86
Métascore
22 commentaires · Fourni par Metacritic.com
- 100The A.V. ClubSam AdamsThe A.V. ClubSam AdamsPetzold handles personal, formal, and political concerns in such perfect balance, it's difficult, and not especially desirable, to separate one from the next. The movie is dense but never feels it, assembled with easy mastery and engrossing throughout.
- 90Village VoiceMelissa AndersonVillage VoiceMelissa AndersonA transfixing Cold War thriller set in the East Germany of 1980, Christian Petzold's superb Barbara is made even more vivid by its subtle overlay of the golden-era "woman's picture," the woman in question being Dr. Barbara Wolff, brilliantly played by Nina Hoss in her fifth film with the writer-director.
- 80EmpireEmpireTough and tender, it's the best Iron Curtain drama since "The Lives Of Others."
- 80The GuardianPeter BradshawThe GuardianPeter BradshawThe weird oppression and seediness of the times is elegantly captured, and Hoss coolly conveys Barbara's highly strung desperation.
- A slow-burning Cold War drama that will reward patient viewers with its ultimate emotional payoff.
- Not only has director Christian Petzold assembled a fascinating hill of beans, but there's a moonlit scene that almost alone justifies his Silver Bear win at Berlin.
- 80Time OutEric HynesTime OutEric HynesDespite being the subject of nearly every shot in the film, Hoss maintains an air of mystery, simultaneously projecting severity, sensitivity and sensuousness throughout.
- 75Slant MagazineSlant MagazineMost compelling in Christian Petzold's latest is the way the filmmaker adeptly conducts his tides of Cold War paranoia.
- 70VarietyJustin ChangVarietyJustin ChangA story of love and subterfuge in 1980 East Germany that never quite accelerates into an outright thriller, Barbara reps another assured collaboration between director Christian Petzold and his main muse, actress Nina Hoss.
- 67The PlaylistChristopher BellThe PlaylistChristopher BellThough maybe a bit too stiff and straight-laced, Barbara is a frequently subtle, moderately interesting character study set in a grievous East Germany during the 1980s.