La voix du rossignol (1925) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A beautifully rendered fable that is surely this animator's most moving film
wmorrow5912 September 2005
Wladyslaw Starewicz was a true pioneer of puppet animation, an artist who devised new "pixilation" techniques as early as 1910 and was still producing fascinating movies right through the 1950s. At the time of his death in 1965 he was hard at work on yet another new film, one which, sadly, remained unfinished. Starewicz was unafraid to explore the darker corners of his imagination, and was therefore an influential trail-blazer for such latter-day filmmakers as Jan Svankmajer, the Brothers Quay, and Tim Burton. Starewicz' films usually feature animals whose behavior serves as a satirical comment on human foibles, and while some children might get a kick out of his macabre sense of humor I believe the man's work is best appreciated by adults.

This film, known as "The Voice of the Nightingale" in its English language version, represents a pleasant departure for Starewicz, with a lighter and gentler story that makes it one of his more accessible works for general audiences. This is a simple tale of a little girl who traps a nightingale in a cage and intends to keep it as a plaything. While the girl is asleep the nightingale enters her dreams with his song, and narrates a legend set in the Kingdom of the Flowers. (This scene, featuring fairies and sprites interacting with grasshoppers, dragonflies, etc., may remind some viewers of the "Nutcracker" sequence in Disney's Fantasia.) But then the nightingale sings of his own sad plight, the tale of how he met his lady love, their courtship and the birth of their chick, and how his spouse, out hunting for food one day, narrowly missed being hit by an arrow fired by a boy. Since then, the nightingale has been searching for his spouse, and it was while he was searching for her that he was trapped in the girl's cage, leaving their fledgling alone in the nest and unable to fend for itself. Waking in tears, the girl sets the nightingale free with a new understanding of humans' proper relationship with the animal world.

The story is simple but the exquisite technique Starewicz brings to bear on this material lifts it out of the ordinary. The film combines live action footage of the girl and her surroundings with animated puppets representing the birds, animals and the fairy denizens of the Kingdom of Flowers. All of this footage has been hand-tinted, and the title cards have also been specially decorated and colored. Starewicz expresses his darker side only once, when the newly captured nightingale frightens the little girl -- and the audience! -- by briefly transforming himself into an angry rat. Otherwise, "The Voice of the Nightingale" is a gently moving little fable, sweet but not cloying in tone. Like Starewicz himself, this film deserves to be better known.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Good story and animation
Horst_In_Translation29 August 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"La voix du rossignol" or "Voice of the Nightingale" is a 13-minute short film from 1925, so this one is already over 90 years old. The writer and director is Wladyslaw Starewicz, but despite his Luthuanian origins, this is a French production as the title already tells us. This is the story of the relationship between a nightingale and a little girl and the writing here is the biggest strength I think. It does not only make sense, but makes an impact on the emotional side and also as a dramatic movie. Besides that, Starewicz proved again that he was among the best European, maybe world-wide, animators of his time and it's intriguing to see how different this is from the American approach at animation in the 1920s. This is a contender for my favorite work from Starewicz and if you love animation, you should definitely check it out, maybe the colored version too.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
a little bird told me
lee_eisenberg5 January 2017
Having fled revolutionary Russia, Władysław Starewicz moved to France, where he continued making cartoons. Most of them are surreal, but "La voix du rossignol" ("The Voice of the Nightingale" in English) is almost mystifying. It depicts a girl who catches a nightingale, but has a dream reminding her that birds are not toys.

The short is tinted to make it look as if it's in color. The tint might look silly to any person who's used to movies getting filmed in color, but you have to realize that cinema was still a relatively new thing at this time, and they were still trying to figure out how to do things.

Anyway, it's an OK short.

The bird's life as a troubadour. A troubadour who got killed before he reached Bombay, is it? (props to the Rolling Stones)
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Charming Story With Skilled Craftsmanship
Snow Leopard17 August 2004
"The Voice of the Nightingale" combines a charming story with Starewicz's usual skilled craftsmanship. It seamlessly meshes animated puppets with live settings, and it is also enhanced by the use of color, which must have come at the cost of some painstaking work.

One of the impressive things about Starewicz's movies is the range of material with which he made high-quality features. This one is more low-key and more touching than is usual for him, and yet it is just as memorable as his more frenetic, fast-paced features. Rather than going for laughs, it tells a simple but thoughtful story of a girl and a nightingale. The animation is up to his usual high standard, although you don't notice it quite so much here, because the story takes center stage. It works well, and it is a very nice little film overall.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Not Wladyslaw Starewicz's best, but still a very nice little film.
planktonrules29 October 2011
Warning: Spoilers
From the 1910s until the late 1950s, Wladyslaw Starewicz made a bunch of cute little stop-motion films. Aside from being one of the early pioneers in the craft, he had a fanciful knack of looking at common objects like toys and dead bugs and imagining them in their own little world. Animating them, he made some amazingly cool films that are still very, very watchable today.

"La Voix du Rossignol" is a bit different from the other Starewicz films in that it is more like a fairy tale or a Just-So story. And, interestingly, the entire film is hand-colored--which must have taken a VERY long time to do.

The story begins with a nightingale accidentally breaking a child's doll and falling into a trap. The girl decides to keep the bird as her pet. And, each night, the bird causes the girl to have some amazingly fanciful dreams--such as one involving bugs and little fairies. In addition, the bird induces a dream about the life of this nightingale--and learns that it's sad because it lost its partner. The child is touched to see such strong feelings in a bird and decides to let it go. The bird, in thanks, gives the child the ability to sing beautifully during the day--and the bird will retain it at night. And, supposedly, that is why these birds only sing at night.

This is a very sweet tale and is very well done. Engaging and exceptionally well done for a silent short. Well worth seeing even if the story is a tad confusing from time to time (it could have used better intertitle cards).
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Voice of the Nightingale is most charming Ladislaw Starewicz short
tavm30 August 2006
Warning: Spoilers
The Voice of the Nightingale is Ladislaw Starewicz's most charming short about birds and their relationship with nature and humans. It stars his daughter as a girl who keeps the bird after he accidentally wrecks her doll while walking through her trap cage. The bird briefly turns into a rat while captured, frightening the girl (and us!). The captured bird sings hanging on a windowsill as the girl dreams first of a grasshopper and spider fighting over a pixie captured in spider's web, and then of the caged bird's wife, whom he was looking for when the girl got him, leaving their child alone. She wakes up and frees her pet. As reward, she now has a beautiful singing voice. Besides the story, there's also wonderful color-tinting to be awed and inspired by. So if you love Ladislaw Starewicz's work, seek out the DVD from Image Entertainment, The Cameraman's Revenge and Other Fantastic Tales.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
beautiful beautiful beautiful
princessorig14 December 2001
What can I really say? I don't want to waste time talking about the technical aspects because this movie is simply pure joy. Too beautiful to remain obscure. Hey film festival guys: get this movie out there!
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
All in color
boblipton13 November 2002
Amazing mix of stop-motion animation and live-action little girl, all in color! I can't identify the process, as Technicolor was not available in Europe when this picture was made and the technique looks lifelike. A certain amount of bleeding around the greens and yellows leads me to suspect this is a mixture of color photography and tinting.

As for the story, it is told with Wladyslaw Starewicz's usual charm and good humor. A must for any animation fan. Check it out on Milestone's THE CAMERAMAN'S REVENGE set.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed