Monument (I) (2018) User Reviews

A loose set of etudes

[zefciu · 3/10 · 19 June 2022]

There is no ovearching plot (the clichest of clichey excuse for an ending doesn't count). There is no consistent genre (we have a little eroticism, a little body horror, some psychological drama, some standup, and some abstract artistic cinema). The graduates of a film academy are testing their skills. But can this loose set of theatrical etudes be called a movie?

Obvious and cliche ending

[Sobertoaster-764-479561 · 1/10 · 27 August 2023]

With no real point to anything prior, everything that happens is totally inconsequential the entire film other than for the sake of a character delivering a line so the movie has some form of dialogue, or trying to film a semi artsy shot with OOOH shadows, ohhhh decrepit concrete halls and rooms, ooohh metal. Films similar have been done a hundreds of times but done better with more artistic vision, more interesting characters, more symbolism, more twists and turns. No plot whatsoever, no good character development. No likeable characters. Watch people do chores for the duration of the movie in a hotel having little boring conversations periodically while knowing "this is symbolic or something right?" with no discernable payoff or meaning. My absolute least favorite type of film, some sort of abstract allegory or metaphor piece, that doesn't even make sense, like watching a toddler trying to fit the square peg in the round hole. I don't even think it was that deep though I simply think they wanted to just do a visual style/aesthetic and fill everything else in along the way. An extremely frustrating film, but not even in a "hurts so good" type of way, there are better movies for that feeling as well.

written by people who LOVE smoking

[davidm-14 · 8/10 · 28 August 2023]

A group of students learning the hospitality industry are sent to a "learning" event center and basically forced to do everything work-related, from custodial to serving in order to pass

from the get-go, absolutely everyone smokes, wants to smoke, or is somehow kept from smoking. Maybe i'm just overly sensitive, since this a foreign film. Maybe everyone smokes now except in the US.

All the students seem tired and wrung out on the bus, before the story even takes off. What follows, after they arrive, is a bit like basic training - break them down and build them back up. There's not much in the way of horror here, but it is a well-made and engrossing film. That this is a student film made me even more impressed.

Hope you like watching hotel staff doing remedial duties

[ksgillihan · 2/10 · 8 November 2023]

I'd like to start out this review by saying uh, what? That was my entire reaction to this film. Maybe I'm just not artsy enough to understand this? Maybe I'm not cultured enough to grasp the subtle nuances of young people doing cleaning and cooking duties in a hotel and extract the overall message? I don't think so though. Usually even artsy movies have some semblance of plot or character development. This movie has neither of those. I can't even figure out what the point was. There were some very weird things that happened and I suppose they were going for something intellectual and subtle right? Even with that very, very gracious point of view I can barely even call this an actual film. It has some decent cinematography but that's about it. I think even Tarrence Malick would look at this and say "what the hell did I just watch?" If you like plots and character development, don't watch this trash.

Not worth your time

[gressman07 · 3/10 · 7 October 2023]

This is a definite skip unless you really are trying to waste about 2 hrs of your life. The reviews before pretty much sum it up, yes a movie was made and congrats to all involved. The movie is competent enough but there's nothing here that your mind isn't really protecting onto itself like a blank canvass. The opening is intriguing enough but you'll want to make friends with the fast forward button. Kudos for learning film technique etc but don't feel the need to consume an art students graduation protection and don't feel bad for it, is what it is. Anyways there's nothing that hasn't been said.

Irredeemable Dreck

[treylaford · 2/10 · 12 February 2024]

I can't believe anyone would be impressed, or entertained, much less thrilled by this depressing mess of a project. I can't even call it a film, because it has the feel of a student project, executed by the most mediocre of students. Which is precisely what this turns out to be! It's like watching an emaciated person flexing in the mirror. A person so mentally diminished by hunger, they've been convinced they are truly magnificent physical specimens. Now I know that actors are cringe people, as a general rule, but these folks are delusional. Trying to be edgy is never successful- it's either edgy, or it's not. It's a loosely jointed, plotless mess, which a group of theater geeks have lent themselves to desperately, in an attempt to "make it". I think a one star is as rare as a ten star- basically impossible (almost impressively) to attain. Yet I wavered over that nadir for longer than a moment. A nice butt shot rescued this film from the abyss- the veritable star of this show. By far the closest thing to talent any aspect of this farce was able to exhibit. Mired in the miserably depressing shadow of a world war, and subsequent Cold War, even these echoes are hollow, and meaningless. It fails to shock, amuse, or thrill, in any capacity. I hope the participants grow up enough to abhor its existence, and perhaps it will inspire them to be better. To make better career choices. To never sell yourself out completely to a terrible script- if they even had one. It is like a poorly edited batch of acting exercises was bundled into a movie length waste of life, punctuated by one of the most clichéd reveals since silent film was en vogue. Thank goodness for that really nice, prolonged derrière shot, which was the one redeeming part of this stinker. No puns intended. I guess the horror was the prospect of getting a real job- which is what this bus full of hospitality trainees are engaged in? Having a boss who is contemptible, but overall uncaring? Certainly, this is frightening to actors, who always bring up any real jobs they did prior to acting, with wry melancholy, and their most believable thousand yard stare, as though being a waiter, or working construction was the worst thing a human being could be forced to endure. Worse than prison. Worse than stage 4 cancer. Worse than a long road trip with your mother-in-law. Unless you enjoy non sequitur, after non sequitur, after non sequitur, ad infinitum. Not worth any butt shot, however impressive. Don't waste your precious time on this pretentious mess.