Norah says that their friend disappeared "without a trace, like the show", and then the camera shows the face of Elena Roarke considering very seriously this information. Roselyn Sanchez previously starred in Without a Trace (2002) playing Elena Delgado.
Maureen McCormick (Rosemarie) was in six episodes of the original Fantasy Island (1977) series, playing six different characters.
Maureen McCormick is the first guest to appear in both the original Fantasy Island (1977) series and this one.