A Lad an' a Lamp (1932) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The racial humor will go over kids' heads
Damonfordham9 April 2008
An odd and interesting Our Gang/Little Rascals flick, this is indeed filled with some undertones of racial stereotyping. But much of that will go over the heads of the modern kids who see this.

Essentially, the Gang reads "Aladdin's Lamp" and get the idea to rub all the lamps they could find hoping for a genie to appear to grant their wishes. As mentioned, Stymie, the Black hero of the early 1930s episodes, wishes for a watermelon and for his "pappy to get out of jail" (this running "gag" from the Stymie Beard years is even less funny today than it was in 1932 for obvious reasons). For some reason, Spanky wishes for Stymie's brother Cotton to turn into a monkey. With the help of a practical-joking magician and his smoke pellets, Cotton appears to do just that to Stymie's horror! To make matters worse, Dickie and the rest of the gang consider selling Cotton to the circus! Adults will have a coronary over the racial implications of all this, and another racial gag involving a Black cook trying to woo his girlfriend, who abscond in histrionic hysterics when the monkey shows up. However, modern children who are innocent of the baggage of stereotype implications will just see this as amusing and wonder how the Gang could be so foolish as to think that Cotton turned into a monkey.

Kids will enjoy other aspects of the film, especially when a bully (Donald Haines) bothers the kids and the magician (who is watching all this nearby) drops a smoke pellet, appears, and yells, "Be gone, villain!" while Donald does just that. This will appeal to the imagination of the small set. In a sense, this will play better to children than adults.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Well, this is bound to raise a few eyebrows!
planktonrules9 December 2011
Warning: Spoilers
While this Our Gang comedy is worth watching and has a few funny moments, it also might make many of you cringe, as it is chock full of very inappropriate black stereotypes. The problems abound but what struck me were the times that Stymie tried to use their 'magic lamp' and said things like 'I wish my daddy was outta jail...I wish I had some fried chicken...' and later 'I wished I had a watermelon...'. It's pretty nasty, that's for sure.

This Gang finds a lamp that looks like one of those old ones from stories about genies. On a lark, they try rubbing it and THINK that it actually works. Later, a magician who is dressed like a genie just happens to see them and decides to answer their plea for help. It's quite funny but highly contrived, that's for sure. Later, little Spanky wishes that Stymie's brother, Cotton, were a monkey and he seems to be turned into a chimp! What's next? See it for yourself. It has some funny moments but certainly is not among the better films of the series.

By the way, Stymie's little brother played his brother, Cotton, in this one. Also, his sister also appeared in many Our Gang films--often playing a boy not a girl.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
This "Our Gang" set of theatrical shorts was finely crafted . . .
pixrox111 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
. . . by the MGM movie studio (which would soon distort American History with its deplorable revisionist egregious feature, GONE WITH THE WIND) to draw crowds to the movie houses in the USA's "Jim Crow" South during the 1930s. A LAD AN' A LAMP has been rated as high as "10" out of 10 by some sociologists as one of the most perfect examples of anti-Black Racism ever committed to film in the U.S. A young White lad keeps pleading with a presumed genii to turn Black tyke "Cotton into a monkey." When it appears to the gang that this "magical" transformation actually has taken place, another White urchin--obviously familiar with the basic economic precepts of Lazy Racist Slavery--pipes up "Let's sell him!" before apparent shape-shifter Cotton regains a voice of his own. Then, when the monkey-formerly-known-as-Cotton, knocks over a few cheap trinkets in a store, a White cop immediately issues the following bone-chilling extermination directive to the city's entire "peace-keeping" force: "There's a drunken monkey running loose; shoot to kill!" Some have asked, "Why can't we all just get along?" If you view A LAD AN' A LAMP, you'll likely conclude that we never have "gotten along," and that we never will.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent example of pre-code stereotypes....
16mmfilms.com1 April 2007
"A lad an' a lamp" is considered to be a classic example of pre-code shorts. Hal Roach created the series in the 1920's and the early episodes were silent. Originally shown in theaters as "Our Gang" Comedies.

Originally distributed by MGM Early TV syndication packages included this title "uncut".

TV distributer: King Features In later years, the episode was heavily edited.

Eventually "pulled" from the series.

A very young Spanky, and a dapper Stymie shine in this short.

Given the chance to make wishes with a magic lamp, Stymie wishes for a watermelon....a BIG watermelon...

An Italian grocer rolls a watermelon to the kids..

Stymie wishes for fried chicken and to get his pappy out of jail.

Spanky changes Cotton into a monkey... (all he needs is a tail)

Uncut versions include: Scaring the cook from the diner.

Cook: Do you loves me honey???? Gimme the biggest kiss you've got...

Spanky: Gimme another pie, and this time keep your fingers out it...

Italian Grocer: Thats'a the monkey down at at the Theatre..."
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great!!!
clark-71 December 2000
This has got to be the funniest of the Little Rascals series. The monkey actually appears to be drunk (he finds a bottle of liquor). Spanky is also naturally at his best in this one. The scene where the monkey kisses the cook is hilarious too. If you can find it, check it out!!
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Lad an' a Lamp is one of the more uncomfortable-on-the-stereotypical-side Our Gang shorts
tavm1 November 2014
Warning: Spoilers
This Hal Roach comedy short, A Lad an' a Lamp, is the one hundred nineteenth in the "Our Gang/Little Rascals" series and the thirty-first talkie. After hearing the story of Aladdin and his lamp, the gang try various lamps to rub when making wishes. Spanky keeps wishing Stymie's brother Cotton to become a monkey and then-through some contrivances I won't mention here-thinks he's become one! The monkey then gives chase and gets the police after him. This short marked the return of Wheezer to the gang after being absent from the last three eps but he doesn't have many lines or contribute much physically. It's usually Spanky and Stymie who gets the lion's share of scenes now and while both are pretty amusing here, some of the lines fall on the stereotype side concerning Stymie and Cotton's race that makes one now wince. And to tell the truth, I don't think the monkey is all that funny. I did like that lamp post cover falling on that cop's head as well as that "genie" scaring that bully out of that watermelon. And seeing Spanky and Cotton both looking full at the end was good for a chuckle. So on that note, A Lad an' a Lamp is worth a look.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Magic Monkeyshines And The Little Rascals
Ron Oliver17 June 2000
An OUR GANG Comedy Short.

All it takes is A LAD AN' A LAMP to cause trouble. Convinced he's found Aladdin's Magic Lamp, Spanky tries to turn little Cotton into a monkey. A runaway chimp completes the illusion, but the havoc it causes downtown is no make believe...

A funny little film, with good performances from Spanky & Stymie. Highlight: the chimp behind the diner counter.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
One of Our Gang's best
Leofwine_draca3 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
A LAD AN' A LAMP is one of the funniest of all the Little Rascals films. This is because the plot is outlandish and inspired, featuring the kids discovering a magic lamp which has the power to make wishes come true. Or so they think - said wishes are actually brought about by coincidence rather than magic. What this all boils down to, after a lot of good natured sketches, is a comic routine in which a chimpanzee runs rampage around the city, wreaking havoc wherever he goes. I found it hilarious.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed