Nev and Max read and respond to a wide variety of fan emails, answering questions and dishing out advice on topics ranging from love triangles to telepathy.
A concerned son reaches out when his mom's mysterious online boyfriend seems too shady for comfort. But Mom is hiding secrets of her own, and once Nev & Max find their man, things take a bizarre turn that leave them shocked.
After five years of talking to Matt, Kim is ready to meet up with her online love. As Max and Nev try to bring the two together, they uncover buried secrets that threaten to drive a wedge between the two lovers.
After a number of near-death experiences, Lawrence survived through it all with the assurance of Cierra's online love. But with Cierra blowing Lawrence off whenever they try to meet, Nev and Max must find the truth behind the suspicious profile.
A former catfish turns to Nev and Max for help when they fall hard in love online. This catfish might be playing Nev and Max, or may end up paying for their crimes with a broken heart.
When Zak met Garrett online he fell hard, but suspicious video calls and curious disappearances has Zak worried about who he really fell in love with. Will Nev and Max be able to find Garrett before he vanishes for good?
When Traves asks for help with his internet girlfriend Candy, it looks like a classic case of catfishing. But after more pieces of the puzzle come together, the guys realize they may have caught a bigger catfish than expected.
Mandy is in love with a guy that gives her everything except the truth. Mandy's son has had enough and calls in Nev and Max for help. But following a trail of clues only takes them all deeper down the rabbit hole.
Nev and Max head to New York City to help Infinti, a 19-year-old dancer who is certain that her online romance is the real deal. But when Nev and Max dive deep, they find Infiniti's love interest is far shadier than they ever imagined.
Dylan's desperately fallen for a beautiful model with an elusive secret. With all the standard red flags, Nev and Max assume it's an open and shut case - but the truth is something stranger than fiction.
Kiaira and Cortney had a baby, but the two have never met. Nev and Max are called in to bring the family together, but they worry this could be the greatest manipulation in catfish history.
Nina is a sexy webcam model, who's considering leaving her husband for a big spender client she's fallen in love with online. Nev and Max investigate this high stakes case to determine if his big tips come with bigger lies.
A match on Tinder ignited a fire for Jordan that caused Angel to end a real-life relationship to pursue him. When Nev and his wife Laura get on the case they uncover dark truths that could lose Angel everyone close in her life.
Breana waits to marry Josh for 11 years, but her love fades when the boys uncover the man behind the profile. Josh's past catches up with him as Nev and Max launch a multistate manhunt to uncover the dark truth.
Nev and Max agree to help Chelsea finally meet her online boyfriend, Charles, in person; while Chelsea has only spoken to Charles once, on the phone, the guys soon show her that a picture speaks a thousand words.
Nev and Max attempt to help a young woman named Nae track down her elusive internet celebrity crush and soon find themselves embroiled in a catfish conspiracy.
A mystery email leads Nev and Laura to help Derek track down his online love Annabelle. After digging, they uncover a sexy Snapchat scandal, betrayal, and a conclusion that hits closer to home than Derek could have ever dreamed.
Nev and Max try to help Nick determine if the person he kissed during a mysterious blindfolded rendezvous is actually his online love, Jasmine, or someone entirely different altogether.
Nev and co-host Jane Carrey help aspiring sugar baby Mike choose between his Los Angeles life of leisure and his deep affection for the mysterious Joey, a broke mechanic he fell in love with on Grindr.
Nev and co-host Kamie Crawford fly to Iowa to help Rachael meet Vance, her decade long Myspace romance. As they dig into Vance's past, Rachael is left wondering if he really is the man she spent half her life in love with.
Nev and co-host Tallulah Willis help Chelsea, a young woman who's fallen for a reality TV star. Digging for the truth only reveals Chelsea has her own secrets.
After chatting for years with Chris, Shakinah needs to move forward with her love life, but when Nev and co-host Kamie Crawford find out that Chris is a huge pop star, they know Shakinah needs their help in more ways than one.
Model Dallas has had his sights set on sexy Safari ever since she slid into his DMs, but despite flirty promises, she won't meet. Nev and co-host Tallulah Willis take Dallas on a wild ride as they hunt for Safari.
Nev and co-host Slick Woods help 19-year-old Aubri search for her Snapchat love, Brian. Brian says he lives at Aubri's college but makes several excuses not to meet. With little to go on, Nev and Slick hit the campus in search of answers.
Co-host popstar, Elle King joins Nev to help Nique find her Tumblr love, Alice. Digging deep leads to more questions than answers as Nev and Elle have concerns about who Alice could be and what her true intentions are with Nique.
Nev and NFL star Rashad Jennings help Deven find his mysterious online love, James. James won't videochat yet he invites Deven to fly across the country to meet him. Hopeful for love but prepared for a trap, Deven needs answers.
Nev and co-host Kamie Crawford help Mathan find Leah, a girl he's been talking to for a decade yet can never meet, but Leah has shocking secrets beyond their wildest imaginations that will lead them on one of their toughest chases to date.
When Kristina met Faith in a chatroom, she didn't intend to fall in love and betray her fiancé. Now Nev and co-host Tallulah Willis navigate a treacherous love triangle as they embark on an epic hunt to find the truth.
Nev and Slick Woods investigate the mystery of Oceanna and her enigmatic, online stalker, Nelly. When Oceanna's ex-girlfriend Kira becomes involved though, the team are left wondering who is a victim and who is the perpetrator.
Nev and co-host Elle King help Angel find her online love, Remy, but the closest Angel has gotten to Remy was when he was creepily watching her from outside her car. Angel needs answers but may not be ready for the truth.
Taylor needs help after falling for a guy who claims to have gone to her high school, but she doesn't remember him. Nev and co-host Tallulah dig in to Taylor's tale, only to uncover secrets more shocking than they ever expected.
Kimiko Glenn joins Nev in helping Matthew find his elusive Instagram love, Chance. But as they search for answers, they run into unsurpassable roadblocks that make them question whether we'll ever have a chance to find Chance.
Nev and co-host Kamie help a lovestruck Navajo girl on her vision quest to find the Zuni man she loves, a man who not only admitted to being a drug smuggler but also claimed to have died, leaving everyone desperate for answers.
Tristyn and Lara have cultivated their love over the course of several months on the internet but things may be completely different when they meet in person for the first time.
