Season 2 of Tell Me Lies is rife with shocking revelations chief among them being Drew's tragic death. Drew is Wrigley's younger brother, who accidentally swerved the late Macy off the road, where she hit a tree and died. Feeling responsible for Macy's death, Drew struggles with his mental health, and falls into a self-destructive cycle that leads to his untimely death, an event that rocked Tell Me Lies' cast of characters. Shortly before his death, Lucy pens an anonymous letter implicating him in Macy's death, resulting in him leaving campus.

Drew's death is hinted at the very beginning of Tell Me Lies season 1, when the timeline begins in 2015 at Evan and Bree's wedding, where Wrigley is on cocaine and struggling to cope the day after his late brother's birthday. His death is confirmed in Tell Me Lies season 2, when, after a night of partying with Wrigley, Drew passes away...