"American Masters" Miles Davis: Birth of the Cool (TV Episode 2019) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
18 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
sweet sound, not a sweet man
ferguson-626 September 2019
Greetings again from the darkness. The idea of a PBS "American Masters" documentary on jazz great Miles Davis could be cause for concern. The series is known for its high-level and mostly favorable profiles of influential people. Would the series go "deep" enough? Would it gloss over the dark side? Would it be able to capture the essence of an enigmatic man who changed the music world more than once? The final result is a documentary that acts as a terrific primer for those unfamiliar with Miles Davis, and one that should satisfy his most ardent fans as it chronicles each stage of the music. For this we can thank Stanley Nelson, a documentarian who has delivered several projects on the history of African-Americans.

By definition, the 'cradle-to-grave' approach limited to a 2 hour run time means certain aspects must be glossed over. We learn that Miles' father was a dentist in East Saint Louis, allowing them to be the second wealthiest black family in the state. Of course, this did not shield them from racism and segregation, or even domestic violence within their home ... a trait that Miles would carry throughout his own relationships later in life. "Music comes before everything." It's a battle cry from the memoir, "Miles: The Autobiography". The film features actor Carl Lumbly narrating many of Miles' own words throughout the film - with Lumbly's voice bearing a sufficient resemblance to Miles' distinct sound.

Montages of photos are utilized, initially to kick off the film with shots of Miles performing on stage, and then to mark the specific social and political era as the timeline shifts (1944, 1955, 1969, etc). Interviews are conducted with East Saint Louis residents, Miles' childhood friends, musicians - those he played with and those he influenced, writers, and historians. Each brings their own perspective to telling Miles' story, and perhaps none is more insightful than former dancer Frances Taylor, who was married to him from 1968-78. This era and their marriage was a key element of the 2015 film MILES APART starring Don Cheadle. Ms. Taylor passed away in 2018, and her recollections hold much weight and insight into Miles off stage.

The advantage of a chronological recap of his career is that it allows for a clear grasp of just how often the music of Miles Davis evolved over the years. At age 17, he was playing with Dizzy Gillespie and Charlie Parker, and in 1955 at the Newport Jazz Festival he introduced a new style that shook the industry and landed him a lucrative recording contract. He took film score to a new place with Louis Malle's ELEVATOR TO THE GALLOWS and later played with the great John Coltrane. Of course Miles' seminal 1959 album "Kind of Blue" is discussed by many who note the impact it had on jazz and music in general. We hear from Wayne Shorter, Herbie Hancock and Carlos Santana as each tries to describe a sound that defies description.

As he himself proclaimed, Miles was all about the music; and because of this, it makes sense that the film focuses on his innovative approach. Director Nelson does not, however, ignore the dark side of the man. As far back as high school Miles was "a genius and weird", but lifelong battles with drugs and alcohol, and his history of being a difficult and violent partner, put the personal side in stark contrast to the beauty of his music. His first two wives, Frances Taylor and singer Betty Mabry, both documented his violent temper, and it's a little disappointing that his third wife, actress Cicely Tyson was not interviewed for the film. They were married from 1981-88. Ms. Tyson turns 95 years old this year, and is still a working actor. It was the younger Ms. Mabry that revamped Miles' fashion and introduced him to Jimi Hendrix and Sly Stone, helping usher in the jazz fusion era.

We do learn the story behind the recognizable raspy voice, and the film covers his time at Julliard, his first trip to Paris (where he met actress Juliette Greco), his collaboration with arranger Gil Evans, the influence of Clive Davis, and his performance with Quincy Jones not long before Miles died in 1991. It's details like Miles Davis music provided the template for Hip-Hop that make the film click, but of course the real joy is derived from hearing his music from 5 decades of work. Someone in the movie states "I want to feel the way Miles sounds." And we know exactly what she means.
37 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An inside look at the legendary musician's tortured soul.
eelen-seth22 May 2019
Miles Davis was a jazz musician with a big impact on the music industry, even up to this day. A cultural phenomenon who didn't play by the rules, but did everything on his own terms and with success. Interestingly enough, there hasn't really been a decent documentary made about his life, until now.

Director Stanley Nelson takes us backstage and on to a journey into the highs and lows of Davis' career and personal life, with the respect this legend deserves. He shows us his road to success, breaks down his relationships and doesn't shy away from the darker side of his breakdown. Every strength and weakness get discussed in detail and analysed by professionals and musicians who had the chance to meet the man himself. From Quincy Jones and Carlos Santana to his children. For the hardcore fans, some of the footage might be familiar, but there is new material being shown that has been archived for years.

Miles Davis comes from a honourable family, but still has to deal with segregation in Illinois, in spite of his talent and success. After becoming a breakout star in the United States of America, he embarks on a European tour where he gets welcomed as a world star. Paris has a huge impact on his future career, but this dream doesn't last long as he needs to return back to New York, where he always felt like living in a confined domain. An addiction to heroin, and depression soon haunt him for the rest of his life. Always being afraid of becoming the mirror image of his abusive father, he becomes just that. His former partners speak out on the violence they had to endure and how they were able to escape that toxic environment.

His music gets analysed and we hear plenty of his early style of jazz - bebop - growing into the more experimental phase of his music into the 70s. His sound was unique, even when he reimagined himself completely when stepping back into the scene the last decade of his life. A king that will always be remembered by his success, style and class.

The film itself wants to connect mostly with a more familiar with jazz-audience than a younger one that grew up with poppy forgettable tunes. But when disregarding that certain audience, you might miss out on the opportunity to pull that group in and take them on that journey that is Miles Davis. You can tell his estate was heavily involved in the making of this film, by the amount of footage and music used - it's impressive and that's certainly understated. But what is noticeable in music docs this decade, is the lack of subjectiveness. This could make the film more visually pleasing and go even deeper into Davis' music and career.

Miles Davis: Birth of the Cool gives us a look at the legendary musician's tortured soul who was unpredictable in his actions as in his craft. He changed the game for everyone with his creativity and point of view. If only they showcased that bolder side of his personality, this film could've become something more than just solid.
19 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Gorgeous.
imseeg3 January 2021
I was really amazed to read that there had not been made a comprehensive documentary about the work and life of Miles Davis yet. With full access to the Miles Davis Estate, this film features never-before-seen footage, including studio outtakes from his recording sessions, rare photos and new interviews. Quincy Jones, Carlos Santana, Clive Davis, Wayne Shorter and Ron Carter are just a few of the luminaries weighing in on Davis' life and career.

Miles Davis' (simulated) voice over in this documentary is very effective, especially since his husky, raw voice (caused by an illness) is so powerful, however soft it sounds simultaneously. Like his voice, his trumpet sounds very fragile as well, but it is still so intense and powerful and gorgeous to listen to... Miles Davis' music will live on forever...this documentary let's us hear why...
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A journey through America
paul2001sw-123 March 2020
Miles Davis was one of the 20th century's great musical innovators; an icon of black America; and a difficult, deeply flawed man. This documentary uses his words (although almost no direct interview footage) and music to tell his story. Although it might sound like fairly standard fare, it's really interesting, mostly because Miles, his life and his musical journey are such good subjects; and because Miles' struggles are linked very closely to the broader history of black America. Tellingly, we do get a real sense of how his music evolved, from up-tempo bebop, through the cool beauty of his most famous tunes, to his later, genre-fusing innovations. It seems the real key to his longlasting musical relevence was his keenness to work with younger generations of musicians - although hardly a mentor in any normal sense, a remarkable cavalcade of talent passed through his various bands. But we also get a sense of his own innate talent and his personal contribution to the sound they produced. It's hard to think of any musician around today who might leave behind such an fascinating legacy.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very fine Doc on Miles Davis which serves as a Biography on film
gortx6 September 2019
Stanley Nelson's documentary MILES DAVIS: BIRTH OF THE COOL attempts to be a full biography on film. That it succeeds so well, is a testament to the long time documentarian - and to the magnificence of its subject, jazz legend Miles Davis. Nelson tells the tale in a fairly straight-forward and, largely, chronological order. From his childhood in an upper middle-class black family in Illinois to his fast rise as a teenage wonder on the trumpet to his status as one of the true pioneers of jazz. Nelson makes the wise choice of having Davis' own words 'narrate' his own story (beautifully voiced by actor Carl Lumbly). Virtually all of the music heard in the Doc is Davis' (music by other performers is specifically cited as such; too bad Nelson isn't as detailed when it comes to keeping the proper aspect ratio of existing footage). Woven through the movie is Davis' struggle against racism, which he discovers at an early age despite his family's relative wealth. While understandable in part, Davis was also prone to resentment and violence (particularly against women -- all of his relationships seem to have ended with the women leaving). Nelson doesn't shy away from the truth here, but never dwells upon it, either. Of course, the emphasis here is on Davis' music. And, what music the viewer gets to hear over the course of the (just under) two hours. Beginning with his work with Charlie Parker and others in the mid-40s, Davis was soon his own band leader and began recording with Gil Evans (a white Arranger with whom Davis would have a long simpatico relationship). Davis spent three semesters at Julliard, which showed his passion for the intense study of the musical form, dispelling the notion that everything in Davis' repertoire was improv. Davis was a master improvisational trumpet player, but, it came from an informed place (something he later tried to imbue in his fellow band members). Davis continued to perform right up to his passing in 1991 at 65. One of the things that makes COOL so satisfying is that Nelson was able to reach so many people who worked with and, loved, Davis. Everyone from French Actress Juliette Gréco to former wife Frances Taylor (who practically steals the movie with her verve and bravado) to musicians Herbie Hancock, Wayne Shorter and Ron Carter. Carlos Santana and Quincy Jones are also on hand to provide the perspectives of those who were influenced by his work. Using Davis' own words is invaluable, but, so is the input of those who were there to give another point of view. The only major quibble with Nelson's Doc is that the strict birth to death structure diminishes the kind of emotional and distinctive pull that a less rigid format would have allowed. The movie was co-produced by PBS's American Masters series, which may account for that straight-forwardness (although the sometimes very blue language will have the PBS censors with their fingers on the bleep button...a lot!). A movie about jazz should be a bit looser. Still, COOL is a terrific accomplishment; Whether one is a jazz newbie or an aficionado, one will find a lot here to that satisfies.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"He always had his own way of doing things."
classicsoncall9 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
For someone who's not really a jazz fan, I found this documentary illuminating on one of the seminal influences in that genre of music. It takes a cradle to grave approach on the life and career of Miles Davis, and is a good introductory look at a musician you may have heard of but don't know much about. To say that Davis was a complex man would be a major understatement, as the genius and creativity he had was marred by bouts of alcoholism, drug use and violence that often afflicts those of high achievement. A host of musical celebrities who knew and/or performed with Davis are seen on screen reflecting on his career, among them Quincy Jones, Carlos Santana and Herbie Hancock. Son Erin Davis also had a few things to say about his Dad, mostly complimentary in memory of the musician who consistently reinvented himself with the times. The picture is narrated by actor Carl Lumbly reading from Davis's own words, while photos and clips of Davis serve to illustrate the various chapters of his life in perfect harmony with what we see on screen. Sometimes it even looks like Davis himself is reacting to the narration of his life by virtue of still shots selected to frame the narrative. In tone and presentation, this effort is much like the 2016 film "Chasing Trane: The John Coltrane Documentary", and for jazz fans, both are well researched and informative on their respective personalities.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A decent biography, but more music talk would have been good
simonm-1731325 March 2020
A decent biography. As a younger fan I certainly learnt quite a bit. But while it is interesting to hear about Miles' personal life, relationships, addiction issues, etc I would have liked the film to balance the screen time a little more towards the music and essentially, why we are all sat here in 2020 watching a documentary about this guy - his musical genius. The most interesting parts of the film to me were where we were given insight into Miles' musical motivations, what it was like in the studio with the interview commentary from Hancock, Shorter etc. The part about Miles' improvised score for the French film 'elevator to the gallows' was great - a work of music I wasn't aware of and made me desperate to watch that film. On the other hand sad to see in a silent way given no mention - very signficant as the stepping stone to the full on fusion of brew, and an incredible album. 5 minutes of personal life stuff could certainly have given way for some discussion of the musical ideas behind that project in my opinion. Still, if you want to know more about Miles, his personality, his life story this will fill you in pretty well.
9 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Great Documentary... But SO MUCH Frances Taylor Davis Self Promotion
genious-3541320 March 2020
I get that she is his wife and could provide A LOT of insight and interesting stories and viewpoints on so many things but my God, we get it: You were attractive... lots of guys had interest in you... you danced... you had your own success. The shoe-horning in of this stuff adds nothing to the doc and I'm not sure why the filmmakers chose to include it more than just the first initial mentioning of it.
14 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Miles Davis: Birth of the Cool
Prismark1010 May 2020
Great title but not a great documentary. With Miles words spoken by actor Carl Lumbly and music performed by Miles Davis.

This should be an ideal primer for me, a person who knew of Miles Davis but not enough about his life and music.

When the first talking head appeared I knew what the problem was. There were just to many talking heads, often talking across his music. It was too conventional.

Maybe this could had been framed differently, radical like his music. I can understand hearing from his family, friends and collaborators. Not sure we needed to hear from writers and historians.

Carlos Santana stated something important about Miles Davis. He could hold a slow note, play something slow or romantic that came from within him.

It is clear that despite his talent he was not an easy man to get along with. An alcoholic, a drug addict, a wife beater. He suffered from ill health and he looked bad in his later years.

There was a nice humorous touch with a news clip of Walter Cronkite calling jazz 'musical noise' that is corrupting society.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Fine and Aesthetic Tribute To One of the Titans of the Genre
Screen_O_Genic28 May 2020
A neat and classy entry in the ongoing "American Masters" series, "Miles Davis: Birth of the Cool" is a smooth and laidback chronicle on the life and legacy of Miles Davis. Jazz's greatest chameleon and one of its groundbreakers, Davis was the innovator and progressive who took Jazz beyond tradition and trends with his boldness and skill elevating the music to new heights while taking it to new worlds that would prove influential. The documentary charts Davis' life from his privileged upbringing to the start of his music career from being a protege of luminaries like Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillepsie to being a trendsetting visionary as bandleader where he made some of the most distinguished music of the genre and became a mentor to some of the greatest names in Jazz. His personal life is also highlighted and his character is touched on, warts and all: the drugs, women, violence and the highs and lows of his tempestuous relation with his muse and the world around him. The film features interviews with fellow musicians and people who knew Davis while attractive images and films complement and they're a beaut with the fine strains and stirring melodies of the music as soundtrack. While nothing revealing or outstanding the documentary is a well-done showcase of one of Jazz's most important and talented figures. Hip, suave, complicated and talented, Miles Davis was the personification of Jazz at its most complex and compelling.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Not a canonization, but a bit more on the bumpy side--a bit.
irvingwarner28 June 2022
This was a jazz person's documentary, and I am not that. I have heard and read much about Miles Davis here and there. People like to attach themselves to famous personalities, and with Davis we see these in his diverse orbits. When he got down, they jumped off him like fleas, and when he got back up, they hopped back on. His accomplishments as a musician overwhelmed-truly this documentary established that Miles Davis was a unique force in music. The documentary showed directly if diffidently that as a father and a husband he was a flop; also, as a personality he was misanthropic, narcissistic and a materialist. The two of three wives interviewed established that about him and ironically, themselves. His last wife, Cicely Tyson, a superior artist in her own field, kept her observations to herself, and did not appear. One question not addressed in this documentary lingers with this viewer: Why did he return to the U. S. when his reception is Europe was so warm and appreciative? Other African-American artists did stay, why not Davis?
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An excellently made music documentary
Jeremy_Urquhart11 February 2021
This was a really strong and incredibly polished documentary, with only a couple of minor criticisms worth noting, such as a lot of the old footage featured being awkwardly cropped to fit the 16:9 ratio, and also (more a very personal complaint) I was a bit bummed they didn't discuss either of my two favourite Miles Davis albums (In a Silent Way and A Tribute to Jack Johnson, for the record).

I will say that by and large this is a very good documentary, though. It showcases the good and bad sides of Miles David with a strikingly objective tone, portraying him as a complex person and not shying away from the negative aspects of his life - like his addictions and the abuse in some of his relationships - while also celebrating his talents and contributions to the music world. Many documentaries about deceased artists gloss over darker times in their subject's lives, so this one deserves credit for being so honest- the documentary is all the more compelling for it, too.

Also great was the wide range of interviewees - including still living friends, ex-partners, and bandmates of Miles Davis. Then there was the great voiceover work of Carl Lumby, who narrates quotes and journal entries (I think?) written by Davis himself- a creative choice that could have been cheesy if not handled well, but it was executed fantastically here.

And the budget of the documentary helped, too. They were able to license a great deal of Miles Davis songs (ensuring the soundtrack in general was consistently excellent), and featured clips from films like Elevator to the Gallows and Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs to great effect (licensing footage from a Disney film in particular can't be cheap).

Recommended for Miles Davis fans or just fans of music in general, because I've been watching a lot of music documentaries lately and this is clearly a cut or two above your average one.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Using the talking heads option is so out of date
reginadonk1 November 2019
Without doubt Miles Davis was one of THE premier creative artists of the 20th Century. Beyond that he has also come to symbolise cool in so many ways. However, the realities of his character; his cruelness, tendency to violence, (often perpetrated against women) his serious addictions, disputes and asocial nature are well documented. Do we want to know those details, though, or do we prefer to focus on the genius, the sophisticated aura that he engendered, and forgive the artist his human failings? Well, this documentary certainly chooses to avoid delving too deep into the darker heart of the man. It purports to be revealing and exposing but it isn't. Yes, it acknowledges the wife-beating and the substance abuse but it manages to play down these as either a very small side of his complex nature, or, in the case of the drug use, blame it on external forces. (such as his joyous sojourn in Paris where he was lauded, followed on then by his return to a racist America that treats him like a dog - The film views his subsequent descent into heroin addiction as completely understandable in the face of this experience) This is how one goes about re-writing history, forgiving the often unacceptable, and creating a myth. Meanwhile, if we concentrate on the music then there is no question of his utter integrity, his dedication to the craft and his pioneering spirit. That is fine, although we never get enough lengthy excerpts here to sit back and wallow in. Instead we see and hear endless talking heads giving us their take on the man or how significant they (or they like to think they) were to him during his life. Using the talking heads option is so out of date in the wake of the new wave of celebrity docu-films. It smacks of cheap obvious TV style profiles and is simply artless and lazy. Having said that, there was so little older footage and interviews that I suspected that the makers were either denied rights to much film, of would have had to pay top dollar to use it. So, we end up with a cheap, airbrushed and empty story. Saying all that, the film has one moment of clarity: Someone comments that the cool, the aloofness, and the asocial behaviour of Miles Davis is potentially forever forgiven when we hear the emotion, the humanity and the vulnerability in his playing. If we focus on his message through his music and not his struggle with being a human being we feel the art and that dwarfs the trivia. The speaker assumes that it is this that made women fall at his feet and every guy to want to be him. This film should have been so much better.
12 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wonderful
mikeiskorn14 April 2020
A wonderful documentary about Miles Davis. Even if you're not a fan, still worth a watch. Loads of insight into his life.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Miles Davis: An Education in Jazz
leftbanker-117 April 2020
"When God punished you, it's not that you don't get what you want. You get everything you want and there's no time left."

Listeners got a lot of Miles Davis, and the world is better for it, but it's sad to think how much more we could have received from this golden goose of jazz music. I grew up hearing about Miles Davis, but I just wasn't cool enough in my youth to know his music. I had grown up listening to rock: The Beatles, Led Zeppelin, (I still can't spell that stupid name, and all rock had stupid names) and many others. This new music had almost completely usurped jazz by the time I came on the scene. It wasn't really until I felt that rock had completely run its course in about 1989 that I focused on jazz as a listener.

From the very beginning of my education in jazz, it was impossible not to hear Miles Davis, if not the trumpeter himself, then his vast influence on the jazz world since the time he started recording. I'm sure lots of casual listeners of jazz have wondered what it is about the trumpet that sets it so predominantly on center stage, although not nearly as center as the guitar in rock. I heard the best explanation for this from one of the world's preeminent masters of the instrument, Wynton Marsalis.

Someone asked Branford Marsalis why he chose to play the saxophone, and he said it was because sax players attracted the women. When his brother was asked the same question about why he plays the trumpet, Wynton answered, "Because it's the loudest instrument in the band." Miles was the proverbial squeaky wheel, and that's just how he always wanted it.

Miles was incarnated in the from of Wynton Marsalis who never has seemed to suffer from the demons Miles fought with over the course of his life. Unfortunately, Miles seems to have pushed jazz to its limit, like a country that has ultimately defined its borders. There is still always room for excellence in playing, but I don't know it there is any place else to go after a century of exploring. For me, rock & roll hit this wall in the late 1980s. It had done all it could do and started to repeat itself. This isn't to say that there still wasn't a lot of great music to be played, there just seemed to be not much in the way of innovation.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Turbulent Life Of A Musical Genius
An amazing documentary portraying the life and music of one of the greatest artistic minds of the 20th century. Great direction and use of archive footage, mixed with the legendary music of Miles Davis and interviews with people who got to know the man and the legend through all of his ups and downs. An innovator that inspired countless other artists and laid the foundation for numerous modern genres. A must see!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Uneven - High and Low Notes
daredevil_2324 February 2022
When the 3rd party commentary is running I tuned out. Why? Because of such gems as, "Bebop musicians were rocket scientists. You can compare Bebop to the Manhattan Project and it was developed by some serious sound physicists..." OMG... less inane hyperbole and more Miles in his own words and music!

The director must have known that this was the film's weakest aspect because the film alternates Miles' own words with this running commentary -- forcing the audience to endure the Garden of Gethsemane for a brief glimpse of paradise.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A gentle pass at a complicated genius
jackmilliken-9250310 February 2021
Great photos & great music. Miles was incredibly good-looking & made high art & hung out with Sartre & Picasso. No disrespect to the artist. The movie, however, is a big bow to the musician and not a bio of the man. It's a superficial sketch of an misunderstandably complicated life. Thoroughly sympathetic touches of Miles's contrary & difficult nature told by people who knew & loved him. No detractors made final cut. Some ghastly commentary from so-called experts gushing about late '40's France as a country free of American-style racism. (Paris had been a Nazi city only a few shorts years before). The movie's narrator, in the raspy voice of a Miles impersonator, was creative but also helped gloss-over the ugly drama included in artist's long, incredibly brilliant career as an angry rich kid from Julliard. Herbie Hancock, Wayne Shorter, Carlos Santana and other giants share anecdotes that are funny & interesting. Above all, the music cuts are superb. I'd rate this movie, in the context of music, as Pop
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed