When The Good Place aired its series finale on January 30, 2020, it wasn’t just the characters who walked through the final door—the show itself left a space in our TV landscape that remains unfilled five years later. Remember how we all collectively gasped at that season one finale? Or sobbed during those final episodes? Yeah, me too.

The smart, heartfelt comedy about ethics, philosophy, and what it means to be human gave us four perfect seasons without overstaying its welcome. It managed to be hilarious while tackling some of life’s biggest questions, and honestly, what other show has done that so well? None, that’s what.

As we mark five years since Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani, Jason, Michael, and Janet said their final goodbyes, let’s dive into the ten things we miss most about this utterly unique series. Fair warning: you might need to grab some tissues… or a frozen yogurt.