[Warning: The below contains Major spoilers for Midnight Mass Season 1, Episodes 1-3.] If you haven’t started watching Mike Flanagan‘s Netflix series Midnight Mass, you may want to turn back because we’re delving into spoiler territory with this Episode 3 breakdown. In the installment, “Book III: Proverbs,” the truth about Father Paul Hill’s (Hamish Linklater) identity is finally revealed, or rather confirmed. As miracles begin to sweep over the island, little clues point toward the reality of their savior, as it turns out that Father Paul Hill is actually Monsignor Pruitt, the man who oversaw their church for decades. Rejuvenated and youthful once more, he goes unrecognized by the young parishioners of St. Patrick’s Church. Before reaching the pivotal and revealing third episode, breadcrumbs hint at Father Paul’s true origins. Scheduled to return from a pilgrimage, Monsignor Pruitt was noticeably absent from ferry logs to the island, but Father Paul, a “newcomer,” showed up instead.