Reviews

12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Nana (2011)
7/10
A dramatic but naturalistic avante garde film
30 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Photographer/artist Valerie Massadian's debut film 'NANA' tells the sentimental and momentarily disturbing story of a bright four-year-old girl left alone in the woods for days, when her seemingly depressed mother suddenly goes missing. This piece cleared awards for 64 degrees' Festival de film Locarno Best First Feature, Fic Valdivia International Film Competition 2011, and the Istanbul International Independent Film Festival 2012.

The film opens to a locked-off single-shot of a long, manual and unfabricated execution of a farmed pig. Two male relatives of Nana slowly comfort the animal in order to shoot a pulse of air into its brain, stunning it into a violent shake before draining its blood. The young girl watches this from the doorway of the barn by her mothers' side; questioning and stating facts, more intrigued than concerned. They proceed to cook the animal, covering it in straw and setting a small fire. This seemingly uncut and torturous scene, agonising to watch and causing vocal disgust amongst the audience, set up for the scape of the film; the raw, country lifestyle in which many children grow up.

The next scene contrasts with a far lighter mood. Nana sits in her Grandfather's lap in the barn where piglets slowly make their way out of hiding. The two pet the piglets and laugh together before she adorably exclaims '--they're little roasts!' catching you off-guard, knowing what she had just witnessed. Taking you through the day-to-day regular occurrences, she and her mother spend their time together in a very relaxed atmosphere sharing dialogue over a minimalistic track; running around the countryside, climbing over tree stumps and collecting the essentials of life - firewood, water, setting up rabbit's traps, etc. A heart-warming scene of the girl in hysterics as her mother sprays water into her face is one of the last moments we see them together.

The woman's disappearance is ambiguous and untold. It is now that the girl wakes up alone; seemingly unphased by the fact that no one is around. She goes about her day as she always has, walking through the countryside collecting life's essentials. She follows the same path, throwing wood into the fire, collecting the trapped rabbit and taking it home, then using the same burning technique she witnessed her Grandfather perform earlier on the pig.

The dramatic but naturalistic piece is ultimately about the underestimated ability of young children and survival at a susceptible age; following learned habits and tricks of those who have nurtured the child. With no one around, there are themes of isolation, loneliness and solitude, perhaps relating to the disappearance of Mama. Massadian seems to have been curious about how exactly a child would act if they were to be left alone under such strange circumstances, and has just let the action take place, seemingly bordering on documentary. Nana swears confidently and openly as she draws and role-plays as a character from her past. As one would grow to expect from a photographer, the film is a visual masterpiece utilizing natural light to illuminate locations and moods. The avante-garde film, being a first for both the cast and the director, is something to see even in terms of studying the human psyche.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Good Person (2023)
10/10
A simple but moving, bittersweet indie drama
23 March 2024
I wasn't sure whether to give this 10 stars because it didn't "excel" in any outstanding way, but I don't really have any complaints. It was beautiful, and technically perfect.

I knew nothing about this film going into it, and I think that's exactly how you need to approach it to appreciate its themes and very personal mood.

I only watched this movie because I really enjoyed watching Florence Pugh in Midsommar and Don't Worry Darling, and saw that she was in this recent film.

The narrative doesn't exactly break new ground, have innovative storytelling techniques, or any other gimmicks, because it doesn't need to or want to. I think the film success in its simplicity, because of its simplicity.

The film is self contained, straightforward narrative told beautifully.

The cinematography is similarly subtle but professionally performed, with gorgeous colour pallets without detracting from its realism or immersion.

It is beautiful by its own standard and succeeds at what it is trying to achieve. It was perfect by the criteria you would judge this film.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bright Lights (2004)
9/10
Shoot Out Geelong - Most Memorable Film
30 April 2011
Out of all of the years that I had attended the 24-hour Shoot Out in Geelong, this is by far the most memorable film that I had seen. The story was absolutely adorable, was beautifully shot and actually had me considering it to this day. It may be one of the reasons that I have decided to follow film as a career. To have been watching Jarrah Gurries other short films recently, it is incredible and inspiring to find that this film was done by him. He is definitely one of my new favorite directors; right up there with Gregg Araki.

I suggest watching this film knowing the restrictions of the film competition - the film was to be done entirely in-camera on tape (with only linear editing allowed), written, shot and handed-in within 24-hours.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Gran Torino (2008)
5/10
Builds up to fizzle out - One watch only
25 January 2009
The majority of the movie was good. It was funny, it was witty and it was interesting. I sat and just continued waiting for it to get better, and it just didn't. It turned out to be a comedy with a dark back story.

There was so much racism from the Walt, but it was done in a humorous and generally unoffensive tone (and every race is dealt with, so there is no racism). Watching the different cultures come together was very interesting.

I was sitting in the theater just waiting for it to get back to the dark setting to open up. The movie creates a fair amount of rage within you, watching all the gangsters hurt characters that you get close to. You just can't wait to see how Walt will get them back.

Then low and behold -- the most predictable ending ever. Hardly entertaining, hardly moving. For an older person (middle aged to whatever) who doesn't watch many films (my parents exactly) they may indeed love the entire movie.

But to me, an avid watcher of films (well over a few thousand) it did nothing for me. Sure, I smiled a few times, I grew angry at the gangs, but it went to nothing. It really didn't do anything for me, and I will never watch this movie again (it's barely worth hiring for the first watch). Don't expect an action/thriller scene at all in this comic drama. For a final film for Clint -- it was poor.
1 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Fight scenes that make you puke.
26 December 2008
The whole movie was a total let down. I enjoyed the first movie as it was interesting, but this was just a waste of time and money.

The whole movie screamed at me "WE HAVE A HIGH BUDGET!!"... I don't care. They didn't manage to achieve anything. The whole movie seemed like it was dark and everything, but there was nothing particularly moving about the whole thing. All they did was destroy few things and run around some cities with a few hundred extras.

When I watched the fight scenes, my jaw dropped. Most certainly not in a good way, either. It was some extremely shaky filming and fast cuts. The majority of the time I had no idea what was going on. The fighting itself wasn't too bad, it was like the Vernita Green fight from Kill Bill, but everything was far too shaky and twisted. There were a few shots that I swear were actually upside down. While watching the fight again on YouTube I realized that I wasn't just being picky when I first watched it, it was THAT terrible. It would be the perfect fight to watch if you adore motion sickness.

The whole timing of the guy running around between the extras was pathetic. It was the same crap you see in any spy movie, but it was executed terribly. There was no spark, if you've seen anything like it before you'll know how bad it was done.

My parents were surprised to see my reaction to the movie as I loved action and thriller movies. I went with a group of 40-year-olds, most of them enjoyed it... I was close to shooting myself.

The entire movie was directed, filmed and edited pretty bad.

I can see how some people like it -- they simply never see any dramatic, thriller or action movies.

Watching the trailer on YouTube I barely recognize the movie, which just proves how unmemorable and plainly different the trailer is to the movie. I honestly couldn't look past the shaky camera work - it was just distracting. I might watch this movie again just to make sure that it IS that bad, and I'm not just making diamonds out of coal.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Resident Evil (2002)
10/10
Great movie.
26 December 2008
I have seen a lot of movies in my time, but this one kicked their butts! It got my number 1! In about 2005 I went to a friends place for her Birthday. We all sat down and started watching some movies. This was the only one that we could agree on. I was entranced through out the entire movie. The story, the characters, the mythology, it was captivating.

A beautiful woman in a red dress, suffering from amnesia and being surrounded by anyones worst nightmares is enough to get the movie going. The progression was fantastic. Things never turned out the way you would expect.

After I saw the movie, I hired it a few times from Video Easy. After about 3-4 hires I couldn't do it anymore. I needed to buy it. I bought it on VHS, but I was disappointed at the quality. I watched it another ten times. I then hired the DVD a few more times. During that time, I hired, watched (46 times) and bought Resident Evil: Extinction. We went to Thailand for a holiday, and I bought a copy the number 1. It was a pirate. Disappointedly, I came home and bought it again.

After watching it a few dozen times, and researching Resident Evil on the net a few times I was ecstatic that there was a third coming out. I counted down the days for the next 9 months and got a group of 10 people and got them to join me in seeing it at the cinemas. We all loved it. I heard nothing bad from anyone. My blood felt strange, and I was in awe for the next week. I am just waiting now to buy it.

If I could, I would send my money directly to them.

I have watched the original about 30 times now, Apocalypse about 46 times, and Extinction 7 times. I bought the original Resident Evil on 3 different formats. If that doesn't say how good this movie is, I don't know what does.

A really well done movie.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Brave One (2007)
10/10
Underrated. High expectations completely fulfilled.
25 December 2008
I watched this movie not long ago. My original expectations were very high. I was expecting a cross between what I and my parents would watch. I am a bit of an action/horror geek. My parents are into dramatic movies that I often find boring. The thing that shocked me, though, was that this movie was not boring for a second, everything was down to Earth and you have complete compassion for the characters.

Jodie Foster carried this roll so well, it is honestly some of the best acting I have seen in my life. I was so shocked to see a woman who I had seen playing rolls like Flightplan, Inside Man and Panic Room in such a breathtaking roll (not saying they weren't good, but they don't really compare). She was hardcore, believable, honest and mesmerizing all at the same time. I do not believe anyone else could perform this roll as well as she did. It's like every other movie she had performed in was just getting her experience to play this roll. I was never really a fan of Jodie, she was a fairly everyday actor to me, but now... She is the best.

The writing was really interesting. Everything that occurred I fond completely believable, but it still had that action movie smash to it that I love. The movie from start to finish pulled out so many emotions, I was furious, anxious, depressed, mystified, gob-smacked, mind-blown, happy-sad, my stomach sank a few times and I was scared. There were moments where you feel exactly what the characters are feeling, you want to smash the guy in the head. You want to stand up for yourself. You see the frightening actions played out in-front of you, which is exactly what the lead character was feeling. The monologues fit into the movie, and they didn't detach you from the movie.

The characters were all fantastic, all played out exceptionally. I don't know who I should thank, though. Do I thank the director for bringing out such greatness, or do I thank the actors for showing their talent? Everything is perfect. There is not a moment of long-lasting slow motion, there is no camera shot that gets boring, everything is there to explain what is happening.

This movie hits that mark of Hard Candy, Mysterious Skin, 2:37, Haute Tension, but then surpasses them all with shocking and interesting locations, sets (everything is believable, I am unsure if there is an actual set in the movie), cinematography, direction, editing, color correction and other technical techniques. The thing is, it hits the exceptional mark of everything, but NEVER goes beyond that line to become over-the-top, stupid, boring, or just a plain waste of time.

Honestly, this could very well be my favorite movie of all time (and yes, I have seen thousands of movies). I just need to make sure that the re-watch-ability is as much as it is in my head. I honestly have no idea what else to say. I would pay well over $100 for the DVD, it's just THAT good. I am shocked that other IMDb users have rated it down to 6.9 stars! This movie is really good, and deserves nothing under 9 stars.

If you skipped through all that chitter-chatter about how AWESOME this movie is... just go see the movie. It's perfect.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Rush (2008–2011)
9/10
One of the best Aussie shows I've seen.
10 December 2008
It is surprisingly impressive. I would expect something of this caliber from a higher budget American studio (everyone knows America has the best technically inclined staff at their disposal).

When I watched the first episode I was in awe, this show was much better then next to anything I'd expect from Australia. It has so many things you just wouldn't expect from an Aussie show, and it's on so many more levels. The technical skills and creativity are much better then most other shows on the same budget.

I went to the 24 Hour Film making festival of 2008, and I was surprised to find the lead actress of the first episode there (Aurora). The directors make the actors look great.

It is better then most other cop shows. The stories are a lot more complex and things are done more interestingly. It's not just "find the evidence, yell at the killer", it is visually entertaining and more intellectual. They characters aren't just run off the mill killers, there are large stories behind them all.

It obviously doesn't have the budget of CSI, but it is certainly more interesting (I mean, who wants to watch a monotonous guy wearing sunglasses indoors?). It's more like Law and Order, but even then, the technical skills are better and it makes it visually more entertaining.

I do have to admit, watching it for the second time around it's not as shocking as the first time around, but lightening doesn't strike in the same place twice. I am glad it has been brought back for an encore series. I'll finally get to watch the episodes I missed!
22 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Out of the Blue (2008– )
2/10
Like Home & Away, but more pathetic.
9 December 2008
It is very much like Home & Away in the sets (majority is in a seaside diner) and acting performance. The actors are all fairly attractive, as well.

It is unlike Home & Away that it is so dull, the acting makes all the sentences the exact same (if they reveal a killer, its the same as tone as if they talked about going to sleep the night before). The cameras they use always have a fuzzy white wash on it, it makes the entire show seem so low quality.

The cinematography is pathetic. It's like they pulled it out of the rulebook, but didn't quite understand. It's like everything is filmed with a $200 Mini DV camera on a tripod. The slight pans are just stupid and a waste of time. The audio is very bland and boring. It honestly looks like it was shot with something much worse then a cheap Mini DV camera.

It tries to go further then Home & Away with more camera angles (but definitely not better), a more ambitious story and a more freelance look (going to more locations). It doesn't pass, though. Everything it tries it pretty much crumbles.

The "year 12 student" looks like he's 25. The story might indeed be interesting, but it's certainly not shown.

Technically this show is pathetic, it's so bad I can't continue to watch anymore. The tone is horrible. If my friends made this movie, I would tell them it's horrible. It's that bad.

This isn't even cut out for YouTube. I have definitely seen better stuff on YouTube.
8 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Stick It (2006)
9/10
Good for any gymnast.
9 December 2008
I was really impressed.

There are so many things that are so agreeable if you have ever tried to do any of it.

It's very well done and interesting. The cinematography, color, quality and sets are awesome.

This movie is great. I would very much like to see it again.

It might indeed be a movie worth only watching on DVD, however.

The style is very much like Step Up 2, but is a little more down to earth.

I really enjoyed watching it on TV.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Kath & Kim (2008–2009)
3/10
Doesn't compare to the Aussie version
8 December 2008
It isn't TOO bad, but ultimately it lacks the quality that the Australian series has.

The jokes are few and far between, the actors are attractive (they shouldn't be), the film makers think far too much about the cinematography (it's supposed to look like a home video) and it's just like a serious version of Kath and Kim... it's stupid.

It's too normal to be Kath and Kim. Kath and Kim are supposed to be two curvy, middle-aged women who think they are hot and wear ridiculous clothes. There are no "Look at me Kimmy!" jokes. The fat friend of Kim is not fat at all and she's not even slightly stupid. She's a stereotypical black/Latino chick.

It's just not as stupid or funny as the Australian series. It doesn't compare. Nothing is the same. I admit, this show is pretty funny at times, but it is NOT anything like the Aussie series. I was looking forward to an American take on a bogan family. They failed. It's supposed to be REALLY stupid and hilarious, but the actors don't act stupid! To me, this is just a typical American TV show. It's a let down if you want it to be anything like the Aussie show.

2 Stars because it is an OKAY show, just nothing like what it should be.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hex (2004–2005)
10/10
AWESOME SHOW, definitely should continue.
12 November 2008
When I first saw in the DVD shop I thought it would be a nice show like Buffy or Angel, but I was wrong... IT WAS SO MUCH BETTER! This show is perfect. The first few episodes it was a little slow (and I mean little) but it started to pick up speed and it snowballed and its just each breath-taking episode after each other now.

There were so many themes and metaphors that I was impressed that they managed to include on a television program. This isn't a kids show (although it is safe). It makes you think and not just about the actual show, but about your own life and what you believe.

Definitely the best show I have ever seen. It's like watching heaps of awesome movies after each other. I have laughed, cried and been incredibly shocked by this show. It is simply superb.

I thought Angel and Buffy were good... they really don't compare to Hex. Each script, character, stunt, special effect, camera technique is done perfectly. The opening theme... I honestly can't describe how good this show is without raving.

Don't be discouraged by my enthusiastic answer either, I am very critical when it comes to film and television, I am a film maker myself. This show is way beyond its time and better then anything I have ever seen.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed