First of all, I would like to say I'm sorry. I disliked this episode. I liked almost all episodes of samurai jack, but the ending was the one I really couldn't like. This review is clearly going to be unpopular, but I decided to give my opinion anyway, because a lot of people have misconceptions about why people disliked the ending of Samurai Jack, and I want to explain it here.
First, IMO the initial 5 minutes were just filler. It felt like the story was going really lackluster. And once a fifth of the episode is over the story becomes rushed and there's no time to establish a battle between Jack and Aku. They don't really fight that much and it's just interactions between them the way I see it.
When they brought back the characters I rejoiced. The last time I saw Samurai Jack was in 2010, and back then, my favourite characters were the Spartans and the Woolies. The only part of the episode I enjoyed was when all the characters that Jack had helped came to his aid. This shows they still cared for him nonetheless and haven't forgotten the noble samurai who helped them. Jack then uses that frustrating cliché of love to save Ashi. This is very uncreative in my opinion and only added to the feeling of the episode being rushed. She then fights back and fights Aku by finding out she inherits his powers. Okay, cliché but not uncreative.
Then for some reason, she can make a time portal. I felt that this part was absolutely illogical and unimpressive. She just found out she inherited powers, and like 16 seconds later she can make a time portal? Again, adds to the rushed feeling of the episode.
She then goes through the time portal with jack and then the duo encounter past Aku. I didn't acknowledge this at first, but why did Future Aku not follow Jack and Ashi into the past? To me, that was a missed opportunity to create some awesome action scenes.
They kill past Aku and then Jack and Ashi hug. Some time later they're getting married. The scene would've been okay IF Ashi had not died. I think that Ashi was being used as a plot device for some cheap emotional grab... I felt bad for Jack, but not in the way of like 'You have to pay the price for everything, jack'. Instead I felt bad in the sense of 'He needs a break, he's been there for 50 years come on man'. Uggh, it felt invalidated. Basically, I felt that he suffered too much and he needs some reward . Just being there in spirit to me, isn't enough. I personally think the gods didn't get too involved with this season and the episodes could have been made better if the gods brought back Ashi as a reward for Jack killing Aku.
I know there are a lot of people who like the ending and although I can get where they're coming from, I really cannot see more brilliance than bile in this ending. Please don't hate because it's just an opinion. Just to make it clear, I still do respect the creator, Genndy Tartakovsky and I look forward to what he's doing in the future.
2021 Edit:
Well, it seems a lot of things have changed with time and with the new Battle Through Time ending released, I would like to update this review a little bit. This was written 4 years ago, and my views on the ending have changed slightly since then. I have rewatched the episode a week ago, after not watching it since May 2017, and looking back, some parts (like Ashi fighting Aku with her demon powers) weren't as bad as I expected them to be, but other parts (like Ashi vanishing like just before the wedding) were still as unbearable as I remembered them to be.
As much as I would like to say the Battle Through Time ending solved everything, to me, it only leaves more questions about the lore of the ending, and how Jack got Ashi back, but I don't feel like I would be able to convey my thoughts about it well over text.
Overall, I still think this is a mediocre and underwhelming finale, but I wouldn't say it is the "worst episode of the series" anymore. There are a few other episodes of Samurai Jack which I would consider worse, now that I've rewatched the series.
Thank you for reading this far into my review, and more thanks if you've read the edit and my updated thoughts on it.
14 out of 47 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink