Rich rescues long time buddy and former co-star Rob from a cesspool of depression and divorce papers by goading him back into the fan convention circuit.
Rob unintentionally ingests the perfect combination of over the counter drugs and alcohol, transforming him into a Casanova. Rich reconnects with a former costar he considers to be 'the one who got away.'
Rich attends a fan's hotel room party with the hopes of a happy ending. Meanwhile, Rob opts for the spa only to find himself trapped in a steam room with the eccentric, towel clad owner of the convention company (Ron Livingston).
Rob and Rich wake up to find they accidentally got married in Vegas. While Rob frantically tries to get the marriage annulled, Rich decides to take advantage of the situation instead.
Rob and Rich find themselves buying multiple photo ops with lead actors Jaden and Justin (Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki) in an attempt to pitch them a TV show idea.