Side Show (1931) User Reviews

Carnival Story

[lugonian · 4/10 · 21 April 2012]

SIDE SHOW (Warner Brothers, 1931), directed by Roy Del Ruth, is vintage circus comedy featuring the antics of comedienne Winnie Lightner. A plump size performer better known for her rowdiness and outburst singing style, SIDE SHOW finds Lightner slimmer, restrained and in glamorous fashion. Aside from that, she's still in character for which she is famous. Sharing equal billing is the droll Charles Butterworth, who's quips and responses appear to be taken from tried and true material acquired from old vaudeville routines. Overall, the major asset for this 64 minute production is Lightner playing the self sacrificing woman always doing something for somebody else, and getting hurt in the process.

Forward: "The special train of Colonel Gowdy's big city shows rambles through the night - a city on wheels - a world in itself." The story begins with Colonel "Pop" Gowdy (Guy Kibbee), a good-natured circus owner, leading his circus troupe by train to the next town. Pat (Winnie Lightner), a circus gal since childhood, assumes many responsibilities in the side show. Aside from ticket booth collector, she takes time assisting Gowdy to bed after one of his many drunken binges. Because Gowdy owes back salary, Tom Whalen (Matthew Betz), the newest member of the troupe, stirs up trouble by talking others to leave the show, and having Pat to either get them back or go on in their place. Pat is madly in love with Joe Palmer (Donald Cook), circus barker and compulsive gambler who takes her for granted. Sidney (Charles Butterworth), a philosopher, loves Pat, but gets the same treatment as Pat gets from Joe. Later, Irene (Evalyn Knapp), Pat's kid sister, having dropped out of school, and leaving both her boyfriend, Jimmy (Edward Morgan), and Aunt Sara (Lucille Ward) behind, decides she wants to join the circus and be near Pat again. All goes well until Joe starts giving Irene his undivided attention.

The plot element of having two sisters loving the same man, causing a strain on their relationship, is nothing new considering a similar theme was previously used for the Academy Award winning backstage musical, "The Broadway Melody" (MGM, 1929). One can very well see some similarities of Lightner, Knapp and Cook in the roles originally played by Melody stars of Bessie Love, Anita Page and Charles King, with the exception of King's character being more sincere than Cook's. Though not an intentional remake, both films do include one crucial moment where the self-sacrificing sister has her face slapped by younger sibling followed by an "I hate you!" outburst. As much as "The Broadway Melody" has its share of now classic songs, SIDE SHOW features only one tune, a likable tune, "What Do You Think of Me Now?" wonderfully sung by Lightner.

In between Lightner's character keeping the carnival from falling apart and some dramatic moments involving her sister, she does provide some side show antics of her own, such as dressing up as a male side show barker; being Princess Mauna, a Hawaiian hula dancer; a female figure posing inside a picture frame while trying to keep her posture; and that of a wild black-face cannibal from Borneo involved in a riot. Lightner's best scene comes where she substitutes for high diver, The Great Santini (Vince Barnett), and getting up the nerve to dive 110 feet through circular fire and into a tank with four feet of water. Lightner's diver disguise, from pencil drawn mustache and wide grin smile, is often hilarious, especially when her face resembles that of comedian, Groucho Marx. On screen, Lightner does everything except flying on a trapeze or getting shot out of a cannon. She may do some clowning, but never gets to play a clown. A pity none of these was considered for additional comedy material. Even Butterworth's participation in Lightner's antics helps make them better than anticipated.

While SIDE SHOW was never remade, one can imagine slapstick queens as Martha Raye or Betty Hutton assuming the role originated by Lightner in a product produced in or about the 1940s with added songs and Technicolor. As for other Lightner comedies made between 1930-33, they're as forgotten as Lightner herself. Many of them can be seen and rediscovered whenever shown again on on Turner Classic Movies cable network. "Hey Rube!" (**)

More Charles Butterworth

[Markark · 4/10 · 16 May 2000]

This is not a distinguished or interesting movie, but Charles Butterworth is always worth seeing. He seems to be doing some deadpan vaudeville routine all the time, and I guess you would either think it's funny or you don't, and I do. Plus, the hat gags, especially the one with an elephant and his keeper, are good.

OK, so they ain't the Hilton Sisters, but they'll do.

[mark.waltz · 5/10 · 18 June 2015]

The cult Broadway musical "Side Show" has won a fan following even if two Broadway productions of it failed to run past a couple of months. The story of the Hilton Sisters (Daisy and Violet, not the overly publicized heiresses of a hotel chain who have no reason to be in the spotlight) was basically part of a "freak show", but the two sisters here (Winnie Lightner and Evelyn Knapp) work in a circus where there are also various types of characters seen in the cheaper side shows which traveled as part of "carny's" (carnivals) and often were not welcome in some smaller and overly tough law abiding communities. Like those two attached sisters, these two detached sisters are as different as night and day. "I don't want to be a lady", Knapp tells the vivacious Lightner, adding "I want to be like you!". So while they are not twins (Siamese or otherwise), they are set up to be equally close, with Knapp as much younger and obviously naive in the ways of the world (especially men) and Lightner more of a mother figure, concerned about her since their father (Guy Kibbee) always seems to be drunk when the circus tent is folded and the animals are safely packed on the train.

Lightner is in love with carnival barker Donald Cook, and works hard to keep the circus afloat, especially when all the specialty performers threatening to quit since they haven't gotten paid. She sings, clowns, dances, and even gets to cry a little. Fascinating to me ever since I saw the clip of "Singin' in the Bathtub" in "Show of Shows", Lightner is the whole show. Charles Butterworth is the droll comic who has a mixed bag of gags. The one concerning a mouse is hysterically funny, but the poem he makes an attempt to flatter Lightner with is lame. At times, his humor is truly banal, and even more often, his character becomes so stupid that he makes the most idiotic of people you've come across in real life seem like geniuses. Atmospherically, this is very interesting. If you've ever been to a traveling circus, county fair or country carnival, it's right on the money with the details just perfect. It only slows down a bit due to the romantic confusions concerning Lightner, Knapp and Cook but wraps up with some slapstick and a satisfying conclusion. Lightner got to keep one of the songs written for the film, showing her musical metal wearing a hula skirt, no less. Her soon to be real-life husband, Roy Del Ruth, directed this with fast precision, and that keeps the movie from seldomly sagging.

Great Cast but Weak Story

[Michael_Elliott · 20 March 2012]

Side Show (1931)

** (out of 4)

Decent melodrama from Warner has Winnie Lightner playing Pat, a jack-of-all-trades working in a traveling circus whose life falls apart when the man she (Donald Cook) loves runs off with her younger sister (Evalyn Knapp). While all of that is going on Winnie is also having to worry about the circus itself falling apart as its owner (Guy Kibbee) can't afford to pay the workers. SIDE SHOW is a pretty bizarre little movie that's story is way too weak and predictable to work but thankfully the cast are so good that they make the film worth sitting through and especially at such a short running time (64-minutes). I think the best thing that can be said about the film is that the performances are exceptionally good with each cast member coming off very believable in their part. Lightner plays a very tough, head strong woman and she makes you believe that this is the way she is. I thought he handled some of the lighter comedy just fine but she also did a good job once the drama starts. Cook delivers a fine performance as the dirty two-timer and Knapp beings a certain naive quality to the role and you can see why she'd fall for her sister's man. Charles Butterworth gets a lot of screen time but most of it has him looking straight at the camera and delivering his type of humor. It seems more people are torn on the comic ability of Butterworth but I've always found him rather entertaining and I think he gets to shout off a few good jokes here. Kibbee plays the lovable drunk like only he could. One other good thing is that you really do get a good, intimate feel of what a traveling circus must have felt like. With all of that said, there's no question that the film is way too predictable for its own good and the entire love triangle just isn't believable. What's even worse is the horrid ending, which is just so bad that you can't help but think the studio must have gotten a hold of it. SIDE SHOW is certainly minor entertainment but fans of the cast will want to check it out.

