"Garage Sale Mysteries" Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text (TV Episode 2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
It kept our interest until the bitter end....and then you will (never) guess the obvious
Ed-Shullivan26 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Well Lori Loughlin reprises her role as special crime/homicide consultant Jennifer Shannon to the local police force. Yes of course this scenario has played out a thousands times before on both television series as well as in made for TV movies such as this one, but I must say it held mine and Mrs. Shullivan guessing until near to the bitter end.

We liked that there were a few family and friend side stories intertwined in this murder/mystery which makes for a broader family viewing audience. We also liked that there was no gratuitous blood or gore, unnecessary sex scenes or foul language to shock the audience.

Instead, actress Lori Loughlin who plays antique dealer by day and murder sleuth the rest of the time made for an interesting and light watching Saturday afternoon television movie once again. A well known country/rock band is in town to promote their new tour and album and slowly as the characters roles are slowly exposed to the audience we discover that one of the bands disgruntled and despondent members Lita Merril (played by Emily Tennant) is found hanged in her home which appears to be a straight forward suicide with a text message explaining the reason she has taken her own life. That is until the pretty female amateur sleuth detective Jennifer Shannon is invited on to the crime scene to provide her expertise analysis.

As the film rolls on the Shannon family has some challenges at home while dad is intending to proceed with the demolition of an old building but the Shannon's feisty daughter wants to preserve the building for its historical value. Also on the agenda is Jennifer's partner in the antique store Dani (played by Sarah Strange) dealing with the unexpected visit of her overly opinionated big sister Beth Anne (played by Gabrielle Miller) who rustles a few feathers with her visit.

So we do have a few side line stories mixed in with this suicide/murder who done it mystery and of course the suicide does turn into a sure fired guaranteed homicide that needs the help of amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon's unique deceptive abilities to crack open. I will say that Mrs. Shullivan and I picked a few potential murder suspects as the film progressed and I will also say that the actual murderer was a bit of a letdown as was the motive for this murder.

Overall though the film was better than your average made for TV murder mystery of the week, and so therefore I credit the film with a fairly high 8 out of 10 rating for some decent screen writing and even better acting by the entire cast for a quick made for TV film with a limited production budget and tight timeline for shooting the film I am sure.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Costume dept
suzieq12-390-5486717 March 2021
Just amused by the fact that it's snowing and freezing cold and in one scene the stars are wearing "summer" clothes! Costume what were you thinking? That said nice film.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Murder by Text
coltras3526 June 2023
Famous country singer John Dalton's concert rehearsal is stalled when the entire crew receives a suicide note from Lita, the band's bassist. After discovering that a Taser was used to immobilize her before her death, Jenn is skeptical that Lita's death was actually suicide. But by whom? Is it her estranged husband that just shows up out of the blue or one or more of the other band members? She begins her own investigation that includes a forensic pathologist and an investigator. Also, Dani's older sister Beth Ann comes to Town to Visit her.

A faked suicide that is actually murder is a well worn occurrence in mysteries with the detective pointing out why it isn't suicide, but here in this good mystery Jenn is struggling to prove it's murder except for a few signs and her instinct. It's another well done mystery, though some subplots such as Dani's sister scenes can hamper the pace a bit.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Fairly interesting mystery
jml198823 November 2019
While not my favorite in the series so far, it did keep me guessing until the end whodunit.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
OK
Jackbv1236 January 2018
The story is interesting enough. I didn't suspect the right person until very late. Actually, I think they had almost no proof, even after the arrest.

The acting doesn't seem real. The characters are shallow. To me there was one interesting quirk - Loughlin's acting at times reminding me very much of her co-star on When Calls the Heart, Pascale Hutton. Only some little snippets.
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
It's all in the how
bkoganbing14 August 2017
Some items given to Lori Loughlin for sale by rockstar Emily Tennant skyrocket in value when she's found dead of an apparent suicide. It looks like Tennant hung herself from a beam in her house.

The whole group she was part of (they look like the Mamas and Papas with a few Uncles and Aunts thrown in) is pretty devastated. Only to Loughlin does this seem like murder. She doesn't even get any help from her friendly medical examiner Jay Barzeau.

This case is all in the how because as long as the cops don't think it a homicide, but a suicide the killer is free to operate pretty much as the killer pleases. It's Loughlin that finds the clue as to how it was done and from their it's downhill.

The victim left a considerable estate and that figures into things only partially. But there's more to it than that.

The final touch for Loughlin is provided by her computer nerd son Connor Stanhope. Maybe he ought to go into partnership with mom.

I had a bit of a problem believing the cops were so dumb on this one.
10 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Suicide or murder in this music centered case.
cgvsluis20 June 2023
"Chocolate donut or bear claw?"-Dani "What happened to smoothies and kale?"-Jen "This is medicine."-Dani

Dani's judge-mental older sister Beth Anne is coming to town...and musician John Dalton's bassist and creative designer come in to Rags to Riches looking for a jacket for his local concert inviting both Jen and Dani to the pre-concert soundcheck. While at the soundcheck, the bassist texts the band her suicide note. Needless to say Jen's curiosity is piqued especially since she just dropped of some items for consignment.

Detective and friend Frank Lynnwood seems to think it is a cut and dried suicide.

Meanwhile on the home front, Hannah along with a bunch of fellow college students is protesting the tearing down of a historic Hatcher building...the big condo development project her dad Jason is working on. So, conflict on the home front!

A solid entry in this cosy mystery series with both a tight family unit and exceptional friendships.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed