Emanuel (2019) User Reviews

Difficult--Important..

[greenhulk-62057 · 8/10 · 20 June 2019]

Emmanuel manages to tell a riveting, heartbreaking story, while successfully refraining from glorifying a killer. It is unfortunate how forgettable these tragedies can become, as society has to acclimate and recover from what seems like a new headline every month. Still, Ivie accomplished the impossible task of making the story about the victims only. Is the evil subject mentioned? Sure. But this documentary is not his documentary. This film gives the families of the fallen a chance to speak and let those distant from the tragedy have an idea of what they went through, and how large this problem truly was, and still is.

Even with a message to share, this piece is able to deliver it without preaching to the audience. Nothing feels heavy handed or over-explained. Ivie lays out the facts, then lets the viewer decide on their own what weight this issue carries. Although I left the theater with tears in my eyes, I also left with a feeling of empowerment and forgiveness -- something that was a focus of the film makers.

A Powerful Account of Forgiveness in the Midst of Violence

[mcheong-24674 · 9/10 · 6 November 2019]

Emanuel is a documentary that assembles eyewitness accounts and found footage to tell the tragic but also astonishing story of the Charleston Church Shooting.

What begins as a harrowing account of deliberate violence to stir up racial tension sets up an expectation of snowballing violence. Surprisingly the anger, hatred and rage that could have been expressed transforms into a powerful expression of forgiveness and peace.

The film has an understated tone where the facts speak powerfully for themselves. Emanuel tackles a difficult subject that the director navigates wisely and artfully. The result is an experience that is riveting to watch and profound in its meaning.

The power of faith and forgiveness

[Woodyanders · 9/10 · 11 July 2022]

On June 17, 2015 a 21-year-old white supremacist shot and killed nine African Americans in the Emanuel African Method Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina. This documentary not only focusses on the aftermath of that tragic incident, but also explores the history of Charleston and the way the community came together in a time of great need.

Director Brian Ivie astutely captures a strong and heart-wrenching feeling of terrible loss -- the eyewitness accounts are both moving and harrowing in equal measure -- as well as offers a moving and inspiring portrait of the triumph of the human spirit in the face of adversity, with love, kindness, and forgiveness winning over hatred, intolerance, and violence thanks to the firm and unshakeable faith of the good people of Charleston. A very poignant and powerful film.

The Film that 2019 Absolutely Needed

[chasemcelroy · 10/10 · 21 October 2019]

I was deeply moved by the powerful real-life story of people choosing forgiveness over hate. In a world that seems more divided than ever before, it was so beautiful to see how the people of Charleston came together after a horrific shooting. After seeing this film you can walk away with a feeling of hope as it offers a path forward. You won't regret a single minute you spend watching this documentary.

Such an important film.

[rxb-05837 · 10/10 · 20 October 2019]

This is one of the most important documentaries I've ever seen. To be honest, there are moments that are difficult to watch as it demands that you engage with the story - the brokenness of humanity and what it means to look it in the face. It's not a film you watch and forget about. It powerfully tells of one of the most wicked hate crimes in recent American history - the murder of nine African Americans by a white supremacist during a Bible study. While it dives into the historical and systematic issues at play, the film doesn't dwell on the details of the evil of that night too much. As it begins driving home it's purpose, you hear story after story directly from the victims' families about the forgiveness that this evil was met with in the midst of their grief. It's a powerful display of a costly and difficult forgiveness and the ways that it can drive out fear and produce hope. It's stories like these that remind us that evil doesn't have to have the final say.

A must watch!!

One of Life's Miracles

[pammia-637-152524 · 10/10 · 18 June 2019]

This movie took the time to venture into the internal feelings of survivors of the Emanuel 9 shooting. Since it is a documentary it is carefully edited to make important yet unforgettable points without traumatizing the viewers. It lays a historical foundation, it tells the immediate trauma faced by the daughter of a victim, tt humanizes the victims and gave their lives value it tells the story of hate inbreed and born in the shooter who seeks maximum input, it tells how trust in God and your beliefs in Jesus allows a person to forgive and forgive with the same love of Jesus Christ. it tells how what could have been the match that lit a "race war" in the USA was extinguished.

The writer and editor did an excellent job highlighting important facts without being "in your face" graphic. A soft approach to a hard core situation. I gave it a 10 because I am hypersensitive and expected to boo hoo throughout -- instead I felt the grace of God in their lives of the survivors instead. A must see.

Great film

[samantharice · 10/10 · 22 June 2019]

Loved every aspect of this film. It really shows how forgiveness can change a person and I love the stories from loved ones about the night really touched me.

A Beautiful Documentary

[mapabuslife · 10/10 · 16 June 2020]

This is one of the best documentaries that I have seen in years. An unspeakable tragedy tranformed into a story about love, hope, and forgiveness.

Powerful and moving story!

[smestrada · 10/10 · 6 December 2019]

I had the privilege of meeting and working with Brian Ivie. He is one the most down to earth, gentle, and striking storytellers I know. Emanuel will move you to think beyond politics and leave you both broken because of the past AND hopeful for the future. The true story behind the victims of the Emanuel church shooting. Not just the ones who died, but the ones that were left behind. Heartbreaking. See the movie in an intimate setting with friends you can talk openly with. So important.

The power of love!

[blakewildt · 10/10 · 3 November 2019]

I thought this doc took a horrible tragedy and told the amazing story of love that you never see in the headlines. I want to thank the victims families for opening their hearts to share an experience that was impossible to talk about and relive.

Must See

[gdk-Connecticut · 10/10 · 3 November 2019]

Emanuel is unlike most documentaries I have ever seen. The cinematography is amazing, but that's hardly the point. The true beauty of the film lies in the processing and vulnerability that we see in the hearts of the victims' families. Their authentic and convicted choices made me seriously wonder if I would have the strength to respond as they did or descend into hatred. You will not be the same after watching this. It is a must-see film for anyone who cares about faith or social justice. 10 out of 10.

Emanuel, forgive and don't forget

[Stream2BigScreen_Movie_Reviews · 8/10 · 7 January 2020]

The Stream: Only in theaters June 17 through June 19th.

The Big Screen: Heart wrenching narrative of the delicate balance of faith amidst harsh race relations.

The Final Bill: Catch this in the theater while you can, and if you miss it, you should definitely request it on a streaming service.

-S2S

I am actually very glad to be able to present a movie that is close to my soul, Emanuel. Many people remember the headlines about the Emanuel 9, but few remember the people who were truly affected. This limited release movie/documentary from some first time film producers, brings us their story. This film brings us their heart. Emanuel is going to be a movie that flies under the radar, but deserves to be in the forefront of this country's face and spiritual heart. And I'm glad celebrities such as Stephen Curry and Viola Davis had the heart to get behind this film. So, let's get to it.

Emanuel, is a deep dive into the four surviving relatives that ultimately shaped the tide of a divided country. The producers of this film did a great job of storytelling. They do a seamless job of navigating current events and feelings, history and spiritual presence. Many times films get lost in typical frameworks, but the producers challenged that narrative. This is part of the reason why I stated it is a movie/documentary. Most would clearly state this as a documentary, but the feel and parts of the beginning of this movie are artfully and cinematically done.

With that said, this movie/documentary is truly about the interviewees and the lesson this country desperately needs to learn from them. Amidst speaking about the loss of their loved ones, these people find a way to speak love, life, and forgiveness into this film. This is ultimately, the best part of the film. There are messages in this film that are needed for this country to heal and move forward. Christians/religious leaders need to be at the forefront of the healing of this country. And, putting your faith in everything good, even when it hurts, is the only message needed to get us past this cultural divide. The producers of this film gave this message a great medium.

Long story short, this movie must be seen and supported no matter where you see it. This movie evokes powerful emotions but, more importantly, powerful conversations about race relations and religious belief. In order for this country to succeed and to grow, a movie like this is necessary. Necessary to spark conversation, healing and spiritual growth. So, go see this in the theater or ask that your local theater add more showings of this film. If not, definitely support by finding this on some streaming service or requesting for it.

Outstanding!

[mrsmichellefenton · 10/10 · 20 June 2019]

Highly recommend this film to everyone! Please go see it and refer everyone!

Powerful - A Story Everyone Needs To Hear

[karinmanton · 10/10 · 3 November 2019]

Emmanuel beautifully displays the power and life that come from forgiveness to every single one of us across all levels of society. In the midst of tragedy, these families who lost loved ones open their hearts to us in order for people to see a raw, unfiltered view of what they experienced during the tragedy in Charleston. You won't walk away from this film unchanged, Ivie and his team did an incredible job!

Fantastic film

[karissacampbell · 10/10 · 13 November 2019]

This film was beautiful and real. Will make you cry and smile due to the ability of humans to forgive and love regardless of the hate that's in the world. It was fabulously directed and everyone should see it.