This version is OK but I always felt they get the character of Scrooge wrong and the conversion to "good Scrooge" is rather abrupt compared to the book. There IS a transition stage.
As with many versions, Scrooge is sort of a caricature of a greedy capitalist foregoing personal connections in the pursuit of wealth. This is a wholly inaccurate and less complex version of the character than is presented by Dickens, the greatest psychologist of the 18th century.
I submit that Scrooge is the product of childhood trauma and as result he has gone through life with a major feeling of inferiority along with a need to prove his value.
As a child, Scrooge is isolated from family by his father. The only warmth or compassion he comes upon prior to Fezzywink was that of his sister, who dies young (another source of trauma).
Under Fezzywink, Scrooge is happy and meets his fiance. She comes from a family of greater means than he does and is viewed by Scrooge and others as too good for him. Thus, due to his childhood, Scrooge feels the need to earn love from others. In his mind, the way to become worthy of her love is to increase his social standing through the pursuit of wealth.
In the process of chasing wealth as a means to earn affection he does not feel worthy of, he pushes her away (possible avoidant behavior). After this, his APPEARANCE is that of a greedy miser happy with being alone and caring for no one but himself.
I submit they Scrooge NEVER changes. He was ALWAYS the man we see at the end of the film. The reality is that he was too afraid to become close to anyone after his father, sister, and fiance. He is not a bad person. He is merely afraid of caring for others. The pursuit of wealth is merely a replacement for the love he desires.
Thus, the conversion of Scrooge in this film reflects a tired old misinterpretation of the original story. Almost every version tends to portray Scrooge in this manner, aside from the 1984 version. He might be the most misunderstood and misinterpreted character outside of Dr. Jekyll.
0 out of 5 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends