[Warning: The below contains Major spoilers for How I Met Your Father Season 2 Episode 12, “Not a Mamma Mia.”] The first half of How I Met Your Father Season 2 ended with Sophie (Hilary Duff) deciding to track down her dad, and she doesn’t waste any time doing so! In the Hulu comedy’s return, Sophie asks her mom Lori (Paget Brewster), to share everything she can remember about her dad. “I met him at Lollapalooza, he lolla’ed my palooza, and bam, here you are!” Lori tells her. When Sophie shows her a photo from that day, Lori does remember he had a barbed wire tattoo around his bicep. Sophie also spots a badge that reveals he was working at the festival, and his name ends with “ick.” Thanks to a deep dive on LinkedIn and a little blackmail, Val (Francia Raisa) helps Sophie narrow it down to three men, and the group splits up to track...