Moon Lovers: Scarlet Heart Ryeo (TV Series 2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
109 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Sweeping Romance but Love Hurts
AppleEye2U2 November 2016
This is definitely one of the best k-dramas I've seen, but be warned if you aren't used to the Korean way of story telling. There are certain clichés in every k-drama, including this one, that may look strange to you at first:

1) Love Triangle: there is always a lover who sits and watches the love of his life fall for the lead actor; 2) Extended close ups: characters stare at each other for a very long time until the music stops; 3) The Wrist grab: they have all kind of meanings like ' just stop' , 'don't go,'you're mine'; 4) Drunkeness: usually a heartbroken character trying to kill the pain inside; 5) Accidental kisses: the lovers accidentally fall or bump into each other; 6) Raining or snowing scene: probably good for dramatic and cinematic effect; 7)Secrets & Lies: the lovers hide certain facts from each other, because they don't want to hurt each others feelings, making things worse; 8)Sickness & Health: characters nurse their loved ones personally back into health; 9) The back hug or piggy back: the male gives the female a heartfelt back hug or carries her on his back, when she's injured or tired, or just to be sweet; 10) Separations: lovers have to be separated, always one of them leaves, sometimes without notice; 11)Kissing Scene shot from several camera angles: sex is only implied,never shown in k-drama, all we get is The Kiss; 12) Cliffhangers: in order to hook you every single episode.

Are you still there? Then you will be rewarded with feisty girls, pretty boy actors (flower boys), excellent cinematography, catchy music scores and sweeping stories like Moon Lovers.

The plot: During a total eclipse of the sun, a 25-year-old 21st century woman, Go Ha-jin (Lee Ji Eun), is transported back in time to Goryeo Dynasty. She wakes up in the year 941, in the body of 16-year-old Hae Soo and there, she encounters the many royal princes of the ruling family. She initially falls in love with the gentle and warm 8th Prince Wang Wook (Kang Ha Neul), and later with Wang So (Lee Joon Gi), the mutilated 4th Prince who hides his scarred face behind a mask. He's surnamed "wolf dog", because he had to fight wolves when he was still young and was treated badly as a hostage. Now he likes to foster his image as a fearsome beast. There's a fight for the throne going on. Hae Soo finds herself caught between it all. Thanks to her history lessons at school she comes to realize Wang So will win this battle finally. He'll become the future king of Goryeo, and a bloody tyrant at that. Soo loves So, but she also fears him. Can she change her lover into a better ruler in time?

The Good: The first meeting of the 'Moon Lovers', Hae Soo and Wang So, sets the tone for the whole series: old fashioned romance but a love that hurts. There's the black Wolf Prince riding his war horse, first endangering Hae Soo but saving her as well by lifting her in the saddle in front of him. Then there's the extended closeup of their faces, sitting opposite each other, bouncing up and down, having their eyes on each other while the music plays their love theme. The next scene he seems afraid of his own feelings and So drops Soo to the ground. Their love is painful, literally.

Leading man Lee Joon Gi is simply the best actor available for that kind of TV making. The minute he appears on the screen I am glued to his face and facial expressions despite his mask, that renders all kinds of emotions like joy, pain, embarrassment, hate. Notwithstanding his well performed fighting scenes, he's in danger of becoming a modern Rudolph Valentino, with female fans only. I hope he'll get the chance to proof himself in less romantic roles playing more tormented characters like the lead in Man on High Heels (2014)for example.

The Bad: Moon Lovers is a remake of the Chinese series 'Scarlet Heart' with 35 episodes. The original version could handle all the princes and their love interests. The Korean production however should have cut some story lines to flesh out the characters of Soo and So, who are the protagonists, giving them more time to develop their romance. Now we were misled thinking Wang Wook was Soo's Prince Charming. Kang Ha Neul gives a stunning performance, so it was no punishment to watch him stealing screen time from Lee Joon Gi. But the story lines became too difficult to tell, leaving plot holes until the very end. Also there are still questions unanswered: is this all about(moon)love? Or altering history? Who knows?

Nevertheless I would highly recommend this series. I was hooked for 20 episodes, hoping for a sequel.
74 out of 79 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Heart-wrenching
rondmendoza3 April 2017
I am no fan of Korean TV series but I took an exception in watching since the plot was very complicated taking a step back in time. It took me awhile to feel comfortable watching since it took a lot of effort in reading subtitles while internalizing the dialogue. But right after Episode 2, I was totally hooked. I couldn't stop with just 1 episode a night and had the craving to just watch all 20 episodes in 2 nights!! Scarlet Heart Ryeo has just begun airing in the Philippines but I have access to the original version with English subtitle, which I prefer. It was giving me a headache listening to the Tagalog translation. Besides, it was more heart-wrenching hearing their original voices. So, as a fan of the Scarlet Heart Ryeo series, I hope that a Scarlet Heart Ryeo 2 is up for an international showing SOON. It may not have been a hit in South Korea but I hope that the producers seek the comments from the international audience for an unbiased feedback.
29 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Sad but still amazing
hladnik-music1 November 2016
Warning: Spoilers
I loved this drama. The story and acting was amazing. I think all the main actors have done an amazing job. Ending is extremely sad, though. I would love to know that beforehand. I was really hoping for a happy ending, but towards the end the story was just getting worse and worse. This must be the saddest drama I've ever seen. There are some really sad events earlier in the drama, but last part is just tragic. Usually, when a drama ends like that, it makes me hate the whole story. But this one is just so good, that I still love it. Overall, the story was amazing and I love that ending was connected to the beginning. Just be prepared that it starts quite lightly, but gets darker.
22 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A 21st century woman drowns and wakes up in the body of a 10th century noble girl. She witnesses firsthand the rise of the 4th King, Gwangjong.
ricalessandrayoung17 January 2017
Lee Joon Gi delivered his role of unwanted, abused, desperate-for- love Prince very well, and IU was very natural in her expressions. Their friendship and romance were slow in developing, but blossomed beautifully when they did, leaving viewers aching for more.

They say a story is only as good its villain. Scarlet Heart has no shortage of villains, all the actors and actresses playing their roles magnificently 'til the end.

Warning: This drama is not for the weak-minded and fainthearted.

Overall: Good acting, good story, good soundtrack, good chemistry between the leads, good fight sequences, good cinematography, based on historical events (but filmed with liberty).

I was hooked from start to finish, left with just one wish... that the director and staff have mercy and finally grace us with those precious deleted scenes!
25 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Awesome drama
maraconwi2 January 2017
When I'm done watching the other korean dramas, I'm in a doubt if I should watch this one. But after I watched this, it hooked me. It's already months ago when this drama ended but I'm here, still searching updates about them and wanting to watch it again. I also watched this on a live stream and I don't understand anything what they're saying but based on their emotions, I feel that I know what's really going on. I'm even more emotional when I watched them like that.

The acting is super b! I'm very impressed to all the actors especially Lee Joon Gi, who I know is very perfect on every korean historical dramas and Kang Ha Neul, who gave me goosebumps with his acting. Also, the other actors did a great job.

The stage production and costumes will make you thought if this is a TV or a film production. 10/10 for me!

When I'm currently watching this, I'm kinda disappointed to myself because I think back then, "Why I am only watching this now? I should watched this before anything else"

That really make me regret back then lol

-

If you'll be watching this, brace yourself with a lot of emotions. You may find this a cute love story with a love triangle going on, but when the story goes on, a tragic moments happening and you may curse a lot of people when the Princes begins to battle for the throne. You'll find whose greedy and not. What they priorities most. Love or Power? Family or Love?

I hope you'll enjoy watching this bcoz I never forget this one and it will be remembered as one of the best. On all dramas I watched, they were on my top 3 list.

The ending may not as you expected as similar as the original series "Scarlet Heart" from China. But it's a good ending I think it's better that way that they didn't copy the exact ending happened on the original series.

BTW, Lee Joon Gi mentioned that it's impossible to have a season 2, who knows. Maybe a miracle happened.
20 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Simply SUPERB!!!
dragonbunny743 February 2017
Moon Lovers was my first Korean Drama, and i got addicted! It is simply SUPERB!!! The actors have a great chemistry together,and i will like to find out other movies or settings they had made before Moon Lovers! The landscapes and locations are fantastic,the battle scenes were like watching a well made action movie with great battle choreography. I was surprised from the costumes and fashion of the era that were Amazing,and most of all the plot is breathtaking! I can't hide that I cried many times over the 20 episodes i saw in just 5 days time! I recommend it to everyone,and i hope that there will be a second season!!! Please!
22 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Still crying
soeyannaing-4312717 April 2020
I can't even write a review because the body is too tired and can't move on So the only thing I want to tell is not watch is if don't have a strong heart or you will cry in every last 6 episodes OST will hunt you though they finish throughout your life
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I cried again again again and in every episode.
esrateva-2842426 January 2019
I felt the warmth of love, relations, bondings, funny moments, lots of emotions, climaxes and many heart breaking betrayal. This is by far the best historical drama for me. Omg I cried so many times. Watching this drama is an eye punishment for us..
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Keep your tissues ready...
ninchenbienchen28 June 2020
...because this k-drama sure will make you cry - A LOT.

The story is partly fiction, partly historical facts. The cast was amazingly chosen and the characters are awesome. This show contains everything from the little cutie to the wise to the misunderstood and the purely evil.

I'm not sure how I feel about the ending plus a few aspects that led to it didn't make a lot of sense in my opinion.

However, I was literally addicted to this show from the beginning until the very end.

I highly recommend this show!
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A girl travels time and attempts to change history as she falls in love with two princes of the Goryeo dynasty
me_sweety29 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I donot know how I really feel about this serial. It started off pretty well. The story line and the character development of Soo and So made sense. But I dont know if this is me but sometimes there are loopholes in Korean serials. Like characters show really exaggerated reactions to mere things which ends up changing the storyline very radically. Like Wang so's reaction to finding out that Soo had loved Wook at one point was far too exaggerated and so was Soo's unwillingless to mend their misunderstanding. I can understand why Soo wanted to leave the palace, the king was changing into the man she feared he would become, the Queen's relationship with him as well as her increasing loneliness, but still i felt that her reaction to her servants death felt a bit exaggerated.At times I also struggled with Soo's character, She was shown to be a hot headed girl who was outspoken and bold in the beginning but soon it transformed into a typical Mary sue who was everyone's savior and was flawless.I think the main fault of Soo was refusal to marry the King, In the goodness of her heart she made the first move to priortise the throne over their relationship and I think that is where the conflicts started. I also felt that there were too many questions which were left unanswered, Why had Soo timetravelled? Who was the astronomer and how did he appear in the end? Why did Wang So's mother hate him- I mean his abuse at the hands of family was an important part of the story but the cause of his mom's resentment was never explained...? The last episode also felt poorly directed with chunks and bits and pieces from the past mixing into the present. I felt that the resolution was never reached and as an audience i didnot feel satisfied with the ambigous decalaration of the king that " He will find her again" The one thing which does make this series worth watching is Joon Gi lee's acting. It is perfect. From his tranformation from a cruel warrior to that of a lover to that of a blood thirsty king, everything is perfect. In the end I would say that with better direction and better script handling this could have been a much more amazing serial. I guess a season 2 could do a better job of satisfying the audience :/
18 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An Unforgettable Drama
cierrascornerblog18 August 2022
This drama absolutely Broke me. I feel Like I will NEVER recover from this show. I Loved it, I Hated it, It Hurt, It completely Broke me But the Love was EVERYTHING. I binge watched this entire show of 20eps in one go. It left me a crying sobbing mess. I cried an ocean of tears. Let me say I went into this Drama knowing absolutely nothing . I wish I would have known beforehand that it wasn't an HEA (by MY Standards), Because then maybe I could have better prepared my heart for all this damage. ( My Drama BFF recommended it to me and ohhhhhh man I should charge her for emotional damage lol) I give it a 9/10 That cliffhanger ending just wasn't fair, I definitely needed more. This ending absolutely destroyed me and I will never be over it or forgive them for doing us this dirty. This Drama pulled so many emotions from me. And for a show to really have such a huge impact on your emotions, to bring out all these feelings an have you so immersed, it's a 10. The Love was pure and unconditional, The relationships were unlike anything I've ever come across. (these bonds were just so special) you really feel the friendship and the love that each of the princes had with HaeSoo, it was very remarkable. The Drama... The Drama was overwhelming and unmatched! The anguish left me broken beyond repair. Y'all this seriously broke me! I was not okay for days. Initially it was a show that gave me a "I can't say that I hated it but I can't say that I loved it" because it seriously put me through a $hit show of emotions. I had the biggest hangover/hangarround from this show, I couldn't get into anything for a bit. It was unforgettable, this show and these characters are just so memorable, and their love will leave a lasting impression on your heart. It's definitely a MUST watch. I highly recommend it. It's a top drama for me with a HUGE Emotional damage warning.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Would have been a complete flop without its male lead
SofiCastle23 April 2021
This show is rather poorly written, only adequately directed and quite badly acted by a bunch of young people mostly casted because of their looks. The female lead is also insipid - maybe it's the part or the director, because I've seen IU in other shows and she was good. Quite honestly, the show's only redeeming quality is its male lead, who really manages to mesmerize the audience to the point that some of them even graded the show with 10/10. Otherwise, a show full of plot holes where the colourless female lead only pays attention to the male lead in the last episodes after spending almost the whole show pining over his self righteous brother would have never been classified as "epic romance". So, congratulations to Mr. Lee JunKi, I guess.
11 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Bad ending
resvita17 November 2020
When the female lead become the victim of man ego and lust.
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Depressing but Still Thumbs Up!
fpkvbcjmj28 September 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I can write plenty of good words for this series. It was wonderfully made, cinematography, costumes, make up, effects. The actors played their parts really well, So, Jeung and Haesu made me cry few times.

The story is quite long and a lot of side stories as expected since it revolves around 7 princes and the female lead. Few plot holes and I wished the ending had been better.

And speaking of ending, for some reason it left me in a depressing disposition. Possibly because they tried to get it as close to true events, so the characters who would have made this series a happy ending are really non-existent so they had to get rid of them before the series end. Too much death and sadness. It does not give you a happy feeling after spending 20 hours watching.

However, I was glad to watch it since its highly rated and the actors are top-notch Korean artists.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This one will haunt you for days.
nishujikalal20 August 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I finished this series in 2 days and I am happy and sad at the same time. Maybe not so happy. If you are in a happy mood you will love the starting episodes but after that you will be plunged into sad and depressing mood. If you are already sad and if you want a good cry, you should definitely watch this. The portrayal of royalty and reality is so uncanny. Some people would definitely relate to the relationship and friendship part. There are lots and lots of people dying due to greed Or love, it's just heartbreaking💔😭.

I wished for a happy ending though but still, loved it.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great drama
ashwinijinu5 November 2016
Superb drama. The starting may feel entirely opposite to end. Very romantic drama. The story line is also perfect. The ending might be little different kind of sad ending but if there comes a season2 it will be good. The love scenes is very cute. The acting of all the cast is superb. I loved the part of Baekhyun as Wang Eun. Hes very cute and his acting is also very cute and emotional. All the actors are extra smart with great attitude. All the couples had great chemistry. The dressing of the actors and actress and their hairstyle is gorgeous. There were some scenes still hanging so it's better to have season2. That would make the drama perfect.

The fight scenes were also nice. I can give it a 10/10 rating.
12 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
SAD but LOVED it
maanadarvishi16 July 2019
Great story, loved it. Maybe if i knew i'll be sad in the end i wouldn't have watched it but i'm glad i did. All the actors are great. it was the first time i saw lee joon gi as an actor and i fell in love with him. He was perfect for his role. Although i'm still sad about how it ended but i guess because it was sort of bassed on the truth they couldn't do much more. Everything considered it was a great drama. it would be fun if there will be a sequel in the present time.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
10/10
dajanadae18 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Omg the acting in this one was brilliant! Even their pores were acting haha.... The story was amazing and well written. This show has only one flaw and that's the fact that they didn't do the 2 season like they did with Chinese versions so i was missing the closure for the characters. I am still crying.....
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Started as cute and lighthearted, ended as deep and heartbreaking
hyukiemoonjie10 July 2022
This has to be the most heartbreaking k-drama I've ever watched. At first, it seems very unassuming considering how the characters are usually just bickering and making jokes, until by episode 5, where everything started becoming dark. The acting performances of ALL important characters really captured my heart the most.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
MOON LOVERS-SCARLET HEART
prathyushakatta20 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Its nice .....every episode was interesting... Hea Soo role is maintainted dominantly in every episode... she in present highly disappointed at life...as the situation carries...she was fallen into deep waters..when she woke up she realises ...she is in past... later gets attached to prince's of palace.... She said no to 10th prince proposal....as she cant share her husband... when comes to Wong Soo...his marriage is highly expected with heroine.. but ...it happen with another person.... Hae Soo...no one is as before when thay had a desire for throne....(4th prince and 8th prince) at the ending heroine become the wife of another prince.... still....her love to Wong Soo never declined and think and think of him...and died in the age and becomes alive in present .... story with best dialogue in "I WONT LET U GO"....
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great Drama, Great Actors
drmartinhausberg5 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
What looked first to me as a soap opera, turned out to be a fantastic drama adding up more and more suspense from one episode to the next. The acting is just great. A lot of facial expression, a lot of gestures, only little action scenes. A great part is about how characters change for the good and for the bad throughout their lives. Many scenes are heartbreaking, if you follow the plot your emotions will be stirred up. Just the last episodes has elements in it that should have been left out since these elements distract from the overall message.

It seems that they plan on producing a second series, if so, I am definitely looking forward to the sequel.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I wish she ends with 8th prince
richardjonathan26 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
6/10 There is so many unexplained stories

But i really wish she became one with 8th prince Why he didnt help her when she protest. He could help her and became main character!

The 4th prince overreact to Hae Soo ex boyfriend is 8th prince is too much.

For god sake.. is her ex.. She is in love with 4th prince at the moment..

I love how IU acting here but the storyline made me dislike this series

I wish they will make Go Ha Jin meet with them again in present day..But the endind doesnt help her. And leave her hanging. And cried.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
The Slipperiest Time Slip!
Park_Min18 January 2024
This drama turned out to be a reverse harem in disguise. A handful of princes with varied flavors happened to meet a mentally handicapped girl to start their quest of hunting this wild female from a different timeline. All of these princes have the edgiest troubled teens behaviors with a mix of daddy/mommy issues. Out of all of them, the male lead took the edge in being the ultimate dark and mysterious bad boy, literally. Zooming out, all of this was done for a trail of pathetic emotional baits with no substance, they were begging the viewers for pity points. The moment the female lead knew about them, she approached every single one with the mentality of "I can fix him". While the princes were intentionally irrecoverably broken by the writer to serve a purpose for the female lead, she equally had her own set of problems. Within the span of a few episodes she became weirdly too attached to all of them and going even further to offer sacrifices, while neglecting her brief arrival and the fact that she was transferred to the past, but I guess shirtless bois are irresistible. The romantic entanglements in general were agonizing to tolerate, it kept you wishing the worse for all of them. Although it was bad as is, but why did they decide to make it worse with each passing episode in the second half? It's just too painful knowing the writer is making fun of us. At least the cinematography was okay and I watched it on BluRay.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This beautiful drama makes me start reading about korean history
danaadria19 June 2018
I can't give less than 10 stars. I love the script, I love the music but the more I love the Moon Lovers, Wang So and Hae Soo. Their love is so deeply
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best k-dramas ever
leylibabai5 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This is a great show you'll enjoy every second of it.

It has some cute comedy and lots of great romantic scenes at the beginning it's like a love tringle but as it goes by, they'll get serious about their feelings and what they really want. It starts with some soft and descent love of the young princes and Hae-soo and leads to their adulthood and all the challenges they face.

The chemistry between the characters and their actors and actresses is also very rewarding and it is one of the bold points of this series. And I should also say the fact that the people whom they choose for this show are well chosen and I can't think of anybody else for their roles.

This show was one of the first k-dramas that I had ever seen and by watching it I just fell in love with it.

SPOILER ALERT!!!

Although it had a really sad ending and left me depressed for days, it's worth watching.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed