Howard Stern tricked American Idol judges on his show, making Simon Cowell doubt his own credibility. Stern interviewed singers with hidden identities, causing judges to give brutally honest opinions. Stern considered replacing Cowell on American Idol, stating he'd bring a new, more honest dynamic.

American Idol became part of television history after it premiered in 2003. The show became a pop culture phenomenon. It introduced Kelly Clarkson to the world and the judging panel became household names.

Those judges, however, would have their credibility questioned when they appeared on The Howard Stern Show.

During one memorable appearance, Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, and Randy Jackson were tricked by the radio host. The moment had such an effect on Cowell, he began joking that his entire credibility had been destroyed.

The 'American Idol' Judges Were Tricked By Howard Stern When They Appeared On His Show

In 2003, Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, and...