stan sees this as rejection. And then there is Cora's oldest daughter, on the prowl for any man that will take her out of this place she considers a frigid hell.

It really is a complex soap opera set in an unusual place. The one thing that does not quite fit in is the solution to their ruts and boredom that the unhappy members of these families think they will find in the city. The book was written about Maine farmers in the 1920's before the crash. By the time this film was released there were no jobs there, and if you owned food producing land you might lead a boring life, but you would eat.

I'd recommend it for any number of reasons, but primarily it was well acted and it was a rare lead part for Jean Muir. She was mainly a supporting player as was the rest of the cast, plus it is a rare look into a world of farm families in a remote place where so many of the individuals were unhappy and restless, when farm life was generally portrayed as happy in most other films of the 1930's and 40's.

Very early soap-opera about cold-country farming and folks trying to deal with it

[morrisonhimself · 8/10 · 5 May 2023]

Not exciting, not engrossing, but still interesting for its clear-cut characters involved in daily life.

That life is being lived, or at least survived, in the frozen wastes of Maine ... and in fact the very first scene is snowy wintertime, with a temperature of 12 below zero.

To those of us used to sunnier climes, perhaps it is a puzzle just why anyone would want to be in any place that suffered through those kinds of winters; and that anyone could enjoy such winters is, honestly, beyond me, and I spent some three winters in North (brrrrr) Dakota.

Even more puzzling to us erstwhile desert-dwellers is that anyone could actually FARM such an environment.

In truth, though, that is part of what makes this movie as interesting as it is.

There really is a ring of truth: So many of the people do not, in fact, want to be farmers in snowy Maine, and that is the basis of some of the conflict that makes up this drama.

Most of the players are almost unknown today, although IMDb listing shows Shirley Temple in an unbilled bit. I didn't see her, but I'll look harder next time.

Despite their lack of fame, they show acting ability, and are nearly all thoroughly believable in this worthwhile film.

Last I heard, "As the Earth Turns" is available on YouTube, but for some reason in two parts and you will have to search for both. I hope you do.