The King's Case Note (2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The king of Joseon is now a Sherlock Holmes-style detective?
toskomst15 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The kings of Joseon are almost exclusively portrayed either as genuine twits or tyrant rulers who abuse their powers. The king, as played by Lee Sun-gyun in "The King's Case Note", comes off as a rather happy-go-lucky leader who acts like Sherlock Holmes and even knows a few magic tricks. Any resemblance to factual persons, living or dead, is definitely accidental.

This king, therefore, personally neutralises the threat of the usual plot to overthrow him. He does this alongside his own dr. Watson, the pie-faced eunuch Yoon (Ahn Jae-hong), who comes to the palace as a "royal historian" to keep a record of the king's movements. Yoon has a photographic memory to boot. The king calls him Obo, meaning Five Steps, because that's as far from the king as he is permitted to be. Yoon actually gets "promoted" to Sambo (Three Steps) later.

The plot, as the say, is slight. There is the obligatory old men's club of bearded conspirators who sit in darkly lit rooms, simply because, I guess, they have traditions to uphold. The main villain, played by veteran bad guy Kim Hee-won, is so evil that he even slices a maid in half simply for overhearing them. They want to replace the king to gain control of the country's trade. Or something to that affect. Yes, they're from the north. And yes, the movie does have a scene where assassins jump over the palace walls in the darkness with tom-tom- toms on the soundtrack. This is in every Korean period piece. Every single one.

The king and his eunuch remains in focus, though, and together they make this a Korean comedy that does not contain tragic melodrama. Or a love story. Or women in general. The king performs an autopsy. He even explains scientifically how a witch or shaman makes her bottles rattle (they supposedly contain human souls). The king also wants to catch a Nessie-like "ghost fish" wreaking havoc in northern rivers, which means that we get to see the king laid back on the boat with a fishing rod in his hand, to the pluck-pluck notes of a gayageum on the soundtrack. Sure sounds like a first in a period piece.

The two main characters only have to change names and professions to make this movie another instalment in the Detective K-series with Kim Myung-min and Oh Dal-soo. I liked it. It has a lighter and different approach to the material, with little violence, and no sex or nudity. And it would be kind of cool to have this guy as my king.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
a pretty solid Sherlock Holmes clone
digdog-785-71753817 May 2021
If you liked Robert Downing Jr's interpretation of Sherlock Holmes in A Game Of Shadows, then rejoice because The Kings Case Note is the same film - same characters, same tone, and a plot heavily influenced by The Hound Of The Baskerville, plus some generic "intrigue in the court" plot thrown in.

Likeable characters, occasional humor, just a touch of Wuxia, a pretty solid production values make this a welcome break from the horrible films i've been watching lately. Don't expect a masterpiece, but do expect to be amused in this comedy / mystery set in medieval Korea.

I would recommend The Kings Case Note; it's funny, not presumptuous, and while it may need a bit of trimming down, it's absolutely fine for a pleasant evening.

My vote: 7/10.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Pleasant Performances with average aesthetics
saurabhshivalkar12 March 2023
This one has a well woven screenplay and keeps the characters relevant till the climax. Carefully shows the strengths and weaknesses of characters and backed with good performance. The film however lacks a little bit on cinematic aesthetics and background score. The film feels very simply shot and emphasised more on the actors.

Additionally, the art department has make it seem very believable and the costumes are also very good. Had the film had better colour scheme, it would have been aesthetically brilliant and appealing for the audience. The king and his subject outshine everyone in the film with their performances.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great surprise
baekms5 January 2019
Loving detective movies, this Korean movie has all the ingredients for a good detective comedy. To recommend without a doubt. Waiting for a second part!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great movie
shahed-hoque26 February 2022
I am fond of Korean movies. Did not expected must by seeing the rating . It's a out of box detective movie which is under rated in my view. Thoroughly enjoyable. Great acting and humor. Highly recommend for all ages. Please watch. You are gonna like it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed