A Tale of Three Sisters (2019) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
You may leave your village, but the village will still stay with you
ayoreinf28 July 2019
Good cinematography, good actors, a story that's a bit short on originality, but since the actors as I said are good, with Kayhan Acikgoz as Veysel and Ece Yuksel as Nurhan topping the cast, but not by much. And the good actors carry you through the story, even if it's a story I've seen many times before.

Don't get me wrong, it's an important story, the story of how hard it is to really get away from your village, from the place where you were born. Or in other words, as I said in the title, how your village refuses to leave you, even when you did get away. A story about how your place of origin is more than just a social background. I do wish it was more original, but even as is it's a good movie.

One more point I wish to make: this story is being told in a very theatrical style. Using the actual setting of the village and the harsh nature around as a stage, and maintaining strict loyality to the theatrical unities of time and place. But this is a very cinematic theater, and that's the way theater should look like in cinema.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Beautiful!
manuelmandalina26 July 2019
I watched this film at the Ankara Film Festival. I think it was one of the best films of the Festival.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A village at Central Anatolia
suheylkahramaner22 September 2019
I was waiting to watch this movie for almost a year. The movie shed lights on the close relatives relations on a typical central Anatolia village. It clears the issues known to everyone but nobody has enough dare to mention. I really enjoyed, it will be the one of the masterpieces of Emin Alper movies.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Lovely photography, despite suffering, very good to rejoice in such an adverse culture...
RosanaBotafogo17 July 2021
A sad tale, a society where people are subjugated all the time, women subjected to masculine decisions, young people considered incapable, the harbinger of a tragedy, there is no one just good or bad, but acting in accordance with a prejudiced, rooted culture sexist and hierarchist, lovely photography, despite suffering, very good to rejoice in such an adverse culture, its peculiarities, simplicity, rustic and rude... Filled with symbolism, the scorpion, the woman of somersaults, the cold and the stone houses. ..
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Awesome; a masterpiece!!!
gokselll30 October 2019
Watching this movie in theatre was a rare experience that I've got such tremendous artistic pleasure for a long while. Emin Alper gifts a masterpiece to his audience with this movie; congatulations!!!

After "Tepenin Ardi" and "Abluka", we witness a new, original film grammar and a peculiar cinematographical point of view by Emin Alper. (I loved those first two movies, as well; I only emphasize the cinematic-stylistic differences between the works) Unlike his first movies, Alper tells no direct-political word in order to signify tender links among the story, actuality and socio-political formations of individuals.

On the contrary, the director masterfully pictures everyday life in a (unidentified) rural region in Turkey and he, for political context of the movie, trusts to the fact that true narration and ordinary details of everyday life naturally presents a stronge and rational political view.

The magnificence of this movie underlies the balanced combination of;

aesthetic composition of visual narration which plays a leading role rather than just supporting the speeches,

avoiding agitative language and redundant action scenes while keeping the tension across the story,

charming and very succesfull acting performances (though every player performs on upper levels, as a very personal admiration; I tremendously loved the shepherd Veysel and middle sister Nurhan),

balanced presentation of psychological motivations and surrounding material conditions, etc...

The movie, within a single and usual story, touches women's problems, restricted opportunities of provincial life and invisible social class links determining the vectors of all kind of human relations.

And finally, I think that the director achieves to form a cinematic langue beyond boundaries basing on a very local story.

Absolutely, all cinema lovers should see.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
We love Emin Alper
se-mu-ko27 April 2020
Actualy this film so sincerity but the story was like a ''Channel 7''s television movie shot... with high budget and perfect actors.
2 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A village in the middle of Anatolia...
ilovesaturdays14 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This is the story of a father and his three daughters. The father is a widower living in a village in Central Anatolia. He is a simple man who takes great pride in the fact that he is good friends with the village chief. He feels that he has done well by all his daughters. After all, he found them good foster homes where they were kept in relative comfort in exchange for looking after their foster siblings! Thus, he finds himself to be out of options when one by one all his daughters return back to the village after losing their positions in their foster homes in the city. He does not understand the emotional needs of his daughters and yet one can't help but feel sorry for the poor guy. He is an old-fashioned chap who is ill-equipped to handle the crises in his daughters' lives without their mother at his side.

Reyhan, the eldest daughter, is a new mother. Her baby is the pride and joy of her life. As the story unfolds, we learn that she had an affair with her foster father, Mr. Necati, who also happens to be a doctor. At some point in the story, she hints that Mrs. Necati once caught them in flagrante delicto. Reyhan is sent back to the village where she later discovers that she is pregnant with the doctor's child (Did I say that the movie requires a little bit of suspension of disbelief?). When she has labour pains, she runs into the forest and has her baby all by herself! She then goes to town and leaves the baby on the doctor's doorstep hoping that he'll take care of it. A while later, in the hope that she can probably take care of all the children of the doctor's household, she goes back. The doctor's wife gets suspicious and Reyhan is asked to return to her village along with her infant son. Back in the village, she marries Veysel. However, she finds it hard to respect or love him, even though she is not above taking advantage of his inebriated condition!

Nurhan is the quintessential middle child. She is desperate for attention and affection. She replaces Reyhan in the doctor's household after Reyhan is sent back to the village. She loves the children but is resentful of the bedwetting habits of one of her charges. She figures that if she catches a cold, she would not be asked to wash the soiled sheets and perhaps her foster parents would take measures to stop their son's bedwetting behaviour. However, she is horrified to find that her foster parents still expect her to wash the soiled sheets even though she is ill. She gets rebellious, tries to discipline the bedwetter and is soon kicked out of her foster house.

Havva, the youngest daughter, is the most naive character in the story. She lost her position in her foster home because her charge died. Back in her village home, the home of her birth, she feels like a stranger. The house seems new to her. She misses her foster mother and the deceased baby. She even dreams of giving birth to a baby who resembles her beloved charge, prompting her return to the foster home! Her father is trying to place her in the doctor's home provoking Nurhan's jealousy. She learns of her eldest sister, Reyhan's past and is deeply disappointed. Then, she sees the sick Nurhan suffer while the doctor, her foster parent doesn't even bother to pay her a visit.

Veysel is Reyhan's husband. He loves her even though he knows that she only married him for the sake of her child. He wants to make a good life for his little family but being illiterate, uncultured and jobless, he finds himself at a great disadvantage. To make matters worse, the village has a dying economy; the coal mines are collapsing and the young people find themselves with no job opportunities. Veysel hates tending his father-in-law's sheep, but being penniless and untrained, he doesn't have much choice. He is tired and frustrated of being considered a bumbling idiot. He asks the doctor to get him a job in the city but his jealousy gets the better of him. At this point, you pity him and feel that he is his own worst enemy. Soon enough, in a fit of terrible rage, he accidentally ends up killing his foster son! On a run from the police, he finds himself in the company of bandits, the very people that he is afraid of during the beginning of the movie. However, the harsh frost-ridden winters and bad company prove to be his undoing. He seeks absolution for his sins from Reyhan but the bereaved mother is too angry to be forgiving. She even tells him that she is pregnant with his child but would go to Ankara & get it aborted. Guilty, desperate and heart broken, he hangs himself.

This movie has a plot that reminded me of a Greek tragedy. The characters are all trying to break a vicious circle, but their circumstances get the better of their intentions. The father finds himself in a vicious circle of offering one after the other of his daughters to the doctor's household, even though it always ends badly. Reyhan makes mistakes after mistakes, ultimately hurting herself, her offspring and all the rest of the family in the process. Nurhan pays for her bad decisions with her health and possibly her life. Veysel's misfortune and temper bring a lot of suffering all around and eventually his life falls into a downward spiral.

Overall, a good movie with perfect acting, cinematography and direction. Unfortunately, it has an uneven storyline.

P. S. This reviewer couldn't help but notice that the only happy person in this story was the crazy lady who enjoyed half somersaults on the floor!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A masterwork
vesnastavrevska19 February 2022
This wonderful story is told with such intensity and subtlety, that resembles the craft of Arthur Miller. With its twists and turns, the story unfolds such that one cannot grasp its complexity all at once. Alper depicts the multidimensionality of culture in a very neutral, unjudgemental way. His characters surrender to norms or fight against them, but nonetheless are captured like butterflies in a jar, relentlessly aiming at an escape through the glass walls, towards the world.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Picturesque Village, Touching Tales
8bithummingbird6 August 2021
As the title says it is the tale of three sisters holding on to each other during times of separation.

We witness stories of love, hatred, suffering, helplessness, fear, hope and dream through the eyes of women.

The village is so picturesque and mountains are breathtaking, this adds melancholy to the stories.

If you wanna have a pastoral evening witnessing sincere women stories, here's your pick, don't miss it!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Grand Master Emin Alper
yusufpiskin6 June 2021
A great Emin Alper movie. I wish I could see the world like Emin Alper. I think he is the only filmmaker I want to meet in Turkish cinema. To praise a movie, you can say "Like Emin Alper's work"
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed