"Once Upon a Time" Wish You Were Here (TV Episode 2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Wishful Thinking
hellraiser79 January 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Warning do not read unless seen episode.

I may'be in the minority on this but Season 6a was pretty bad, granted there are a few good episodes including this one but like I said few. This season just made not just the same mistakes from last season but even more mistakes than before; let alone plot holes and empty imagination enough to form a missile crater.

I'm just going to mention a few negatives. There was way too much going on, this part of the season was just crammed with so many plot lines and subplots that they just don't go together or let alone work, like adding ingredients to a smoothie that don't agree with each other, it tastes pretty bad.

And most of those plot lines that just went out the window for no reason or no good reason. Like that whole thing of a possible terrorist cell in the Lost Tales community that was just gone, let alone the whole Lost Tales community in general, just simply disappeared. This also meant that more opportunities got lost.

I'm also going to be in the minority on this but I honestly didn't ask for the evil queen back; we've been down this road twice already in Seaons 1 and 2 and we still have the flashbacks which I thought was more than enough. Sadly her return turned out to be a useless gimmick, this version of the queen was really off; all she does is frak around But worst of all kinda a mary sue villain which is not what she's suppose to be, and I hate that because it's practically cheating.

Killing off the Oricle was I felt a huge shot in the foot, because here she had a trump card where she could of keep the Oricle in captivity and get steps ahead of the Storybrooke party by utilizing her powers. There also seemed to be some plot line with the identity of the Oricle so another opportunity lost.

Alright, I've got that out. Now lets get down to the good. In a way by it's nature this is all one big standard setter but it's a good one. I really liked seeing the Evil Queen finally getting what's coming to her, lets just say deserve has a double meaning. The fact that David was the one that took her down was kinda cool because that was something different.

Though I felt the way it was handled was kinda lame and too easy. It just felt like it should of been a more clever scheme may'be "Mission Impossible" style where may'be Hook, Aladdin and Jasimine have a hand in things (which is another bad thing about the episode both have nothing to do) by running some sort of interference or David and one of them retrieves the lamp.

However the highlight was seeing both Regina and Emma in some sort of artificial reality created inadvertently by Emma's wish. It's just really interesting and kinda funny seeing Emma as a non savior. I really liked Jennifer's performance she's sort of parodies on the princess archetype.

It was also funny seeing Regina put on the Evil Queen act just to get Emma to be herself again, a moment when Emma hands over the key to the kingdom Regina just tosses it away like a bad penny. We see the princess version of Emma is pacifistic and just a bit of a wimp which makes sense because she's a princess not a savior.

But we then see the artificial/alternate Henry come in (really like the Gold Armor almost reminds of the Gold Armor from the 80's film "Excalibur") to help Emma. I thought it was really touching moment despite Regina knowing this isn't the Henry where she comes from she couldn't use her powers against him all the same because it's still Henry; Henry throws the sword but Regina doesn't resist, it wasn't until the last moment that's when Emma comes though and uses her force powers to stop the sword. Emma awakens from this because she didn't want to see Henry go down a dark path. In a way you can also say Henry once again saved the day, their love for him is what saved both of them.

We then get a plenty surprise as we see there is someone else in this world as we then see some arrows fly, I knew exactly whose arrows they were. That's right Robin Hood is back, just seeing that I couldn't help but cheer because Robin is one of my favorite characters in the show it really teed me off when he was killed in Season 5 (another negative of that season). So all I can say is welcome back Robin.

And of the course the big reveal comes in the identity of the ring wrath character. And of course it was Gideon/Morphus, I wouldn't say it was much of a surprise if you remember in the dream sequences, Gideon had the same style hooded clothing but it was gold.

Once again have a cliffhanger, hopefully season 6b will be even better I'm thinking that may'be in all three realms the Storybroke party are going to gather allies in a war against an Army of Darkness. For Regina and Emma it's more fantasy characters or alternate versions of a few, for David and Hook it would be characters in the lost tales community we haven't seen yet, and Henry and Violet would journey to the fantasy realm in a Tardis like machine and get a few familiar faces but some new faces we have yet to see like He-Man, Telia, Lion O, Jason, Thor, Balendur, Horsus, Sinbad, etc. I know big order and risk but why the hell not they need it because at this point this show could be running out of magic.

Rating: 3 stars
1 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Making wishes come true
TheLittleSongbird5 November 2018
When 'Once Upon a Time' first started, it was highly addictive and made the most of a truly great and creative premise. Really loved the idea of turning fairy tales on their heads and putting own interpretations on them and the show early on clearly had a ball. Watched it without fail everytime it came on and it was often a highlight of the week. Which was why it was sad when it ran out of ideas and lost its magic in the later seasons.

For me, Season 6 did start off very well, the first three episodes were very good to great. Did find a good deal to like about "Strange Cases" while having some serious misgivings, but other than "I'll Be Your Mirror" the rest of the first half of the sixth season disappointed. There was a real sense that the show had run out of ideas and was losing magic with a lot of predictability, repetition and recycling old ideas without putting enough of a fresh spin on it. The mid-season finale is the second best episode post-"Strange Cases" (after "I'll Be Your Mirror"), and was a decent episode without being a great one.

There are quite a lot of good things. Have nothing to complain about regarding the production values, it's beautifully shot and the production and costume design are both handsome and atmospheric without being drab or garish. The music is used cleverly and fits well, with the right amount of the haunting and the ethereal.

"Wish You Were Here" does a much better job at story advancing than most of the previous episodes, with things getting a move on and the odd answer. Especially a big reveal that was a shock to me and quite clever, though one can understand anybody who doesn't invest in it properly due to it concerning a character one hasn't got to know really. The characterisation is better here, some progression rather than going backwards and going round in circles. Love Regina and the Evil Queen's roles, two of my favourite characters on 'Once Upon a Time' and they have the right amount of angst, menace and camp without either going over-the-top. The writing has its camp and soapy moments, but is actually better than the writing in most of the post-"Strange Cases" episodes.

Am not a fan of the Gold and Belle relationship generally, find Belle a bland character and the relationship rather stale now but there is effort here to put some freshness, which was appreciated. Emma didn't frustrate or bore me as much as she has in some first-half-of-Season-6 episodes. The acting is fine, with it being very much Lana Parrilla's show and she plays both her roles to the hilt.

For all those good things, "Wish You Were Here" had its drawbacks. It is very predictable and the feeling of the show running out of ideas hasn't shaken off here, not many new ones. Didn't find myself completely grabbed by Emma's storyline, which needed more story clarity and a tighter pace.

Most of the previous Season 6 episodes suffered from being over-stuffed and rushed, it's not quite as bad in "Wish You Were Here" but still present. There is a good deal going on in a short space of time, meaning some jumping and sprawling around. None of it is hard to follow, far from it, but the episode did feel rushed in places. Was not really impressed by the abrupt ending or Robin Hood's pointless plot device role.

Overall, decent though there are far better mid-season finales on 'Once Upon a Time'. 6/10 Bethany Cox
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Chewing the scenery!
marydavis-424-61450522 October 2020
Seems the actors had a chance to just show up and break through walls due to the what the heck let's fill time with silliness script.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Stupid People don't change, evils do as they are smarter
downlds22 January 2020
Through out all the seasons, stupid people remain stupid and it's annoying. It started very well but season after season, I lost interest as people, the so called good ones, never learn. Stupid from beginning to the end on obvious things. In opposite, evil ones are smarter.

A pity. Such a good show ruined by cheap scénario as from season 5
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed