Season 5 had a great start however after the first two or so episodes the quality started to take a dive. The current show runners managed to keep all the elements intact about HOC however this seemed to be at the expense of a chilling plot or twist later in its season and dragged on a bit. Rather than write a number of paragraphs and make this review look like a novel I will list the pros and cons in a structured manner for those who bother to read this and care.
Pros
Cons/Criticisms
Pros
- Frank Underwood/Kevin Spacey was exceptional and its probably some of the best acting we have seen from this legendary actor. It feels like he really is the president we're all watching some kind of documentary rather than a drama.
- It had some shocking and chilling moments. Frank revealed he actually had one of the ICO terrorists. Frank pushed Cathy Durant down the stairs before telling her she needs to take a fall and he resigned his presidency after winning the election.
- The show gave us a great and creative way on how the Underwoods won the election by showing a clause in the US Constitution that allowed them to get to postpone it and leave it to the house as a result of fear that they inspired. Later an election was held in only one state that led to the win after Conway appeared in a negative light.
- We saw some old favourites again like Gareth Walker and Raymond Tusk.
- Claire broke the fourth wall and did it well for her character by saying she wasn't sure how she felt about us just yet.
- Some questions were left at the end with Claire and Frank. Frank is now out of the White House and the game and Claire is left with two vultures for Advisors. What will Frank do?
Cons/Criticisms
- The election and Conway lasted too long. The show prolonged the election and Conway's stay when based on past seasons it would have been wrapped up in the first few episodes. After the quick wrap up the show would have shown us a brand new challenge and some big twists, this did not happen this season.
- The show introduced unnecessary side plots that didn't add too much to the plot. Tom Yates story lines is an example and the new reporter from the post who didn't really add much except tell Frank about Hammerschmidt. Seth Grayson making some private deal that also didn't go anywhere. A story involving Russia and China that was not interesting and didn't reveal much. Time wasted on the advisors like Usher and Davis.
- Frank and Claire on the sidelines. I felt we heard less from Frank with his monologues and him and Claire watched a number of others steal the spotlight.
- Davis and Usher. Unless they are used for some other big plot these are annoying time wasters who take time away from Frank and Claire. Davis is very unlikeable as a character and is begging to be killed off, also why was she so quickly thrown into the spotlight?
- Tom Yates. Tom Yates worked well as a character in previous seasons but clearly has no use in this season. His scenes with Claire were painful to watch and no one was interested in him and Claire expressing their love. They waited too long to kill him off.
- Frank giving up his presidency. It seemed out of character for Frank to simply resign the presidency after all the schemes and reveal that it was his plan to bring himself down. He could have confided in Claire earlier as well as there was no reason to keep her in the dark.
- Expected more from the finale. The end was somewhat predictable because we had a feeling Claire would not pardon Frank and leave him out. This end didn't seem worthy of a season finale and would have been better suited as an end to an episode. Compared to previous seasons this was not a huge finale.