Doesn't Hold Up Well

[Handlinghandel · 4/10 · 6 January 2006]

Winnie Lightner seems very game. She looks like someone who'd be a lot of fun. She's likable and seems up to pretty much any task. But she doesn't come across as someone who could carry a movie -- though she's called to here.

Donald Cook, on the other hand, seems very modern as her shiftless boyfriend. He was an interesting leading man who never really made it big. One wonders why.

The rest of the cast includes many character performers such as Guy Kibbee who worked in Hollywood for decades. I think I a caught a glimpse of the straying husband from "Freaks" (a totally different and infinitely better movie also with a circus theme.)

A Little of Charles Butterworth Goes a Long Way in This Movie!!

[kidboots · 7/10 · 20 April 2017]

Winnie Lightner had been a featured soloist in the George White Scandals and was known as the "song a minute girl" because of her fast and robust delivery. She stole her first film "Gold Diggers of Broadway" and everyone predicted a huge future for her because female comics were pretty sparse in those early talkie times. "Life of the Party" was planned as a colour musical extravaganza but suddenly people decided they had had enough of musicals and all the songs were scratched except "Poison Ivy" but with all the tampering it still managed to become one of Warner's highest grossing films for 1930. By the time of "Side Show" Winnie, who had been given the glamour treatment, was there strictly for laughs.

She plays Pat, the fast talking carnie girl who is the real strength behind Colonel Gowdy's Big City Carnival, which is on the skids and the perpetually drunken Gowdy (Guy Kibbee) doesn't help matters. Everywhere she turns there is unrest, caused by rabble rousing new hand (Matthew Betz). She is also labouring under a delusion that Joe (Don Cook) an opportunistic carnival barker with an eye for the ladies, is the man of her dreams!! When pretty sister Irene (cutie pie Evalyn Knapp) joins the show, sparks start to fly, especially as Pat vows Joe to silence on the reality of their relationship!!

Winnie is given a song to perform in the "Pingo Pongo" vein but it's nothing like that - it's crude, rude and completely non catchy!! Charles Butterworth, usually so funny in small doses, really slows the film down with his non-sequiturs. He and Lightner, so funny together in "Life of the Party" must have seemed like a good team bet but "Party" at least had an interesting story - it's a bit of a worry when Butterworth's painful jokes are what holds the movie together!!

It isn't quite follow the numbers - yes, Irene falls in love with Joe, but it only makes Joe realize what a wonderful girl he always had in Pat and how rotten he has treated her!! When he leaves the fun fair his character does a metamorphosis and far from running off with Irene, he reunites her with her aunt and Jimmy who she has long regarded as just a kid!!

Beautiful Evalyn Knapp didn't fare so wonderfully at Warners herself. A starring role in "Sinner's Holiday" which could have done wonders for her career - saw two supporting players get all the attention - James Cagney and Joan Blondell!!

A pleasant diversion

[brchthethird · 6/10 · 7 June 2022]

Winnie Lightner, who I remember liking as a supporting player in Dancing Lady, brings her affable personality to the lead role in this comedy centered around the goings-on in a traveling circus. Although rather episodic, there is a narrative throughline dealing with a love triangle between her, another guy named Joe, and her sister, who visits during the summer when she's out of school. While there wasn't a really memorable arc for anyone, the performances were generally good and there were a couple of standout moments for Winnie Lightner. The first was a bawdy musical number; and the other was late in the film when she really lets one guy have it (Go off, Winnie!). I found the narrative resolution to be rushed, and a bad example of the "Hollywood ending," but I found this Side Show a pleasant diversion.

The Barker Reimagined as a Vaudeville Star Vehicle

[bensonj · 4 April 2016]

Film buffs know that there were three official film versions of the play THE BARKER, namely THE BARKER (1928), HOOP-LA (1933) and DIAMOND HORSESHOE (1945), and real film buffs know that Japanese director Yasujiro Ozu made two unofficial remakes, A STORY OF FLOATING WEEDS (1934) and FLOATING WEEDS (1959). But do they know about SIDE SHOW?

