Ah, Dexter, the show that made us question if we should be rooting for a serial killer. But let’s be honest, half of us were watching for the crime and the other half for the drama behind the scenes. One of the biggest off-screen twists? Michael C. Hall, Dexter himself and Jennifer Carpenter, his on-screen sister, Debra were actually married in real life.

Michael C. Hall and Jennifer Carpenter in a still from Dexter: New Blood | Credits: Showtime Networks

Yep, it was all love and murder on TV, of course until their marriage met a tragic end, though thankfully, it didn’t involve plastic wrap and a kill room. Now, years after their divorce, fans are still wondering, did these two manage to stay friends, or did their relationship get chopped up like one of Dexter’s victims? Let’s dive in!

The marriage, the divorce, and everything in between Michael C.