You’ve seen Willa Fitzgerald play a small-town cop with serious grit in Reacher, a tightly wound cheer coach in Dare Me, and a scream queen in, well, Scream. But she is far from typecast. This Yale-trained actress has been quietly building a wildly eclectic resume that spans everything from intense thrillers to period dramas.

Lately, she’s been turning heads with her lead role in Strange Darling, a thriller that’s anything but predictable, and her haunting performance in Netflix’s The Fall of the House of Usher proved she’s not afraid to get weird in the best way. While she’s no stranger to the spotlight, Willa still flies a little under the radar, which honestly just adds to her whole mysterious, cool-girl vibe.

With a mix of indie cred, TV mainstays, and theater chops, she’s one of those actors who’s everywhere and nowhere at the same time.