Amy Poehler has finally made an appearance on the SmartLess podcast!

The former Saturday Night Live actress reunited with her ex-husband Will Arnett during the latest episode of SmartLess… and it was a complete surprise for him. The interview was set up by his co-hosts Jason Bateman and Sean Hayes.

Amy and Will got married in 2003 and separated in 2012. They are parents to sons Archie and Abel, born in 2008 and 2010, respectively.

“Our youngest saw my schedule on the kitchen table and said, ‘You’re doing ‘SmartLess?’ Does Dad know?’ And I said, ‘No, don’t say anything,’” Amy said while being welcomed to the episode.

Amy joked about it being “weird” for her to finally appear on the podcast. She said, “Well, I wanted to wait until you had done 250 episodes to see if this thing was real. I usually give something five years until I try it.”

Will gushed about co-parenting with Amy.