The Laplace's Demon (2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
"Twilight Zone", Italian Style?
gavin694220 July 2017
A glass in free fall. Have you ever thought if it is possible to calculate into how many pieces it can break into? After numerous experiments, a team of researchers succeeds in doing just this apparently impossible task. Attracted to their experiment, a mysterious professor invites the scientists in his isolated mansion to know more about their studies.

This film was intriguing before the first frame because of its name: "The Laplace's Demon". Anyone who knows philosophy or physics will recognize Laplace as a strong promoter of classic mechanics and therefore determinism. His "demon" could theoretically predict the future because all atoms move in a set pattern. Not unlike LaMettrie, his ideas strongly suggested a predictable, deterministic world was not just theory but reality. And, sure enough, this factors into the film at hand.

The concept of being able to accurately predict how many piece a glass will shatter into has some physics potential, but it has even more philosophical potential. And we see this when the scientists reach the mansion – as they have seemingly achieved a limited understanding of determinism, it is fitting that they themselves become pawns (literally) and their every move is predicted by forces unknown.

Due to the philosophical nature of the film, and its monochrome cinematography, it is being compared to the original "Twilight Zone". This is a fair comparison, and indeed it would fit in well alongside some of Rod Serling's finest scripts. But another fair comparison is to the work of Guy Maddin. Somehow we find ourselves in a rather timeless world, much like Maddin's throwbacks to Eisenstein. We know the film takes place in modern times because of the computers and such, but the look still has something of a retro or antiquated feel. The mansion itself would fit in well in a "dark house" film of the 1930s.

Going any further might risk giving too much away. The film does have some odd quirks about it, such as an Italian man named Jim Bob. Really? But all things considered, this is a great film and one that will make the brain wrinkle a little bit more than usual. "Laplace's Demon" screens July 21, 2017 at the Fantasia International Film Festival.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Atmospheric, Stylishly Italian
alisonc-121 July 2017
A group of researchers have developed a system that enables them to calculate seemingly random events, i.e., how many pieces a glass will shatter into when dropped from a table to the floor. Their studies attract the attention of a mysterious Professor, who invites them to his very remote house on top of a very steep rock in the middle of the ocean. But when they arrive, the Professor is not there, and instead he invites them to take part in an experiment of his devising. All they have to do is survive until dawn…. This is a first feature from writer/director/actor Giordano Giulivi, and it's absolutely wonderful. Montreal's FantAsia Festival 2017 was privileged to have the world premiere, complete with director and others involved at the screening; he mentioned that it took his filmmaking team 7 ½ years to make this film and it's easy to see why, given the really beautiful look of the (black and white) film, its atmospheric qualities and it's combination of incredibly detailed mechanistic movement via cogs and wheels along with the occasional pause for the actors to have a philosophical discussion about the meaning of life. Very Italian, very wonderful!
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
This makes me feel proud to be Italian!
mayamax-4276328 September 2019
I write from Italy and I do it proudly after witnessing this good Italian product. Certainly you can breathe the air of the most famous films played by Karloff in the glorious past years and this script cannot be compared to those wonderful masterpieces. Nevertheless I can say that overall the film of this film has many points in its favor: the well-represented Gothic style, the cleanliness of the images helped by CGI, the play of light and shadow and the wonderful work on sound surrounded by beautiful music. still make it a great product. The suspense is not lacking, not even the mystery and the viewer is kept with the right tension for the duration. Certainly the interpretations are not those of the American sacred monsters and some holes in writing are noted, as well as the lack of special effects. All in all my assessment of this little gem remains high and makes me feel proud to be Italian.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Surprised
j-townend16 March 2019
I must admit,I'm not a big fan of black and white movies when they don't really need to be,but on this occasion with the setting of the movie etc,it was very apt and really worked! I'm also not a big fan of reading subtitles for over 1and half hours,but I really didn't mind in this case,the movie was really well written and also acted by the Castro a very high level. I live in Yorkshire and the weather was so bad today I couldn't even leave my flat,so tried to watch numerous new movies,turned them all off,were just rubbish,then I saw this one and really didn't have much hope to be honest,but my god was I surprised,if you read this review,do yourself a favour even if like me you don't like reading subtitles,give it a shot,I did,and my word,I'm so glad I did, it was the best film I've watched since Birdbox,and believe me,I've watched plenty since then!
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Clever in more ways than one.
s_pini31 March 2024
I'd seen a review online of this movie,which I'd not heard of. It took me a while to find a copy,but I was intrigued enough to keep hunting. I will say it's not the best paced movie and there are a few moments when it feels bogged down. Although saying that,there's also enough of a mystery to make you want to watch until the end.

Some fabulous visuals,and while the acting isn't Hollywood standard, for the budget it holds it's own. The set design in the house and sounds are wonderfully foreboding, and it all ties up nicely. If you like a Ten little Indians type thriller,but with a twist,then this could be right up your street.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An amazing sci-fi, philosophical thriller/horror film from Italy.
Marquis Pierre Simon Laplace was one of the most notable French intellectual of the 18th century whose work influenced the scientific fields of mathematics, physics and astronomy. Laplace is widely known for his -almost theological- faith in the purely deterministic nature of the existing world, where an intellect capable to comprehend and analyse the position of all "items of which nature is composed" would find the future no more mysterious than the past. This is a theory that nowadays, in the light of modern approaches especially in the quantum mechanics, seems obsolete, even irrelevant, but this fact doesn't prevent it from being a totally compelling premise for an intriguing film which transcends a number of different genres such as science fiction, crime fiction, horror and others. ''Laplace's Demon'' begins when a number of young scientists are invited by a mysterious super-researcher in his mansion, literally in the middle of nowhere in order to participate in a self-invented experiment which aims to show that everything, including the diverse human behavior, can be totally predicted by a mathematical formula. When they enter the -terrifying- estate they soon realize that they were invited there in order to be killed one by one by an uknown force which takes the form of the chess piece of regina. Gradually, realizing the terrible truth behind the bizarre invitation by the shady professor, they will have to find a way to move as unpredictable as possible, thus to deconstruct and finally destroy the experiment itself. This is a movie that is shot in black and white, a fact that adds to the gloomy and grotesque feeling that permeates the story as a whole. There is also some great dialogue regarding fundamental philosophical and scientific questions about the possibility of a world where free choice is nothing more but a mere illusion, a concept created by the human need to believe that himself is the sole agent of his actions. ''Laplace's Demon'' is a film that every true cinephile should add to his collection and it is really a shame that this little masterpiece is so little-known outside the Italian frontiers. This film who also certainly appeal to the physics as well as the philosophy scholars who prefer to watch movies that truly broaden their horizons in understanding the great world, a little better. This is a solid 5/5 star rating. Not to miss!
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Well done, but underdeveloped
Rant_Bralding19 October 2023
This is one of those stories where you may end up watching to the end to see what happens, and then feel disappointed that it ended in the most obvious way possible. It's unclear whether the filmmakers endorse the fatalistic ideas of the villain, or ran out of ideas, but I found myself wishing they had embraced the randomnness and irrationality expressed by one of the other characters, rather than marching to the finish.

After a while, the core concept of the film also strains believability - it's basically the predictive science of "psychohistory" from Asimov's Foundation, but applied to individual humans - exactly the way Asimov's series speculated it wouldn't work. To give it credit, the film addresses this point, and for a little while you can almost believe it would work in this situation, but after a while, it gets silly.

The style and execution though, are totally fun. The film seems to be going for some mashup of the Twilight Zone, film noir, and maybe even surrealist films like Maya Deren's, and fully embraces the ability of modern CG to extend sets and render the darkest shadows and moodiest glimmers of light possible. The acting and camera work are both in your face, overdramatic, to what could be a campy degree, but it feels refreshingly different from our current era's conventions. While everything is clearly artificial, the rough edges never get in the way of the story.

When the credits roll, you'll see the same few names repeated over and over - maybe unnecessary, but it drives home the point of how much low budget, small crewed film making can achieve these days. I just wish they'd taken a few more risks and explored their ideas further.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
My Review Of "The Laplace's Demon"
ASouthernHorrorFan10 March 2019
The story is a smart, steady paced suspense mystery told with claustrophobic, well thought out shots that frame the contrast between light and shadow beautifully. The characters, though not completely actualized, are both intriguing and familiar characters. They are the ideal fashion of indulgent self worth and intellect one expects to find gathered at such an outlandish, and Gothic deathtrap on an island in the middle of the sea.

The writing and dialog is clever, concise banter, super smart theoretical explanatory summary, that makes the film elevated concepts approachable and comfortable for the "everyman", and is entertaining. The scenes are stunning and the special effects are so cleverly done. Not to mention that "The Laplace's Demon" utilizes, so creatively, one of the best props to create such effective moments of suspense- a dollhouse. Overall this is a great, modern day revival of classic horror.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Decent acting but dumb story.
deloudelouvain30 October 2020
First of all let me say the movie is watchable. There are some good actors present and the cinematography is decent. The black and white images add something to the dark atmosphere but personally I'm not a fan of black and white movies. We're living in the modern ages where you can film something in extreme high colored resolution on our phones so making a movie in black and white is just outdated, but that's just my opinion. The reason why I score it only a five is because of the story which is just absurd and to be honest quite ridiculous. A sliding coffin swallowing people, taking stairs like it has feet, it is just ridiculous. People making the dumbest decisions ever and being afraid of the coffin is more laughable than scary. As for the cause and effect elements in the story it's again totally ridiculous and impossible. I can't say I'm a fan of this movie like others seem to be, but everybody is entitled to their opinion.
1 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A breathtaking masterpiece
silvia-can24 February 2019
You don't need to be a fan of horror movies to appreciate this masterpiece. Give yourself some time to fully dive into this Black and White/CGI universe, then each beat, each turning point will hit you so hard that by the end of the film you'll be filled with absolute veneration for these italian filmmakers.
10 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Future generations will regard this as a Masterpiece
NoNameLegend4 January 2020
Warning: Spoilers
For me this film is singing to to the choir, as I'm a Mathematician obsessed with Chess. I wandered into this thinking it was some low-budget waste of time.

The way this film is shot is unique, and I think that the way he has portrayed the pieces influencing the unfolding drama - it's incredible, and I'm sure he'll be copied. The amount of time and effort that must have gone into this frightens me.

I can see how this is a melting pot of lots of different film influences, { Hitchcock, Argento, Bava, del Toro, etc } but at the end of the day I just really loved this film, and found it also very intellectually satisfying.

Please make more films like this!
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed