Over the course of its 44 seasons, Survivor has hosted hundreds of immunity challenges where individual players could win the opportunity to save themselves from elimination at tribal council. Since 2000 when the reality TV show began, 17 different contestants have won at least four immunity challenges. However, five of those castaways prevailed five times, a record that has never been broken. In our Survivor hall of fame gallery below, we spotlight those with the most immunity wins in a single season.

Despite four others winning just as many as he did, Colby Donaldson from Season 2 has bragging rights as not only the first player to win five times, but also the only one to do so consecutively. Like Kelly Wiglesworth before him, Colby played the game at a point in time where challenge wins were not held as in high regard as they were later, leaving him in runner-up position to a...