Sally of the Subway (1932) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Clever Idea, But Mulhall Can't Bring It Home
boblipton23 October 2023
Jack Mulhall is a Grand Duke without a ducat to his name. He's waiting on a lawsuit against the German government that never seems to come to any conclusion. He meets Huntley Gordon and his daughter, Dorothy Revier, who are grateful for his treatment of Gordon's son during the last war. When Mulhall confesses his embarrassment Gordon gives him the commission of finding a match of a black pearl for a little friend of his. Mulhall goes to a prominent jeweler, gives him the pearl and a thousand dollars Gordon has provided, and the commission. While there, he meets Blanche Mehaffey, who is the employee fired whenever a customer is dissatisfied. While Mulhall waits for the next stage of his commission, he courts Miss Mehaffey. What he doesn't realize is that he's fronting a swindle: Gordon has the matching pearl, which a confederate will sell to the jeweler for several times its value, then cancel the sale.

It's. Clever idea for a comedy of swindles, since no one is whom he or she pretends to be -- except for the jeweler. Director George Seitz directs well enough, but unfortunately for him, Mulhall is miscast, unable to manage anything in the way of an accent, and way too naive for someone who had been an army officer a decade and a half earlier. With Harry Semels and George 'Gabby' Hayes.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
One for Harry Semels's legion of fans!
JohnHowardReid15 October 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Yes, Harry Semels has a major role in this one with lots of close-ups in which he can huff and puff to his heart's content. Jack Mulhall is the nominal star, but although he is playing a Grand Duke Ludwig of Germany, he doesn't even make the slightest attempt at an accent. Not that it matters. Accent or no accent, he's totally unconvincing. As for Sally of the Subway herself, Dorothy Revier's role is actually rather small. No wonder Alpha used the movie's alternative title, "The Case of the Black Pearl", for their DVD release. The film's real heroine is the lovely Blanche Mehaffey who plays the happy employee who is always fired when some mishap occurs. That's actually her job -- and that's the one touch of originality in the all-talk-and-little-action story and screenplay concocted by George B. "Andy Hardy" Seitz. Both excitement and production values are minimal. P.S. George Hayes plays a police detective, but I doubt if a single fan in the world would recognize their "Gabby".
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed