If you were a teen in the early 2000s, chances are Kristen Bell and Adam Brody held some nostalgic place in your heart. Bell charmed viewers as the bold yet troubled teenage detective Veronica Mars. Meanwhile, Brody won fans over with his portrayal of lovable stoner Seth Cohen on The O.C. Over a decade later, these two iconic characters are back—but all grown up.

In the new Netflix romantic comedy Nobody Wants This, Bell plays Joanne, a sharp-tongued podcaster exploring the messy world of dating and relationships. Brody takes on the role of Noah, a progressive Rabbi searching for meaning after ending a long relationship. The two cross paths at a party and feel an instant spark, despite coming from very different worlds.

Noah still holds firmly to his Jewish faith, even if he adds his own modern twists. Joanne, on the other hand, is an avowed atheist who prefers living spontaneously.