Consider this: SIDE SHOW features a traveling carny show called Col. Gowdy's Big City Shows. The barker (Donald Cook) is going with a girl in the show (Winnie Lightner) who he promises to marry but never does. Lightner is putting her younger sister (Evalyn Knapp) through school, and one day Knapp shows up unexpectedly at the show. Lightner tells Cook that while Knapp is around, they have to pretend that they don't have a relationship. She tells the innocent young Knapp that she can not stay with the show, even though Knapp points out that it's summer and there is no school. Lightner is called away for a moment, and while she's gone Knapp asks Col. Gowdy if she can stay, and he says it's OK with him, and when Lightner returns this endorsement from the Colonel is enough for her to relent. Cook starts to fool around with Knapp in a cynical way but then falls in love for real. Later, Knapp is doing a hoochie coochie dance while Cook shills for the show, when a local boy gets fresh with her. Cook starts a fight with the local, all the carny folks yell, "Hey, Rube!" and there's a royal free-for-all involving the whole carny. When the affair between Cook and Knapp is discovered, Lightner makes a big stink, and the two lovers leave the show. Wow. You'll find all these details, some slightly recast, in THE BARKER (and in the close remake HOOP-LA), even the name of the show. This isn't quite a remake of THE BARKER, and the very perfunctory and tacked-on ending here isn't similar to the original film (or the later HOOP-LA alternate), but there are an amazing number of similarities. The explanation is that THE BARKER was made by Warners and so they were free to cannibalize it. The name of the show may have been reused so that existing footage or props showing the name could be reused.

But this film isn't primarily a romantic drama, but more an excuse as a vehicle for three stars, only one of which is part of the love triangle. There's Charles Butterworth, who is given a lot of amusing business, and also has a number of lines that he can only have written himself. Some examples (said more-or-less apropos of nothing): "I know all about love. I learned about love from the state highway commissioner." "Well, Colonel, take it or leave it, I'm going for a bus ride." And "I believe I'd like to have a nice bag of stuffed figs." At one point he reads a long self-composed love poem to Lightner, which gets sidetracked into describing a sandwich.

Then, of course, there's Winnie Lightner, the supposed star of the film, who does some rather raw routines not related to the plot. She sings a long song in a hula outfit. (Hawaiian music is used as background music throughout the film to fairly good effect, another carryover from THE BARKER.) The song is about a girl whose smile says "Take a look at this," with Lightner (filmed from the navel up) raising her grass skirt at this repeated line. In another scene she impersonates a high diver and so as not to reveal her (supposedly) feminine voice, she talks in deaf-and-dumb hand signals. These are performed very fast, but one can catch a glimpse of not only "the finger" but the classic symbol of the forefinger of one hand poked through the circled thumb and forefinger of the other. Another scene has her playing a geek in black-face, making amusing geek noises.

Kibbee, the third star player, is Colonel Gowdy, and though he has no vaudeville routines as the others do, the character is built up to give him the sort of scenes that he does best; drunk scenes, and a heart-to-heart with Lightner, who is like a daughter to him.

Then there's Vince Barnett (a journeyman doofus I always enjoy) in a small part as The Great Santini. Yup, The Great Santini. One has to ask, was Pat Conroy, the author of the novel on which the film of that name was based, thinking of this film when he used the name, or was that name used in various early films and/or plays as a generic character name. Finally, the film has a nice carnival atmosphere, crowds on the midway, etc. There's a great shot taken from the Ferris wheel as it swings down and reveals the actors on the side-show stage. Visually, there is no stinting.

This is one of those early-Thirties programmers where an anemic plot is used as a background for a few musical numbers, some comedy routines and anything else that comes to mind, all jammed into 65 minutes. In this case, the combination is very agreeable.