Just because you're making a movie about a tragedy does not mean that the audience will instantaneously commiserate with the characters involved. As I sit and watch this movie I feel that my emotions are somehow manipulated so as to force me to feel something I did not want to feel.
Throughout the course of this film I sensed that perhaps the lead character, Oskar, was supposed to connect with us and even though he was granted pretty much the whole two hours of the movie's screen time to do so, failed miserably. His acting was too exaggerated that it was almost unreal. The performance he gave was almost cartoonish, and the feelings he spoke of were not reciprocated in his actions. I am sure I am not alone when I say that I felt absolutely nothing for his character. Yes one or two scenes succeeded at unleashing a few bursts of grief within me, but they sunk back into my untouched heart just as quickly as they had appeared.
There was one scene in particular that started to grab my attention, where Oskar managed to blurt out his quite disturbing desire for his mother's death, in a rather malicious manner. So, instead of relating to the lead character, our hands are forced into resenting him during his entire performance.
So, the only thing Oskar succeeded at was that he somehow managed to engrave an unforgettable impression in our minds
and not a good one at that. The word "obnoxious" popped up in my head over and over again every time Oskar popped on the screen, which was pretty much all the time, unfortunately. And dare I say that he was indeed incredibly loud
loud and unbearable.
Von Sydow was nice to watch and he gave us a tad bit of hope that the film might take a turn for the better, but not even his authentic performance could save this awkward flop of a movie. However, I have to admit that the last half hour of the movie eased my pain, and that each time Sandra Bullock came on screen I felt somehow safe. She managed to hold the movie together with her genuine portrayal of how far a mother's affection can go. But, that sense of security soon vanished when Sandra was no longer on the screen. So, all in all, kudos Sandra, but this movie's demise was just inevitable.
I am deeply saddened by the fact that I had eagerly waited for the release of this motion picture, but what a waste that proved to be. Extremely loud & incredibly close takes you on a journey you are ever so reluctant to take, and gives you reasons supporting that reluctance that only grows stronger as the movie progresses. The movie was nothing more than a kid trying to find a lock that fits a key entrusted to him by his father, and never did it feel like anything other than just that. Although, I feel I should mention that it did succeed at leaving us feeling pity for the mother and contentment that we weren't the ones having to deal with Oskar!
Oh, I forgot to mention that Tom Hanks was featured in this film, and for those brief moments we watched him on the big screen, we waited for a breakthrough performance that never came through. We waited for so much throughout the course of the movie, but it turned out to be a sham, and we left the theater more annoyed and agitated than content and moved.
2012 has yet to prove that it's a good year for movie buffs everywhere, as all the evidence so far is pretty much against it. And so we'll wait for that flick that will turn the tables for this year
6/10
0 out of 4 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends