"Making a Murderer" Plight of the Accused (TV Episode 2015) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Harrowing episode
i-am-so-original3 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Man, this show just keeps getting better and better.

In the third installment, now almost one third of the way through the story, Avery's ship is sinking even faster, as his nephew testifies against him, stating that he and Avery both murdered Theresa by slitting her throat, choking her, and dumping her in a pit where they shot her in the chest and head, finally killing her.

But did that really happen? Probably not. Avery's nephew was questioned earlier (off screen) stating that he had no idea what happened to Theresa and that Avery wasn't behind it. It wasn't until two detectives pulled the slow-learner out of school and planted ideas in his head in a truly infuriating moment. One detective keeps saying, "What about the head?" as the nephew continues to be baffled, until finally planting the seed (that she was shot in the head) needed to convict Avery and make sure that he is never released.

It's a truly heartbreaking scenario. Not only are these detectives pulling apart this family (the phone call between Avery and his sister was particularly painful to listen to), but they're now putting a (seemingly) innocent 16 year old boy behind bars for 20 years in exchange for his testifying against Avery. It's absolutely unbelievable that the local law enforcement would go to such harrowing extremes in order to get Avery behind bars where they believe he belongs, where their jobs and reputations are not in danger. Although, according to this show, nothing is as it seems, so I'm curious to see how this all plays out down the road. If it's true, if the detectives are actually doing this, than that is unforgivable, deplorable behaviour.

The episode's other heartbreaking scenes include Avery telling his family that he can't take it anymore (suicide?) and imploring his fiancé to tell him that she loves him and believes in him. I can't imagine the situation that Avery finds himself in, but to watch it unfold is a thing of dramatic beauty and harrowing reality.

I can't wait to see how it all turns out.

9/10
11 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Serious Bump in the Road
Hitchcoc2 January 2016
Steven is arrested. The property was available for eight days for someone to do anything they want. The key that is significant evidence wasn't noticed the first time. Now it's there. We get to meet Steven's fiancée who has problems of her own. She is really true to him, but she is obviously an alcoholic and during the brouhaha has been sitting in jail for a DUI. However, the main focus of this episode has to do with evidence that is released that a 16 year old cousin has admitted that he assisted in the murder of the young journalist after being encouraged to rape her. The consequences are devastating. What we see later is quite unsettling, however.
7 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Plight of the Accused
Michael_Elliott9 January 2016
Making a Murderer: Plight of the Accused (2015)

The third episode finds Steven Avery in jail accused of murder but some people are questioning if the police have framed him to get attention off of their scandal. While Steven is in jail the police come forward with some bombshell evidence that claims Steven had help with the murder from someone in his family.

When you finish this episode you'll have invested three hours of your time and there's no doubt that the filmmakers have your attention. This documentary is really playing out like a very good crime story because just when you think you've got something figured out something comes out of nowhere and it makes you question just about everything you had previously thought. Knowing that there are still seven one hour episodes to go just keeps you in suspense for what twists are going to follow.

Episode: A
8 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed