Change Your Image
bigbadbear69
Reviews
The Treaty (1991)
Very good but...
As a member of my family (Robert Barton) was one of the Irish negotiators of the treaty, I tracked this down and watched it a few nights ago on YouTube.
I would agree with the views expressed that The Treaty is an historically accurate although dramatised account of events that led to the situation we have today.
Maybe I have a biased viewpoint but I think the character of Michael Collins dominates this too much. This drama focuses on the treaty negotiations and more could have been made of the of the split between Collins, Griffith and Duggan who were in favour of the treaty and Barton and Childers who were against, particularly as the division was referred to early on.
Nonetheless, far better than "Michael Collins"!
Utopia (2013)
One-sided rubbish!
The treatment of Australian aborigines was indeed shocking but this film is so biased, one-sided and dishonest that it does not help their cause one bit. Pilger ignores the fact that since the late 1960's (at least) successive governments have made strenuous efforts to make reparations. He blames the mining industry but some Aboriginal groups get a substantial income out of leasing land to mining companies and that the mining companies do employ Aboriginals. There are some successful Aboriginals. Pilger does not interview a single one. Why not? Pilger ignores the terrible problems caused by drink and levels of violence. It is worth noting that Pilger has not lived in Australia for decades but prefers to fly in every so often, criticise the country of his birth and then fly out again.